Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
New York-style pizzas with offbeat toppings & cocktails in a kitschy, 21+ pizza parlor setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4521 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98116
Website: http://www.supreme.bar/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Supreme Pizzeria & Bar | Order Now for Oven Fresh Pizza
Discover delicious handcrafted pizzas, salads, and sides at our locations in West Seattle and University District. Order online for fast delivery or pickup.
Supreme Dumplings | The Best Soup Dumplings in Seattle
We craft moments of joy with good food. Visit us soon for the most authentic Xiao Long Bao (Soup Dumplings) and other small bites of happiness developed by …
Supreme
… Supreme logo. Pickup Delivery. Select location. Find the nearest store. Supreme – West Seattle. 4521 California Ave SW. Seattle, WA 98116. +100 miles. Store …
Product
Reviews
Travis J
Pizza was good! I didn’t think it was open from the outside, but it’s just pretty dark inside. Server was nice. I’d definitely have some drinks here if I was drinking! I got a pepperoni and a supreme slice. The Supreme slice didn’t have much meat on it unfortunately. But the pepperoni slice was good, should gotten two. Slices are big! Not a lot of toppings for the price you pay imo. I’ll come back for sure though I wanna try that Chicago square
… moreJamie Delis
I love supreme. Been here countless times. The two dudes who work here, one with glasses and beard the other bald and kind are always awesome and thankfully I usually run into them.
Tonight was craazzyy! Thursday Feb 19th ~12:10am.
We showed up an hour before close and the lady already acted like we were bothering her. I haven’t had attitude like this from a restaurant… like, ever? She was so rude. She didn’t know what beers were on tap when I politely asked her which Rubens was on (said she got confused because of the tap at her other job at Bimbo? Ok girl), was annoyed when I told her which pizza slices I wanted, and then you expect me select a 20% tip minimum on the tablet? Naw, I’ll press that custom button, thanks.
And on top of all that, she burnt the hell out of my pizza to the point I couldn’t finish it. I couldn’t taste anything but burnt dough. I sent it back after I took attached picture. It was gross. Didn’t ask for a replacement, didn’t complain, just wanted to leave at that point.
Again, love Supreme in general and I’ll delete this review later, but just had to say something in hopes it gets some attention. I don’t ever leave bad reviews (you can check my history) but this was CRAZY.
Look, I’ve worked in the industry and I completely understand having rough days, but this was just totally unacceptable. I mean it when I say I think this is some of the just blatant, straight up, intentionally rude service I have ever had.
Hope you have a better day tomorrow, girl.
… moreTonight was craazzyy! Thursday Feb 19th ~12:10am.
We showed up an hour before close and the lady already acted like we were bothering her. I haven’t had attitude like this from a restaurant… like, ever? She was so rude. She didn’t know what beers were on tap when I politely asked her which Rubens was on (said she got confused because of the tap at her other job at Bimbo? Ok girl), was annoyed when I told her which pizza slices I wanted, and then you expect me select a 20% tip minimum on the tablet? Naw, I’ll press that custom button, thanks.
And on top of all that, she burnt the hell out of my pizza to the point I couldn’t finish it. I couldn’t taste anything but burnt dough. I sent it back after I took attached picture. It was gross. Didn’t ask for a replacement, didn’t complain, just wanted to leave at that point.
Again, love Supreme in general and I’ll delete this review later, but just had to say something in hopes it gets some attention. I don’t ever leave bad reviews (you can check my history) but this was CRAZY.
Look, I’ve worked in the industry and I completely understand having rough days, but this was just totally unacceptable. I mean it when I say I think this is some of the just blatant, straight up, intentionally rude service I have ever had.
Hope you have a better day tomorrow, girl.
Irma Miller
First time there, was confused as how to order and no one guided us. Ordered two slices of pepperoni and one of their salads to share with my husband.
Food was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
… moreFood was plenty and okay, nothing really special about it. Music was funk/rap, could be a more fun inviting place.
The two workers we encountered were not friendly. Pretty much robotic. Will probably give it another chance at some point. Maybe they were having an off day?
Alan Chung
1st time trying this place out. It’s mostly a bar. We ordered 2 slices of pizza (detroit square and supreme), salt and pepper wings, and caesar salad.
Not sure if it is because the pizza was from a warmer. It was just ok, and most of the meats are cracklely dry.
The salad was to tart that we can’t take the 3rd bite without puckering up. After we told the bartender, she asked if I had squeezed the lemon on it. Thought that was an odd thing to ask.
The wings were well cooked but again super lemony. Guess that’s just the seasoning.
The Rachel’s ginger beer (pink guava) is something I won’t consider as a good drink at $7.50!
Overall, it’s not a great experience.
… moreNot sure if it is because the pizza was from a warmer. It was just ok, and most of the meats are cracklely dry.
The salad was to tart that we can’t take the 3rd bite without puckering up. After we told the bartender, she asked if I had squeezed the lemon on it. Thought that was an odd thing to ask.
The wings were well cooked but again super lemony. Guess that’s just the seasoning.
The Rachel’s ginger beer (pink guava) is something I won’t consider as a good drink at $7.50!
Overall, it’s not a great experience.
Ashlee H
Stopped in for a couple slices tonight for the first time and was really glad we did. I had double cheese and my husband got a supreme, both really good and huge slices. The place is super chill and had the game playing. Will definitely be back to try more. The place is 21+.
… moreEddy Mendi
The amazing reviews online vs what I actually experienced makes me think most of the good reviews are written by drunk / wasted people.
Pizza was atrocious. Flopped worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese on it. Felt and tasted like the slices got reheated in a microwave. All soft and rubbery.
Person at the bar seemed friendly. Idk what the deal with the pizza was though. It was so bad I sat there for a second after holding a slice and wondered if I’d said something to offend the guy behind the counter.
No chance since I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip. Who knows these days. I chalked it up to the pizza just sucks there. Surprising, since everyone was raving about this place online.
Whole foods pizza blows this place out of the water honestly.
Typical dive bar feel, and service was normal. Food was offensive tbh.
… morePizza was atrocious. Flopped worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese on it. Felt and tasted like the slices got reheated in a microwave. All soft and rubbery.
Person at the bar seemed friendly. Idk what the deal with the pizza was though. It was so bad I sat there for a second after holding a slice and wondered if I’d said something to offend the guy behind the counter.
No chance since I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip. Who knows these days. I chalked it up to the pizza just sucks there. Surprising, since everyone was raving about this place online.
Whole foods pizza blows this place out of the water honestly.
Typical dive bar feel, and service was normal. Food was offensive tbh.
Justin Anderson
Cool bar serving not so traditional pizza with other bar food bites and pizza accompaniments. They have a pretty solid happy hour selection for beer a pizza. We went with the non-traditional “Ono” based on a review I read, but was not a big fan. Definitely liked the sauce and bread aspect of the pizza and would like to try some more of their traditional pies. The scallion garlic knots were bomb and a good table share. The wings were okay and kind of small. The place is cool and a great hang out with plenty of games and TVs for sports, though located inconveniently far from Seattle. Would be back if I’m in the area, but not sure I would go out of my way from Seattle.
… moreTori Twine
Supreme is a great value for pizza by the slice when you just want a snack. The restaurant has the old-school dive bar feel, friendly staff, and a lively atmosphere with a few TVs for sports.
… moreLindsay Bowen
This place is great. We did visit on at an off time mid afternoon on the weekend so didn’t experience a busy time, but the staff is wonderful, pies are great and beverage selection is on point. We found our new favorite spot in West Seattle.
Edit: We came back on a busy Saturday night and STILL got great service. We just feel comfortable here, the staff is awesome. This is quickly going to become one of our favorite spots.
… moreEdit: We came back on a busy Saturday night and STILL got great service. We just feel comfortable here, the staff is awesome. This is quickly going to become one of our favorite spots.
Ryan Wong
Awesome staff and full bar. Small enough to feel community and one of the pillars on the strip. For standard slices for west seattle it doe it. Overall compared to the seattle scene I would say it’s a 6.5-7/10 pizza slice. I wish there was more variety. For a standard slice I would say the crust is a little bit softer for my preference personally. Other than that it is great. For the neighborhood it rates on the higher end; for the scale of seattle overall pizza there’s room for improvement. For the average pizza consumer or after a few drinks it’s definitely on the higher end. Compared to all of seattle it get the job done and the bar staff and neighborhood takes it higher. It’s a place you can hang out with your friends with a bar. Food and variety alone could be better. Overall would go back since it is a part of the community and strip and you wouldn’t be sad or disappointed.
… more