Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 444 Borden Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224
Phone: (716) 671-2571
Website: http://brooklynfinestpizzas.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Finest Pizza – West Seneca, NY – 444 Borden Rd – Hours …
Order Hours About. 10:00 AM-9:30 PM; Shop address is 444 Borden Rd, West Seneca, NY 14043444 Borden Rd, West Seneca, NY 14043; (716) 671-2571.
Brooklyn Finest Pizza – 444 Borden Rd, West Seneca, NY 14043
Order online at one of the best restaurants in West Seneca, NY! Brooklyn Finest Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers …
Brooklyns Finest Pizza | West Seneca NY – Facebook
Bring the family, grab a pizza, and enjoy one of Buffalo’s favorite traditions. Dine-in or Takeout Call ahead to order! (716)671-2571 #buffalony # …
Reviews
Stephani B
The Best Everything! Ever since moving to Buffalo from Westchester I have searched for a pizzeria that is similar to downstate/city pizza and I have FINALLY found it. Ordered pizza, garlic knots, chicken fingers and vodka chicken dinner for football Sunday and everything was AMAZING and felt like a taste of home. After getting my Uber Eats order I called them right away in appreciation for their food. If you’re looking for incredible pizza that isn’t doughy and sweet then look no further—I promise you won’t be disappointed. Thank you again to the owner for opening a pizza place like this in Buffalo!!
… moreLiliana Mateo
If you’re chasing a slice of perfection with a side of warmth, this is the place to be. Brooklyn’s Finest Pizzeria has quickly become my go-to spot, and here’s why I’m obsessed.
The Food
Penne a la Vodka with Chicken: Absolutely fabulous. The penne is perfectly al dente, the vodka sauce is rich and creamy without being heavy, and the chicken adds a satisfying savory bite. Every forkful feels comforting and elevated at the same time.
The menu isn’t all about pizza, but the variety they offer is spot-on for a pizza joint that truly nails flavor across the board. The pasta dishes are clearly made with care, fresh ingredients, and a thoughtful touch that sets them apart.
The Experience
Friendliness and Service:The staff are amazing. From the moment you walk in, you’re treated like a regular, even if it’s your first visit. They’re attentive, never intrusive, and genuinely enthusiastic about making your meal special.
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual hangout and a welcoming dining spot. It’s the kind of place where you can pop in for a quick bite or settle in for a relaxed meal with friends.
Final Thoughts
I love this place. The combination of fabulous food—especially the penne a la vodka with chicken—and the incredible team behind the counter makes every visit a delight. If you’re in Brooklyn and craving comforting, delicious Italian-inspired favorites, do yourself a favor and check out Brooklyn’s Finest Pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed. Sammy you are the BEST! This Long Island girl is finally getting the quality of food I used to get back home!!!
… moreThe Food
Penne a la Vodka with Chicken: Absolutely fabulous. The penne is perfectly al dente, the vodka sauce is rich and creamy without being heavy, and the chicken adds a satisfying savory bite. Every forkful feels comforting and elevated at the same time.
The menu isn’t all about pizza, but the variety they offer is spot-on for a pizza joint that truly nails flavor across the board. The pasta dishes are clearly made with care, fresh ingredients, and a thoughtful touch that sets them apart.
The Experience
Friendliness and Service:The staff are amazing. From the moment you walk in, you’re treated like a regular, even if it’s your first visit. They’re attentive, never intrusive, and genuinely enthusiastic about making your meal special.
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual hangout and a welcoming dining spot. It’s the kind of place where you can pop in for a quick bite or settle in for a relaxed meal with friends.
Final Thoughts
I love this place. The combination of fabulous food—especially the penne a la vodka with chicken—and the incredible team behind the counter makes every visit a delight. If you’re in Brooklyn and craving comforting, delicious Italian-inspired favorites, do yourself a favor and check out Brooklyn’s Finest Pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed. Sammy you are the BEST! This Long Island girl is finally getting the quality of food I used to get back home!!!
Layne
This is an amazing joint. Sam cooked me the finest pies, was a great conversation, and is a MASTER at crafting pies.
I am a picky eater that is hard to please and Sam had me try a slice of his grandmother’s style of pizza. I was thoroughly satisfied.
So satisfied I had to order another pie after coming to pick up my order, right there on the spot. What a place!
Truly the most authentic NY style pie you can get out here. It compares to a few pies I’ve had out in NYC.
… moreI am a picky eater that is hard to please and Sam had me try a slice of his grandmother’s style of pizza. I was thoroughly satisfied.
So satisfied I had to order another pie after coming to pick up my order, right there on the spot. What a place!
Truly the most authentic NY style pie you can get out here. It compares to a few pies I’ve had out in NYC.
Eric Liu
Where I’m from, we lack great pizza (none of the major chains suffice). I was planning to be in West Seneca, and before I visited, I was researching pizza places and came across Brooklyn’s Finest. The pizza did NOT disappoint, it absolutely hit the spot. The crust was the best I’ve ever had. I ordered 2 slices of essential, pure cheese pizza. Wow. This was it.
This place is a must, and all the other reviews speak for themselves. A shame I don’t live close, but I made the drive for it. The locals are blessed! Thank you!
… moreThis place is a must, and all the other reviews speak for themselves. A shame I don’t live close, but I made the drive for it. The locals are blessed! Thank you!
K E O Flynn
BEST pizza in the Buffalo area. The pickle pizza, amazing! All slices tried were delicious! Def some of the best pizza enjoyed in a very long time. Will go back to try more. Incredible selection of different types by the slice. This place rivals NYC pizza… it’s just as good! Highly recommend this neighborhood gem.
… moreDaniel Ma
Best NY-Style Pizza We’ve Ever Had!
Incredible flavor with that perfect crunchy thin crust that true NY pizza lovers crave. Everything from the dough to the sauce was spot-on. Simply the best – hands down.
Highly recommended!
… moreIncredible flavor with that perfect crunchy thin crust that true NY pizza lovers crave. Everything from the dough to the sauce was spot-on. Simply the best – hands down.
Highly recommended!
Colville Outfitters
This is the Best NY/NJ style pie in Western New York. The crust has the most perfect crust and flavor. Even my daughter who hates Crust ate every last piece. The mushrooms were fat and fresh. My only critique which is personal preference is I wish they used white onions instead of red ones. The sauce had the perfect balance of zest, tang, flavor and acid. The cheese amount was perfect.
This place was so good I went 2 days in a row and both times were outstanding. The owner was there making sure the pues were in proper rotation and perfectly tossed/stretched than cooked.
This is a bit of a drive for me but you want to taste a pie that isnt covered in grease you will love this place. I can barely enjoy more than one slice of Buffalo Pizza because it makes me feel sick.
I could easily eat a half of one of their large pizzas and not feel gross. I didnt get to try it but I heard the “Grama’s” pie is out of this world. There was 2 slicea when I went in the first day but they got bought quickly. If you see a rectangle cut pie grab it and ask the owner to tell you how its made. I can’t describe the recipe but its multi step recipe I hopefully get to try next visit!
Check it out I promise your taste buds will thank you and so will your stomach. I cant vouche for anything besides plain cheese. Cheese with chicken cutlets on it and Mushroom/cheese.
… moreThis place was so good I went 2 days in a row and both times were outstanding. The owner was there making sure the pues were in proper rotation and perfectly tossed/stretched than cooked.
This is a bit of a drive for me but you want to taste a pie that isnt covered in grease you will love this place. I can barely enjoy more than one slice of Buffalo Pizza because it makes me feel sick.
I could easily eat a half of one of their large pizzas and not feel gross. I didnt get to try it but I heard the “Grama’s” pie is out of this world. There was 2 slicea when I went in the first day but they got bought quickly. If you see a rectangle cut pie grab it and ask the owner to tell you how its made. I can’t describe the recipe but its multi step recipe I hopefully get to try next visit!
Check it out I promise your taste buds will thank you and so will your stomach. I cant vouche for anything besides plain cheese. Cheese with chicken cutlets on it and Mushroom/cheese.
Blue Lagoon Pet Store
so I’ve been going here for about a year. It’s easily my favorite pizza place in WNY not only cause of the food But the people there remember you and treat you with unbelievable customer service but yesterday everything changed. I ordered my normal spinach and ricotta cheese slice and barbecue chicken slice which are absolutely amazing by themselves, but she gave me a slice of Pizza that’s called the Sicilian for free, I’m not joking it truly is The greatest slice of pizza that has ever touched my mouth in 40 years . It was so good that I actually had to cut up some of it so other people could try it. If you never tried this location, you’re missing out. Easily my favorite pizza
… moreLilah Geiger
Have lived less than 5 mins away from this place for years and just finally tried it… so good! This is definitely our new go to! Staff was super friendly and food was excellent. If you’re looking for a true NY style pizza, this is THE place. We also tried the vodka pasta and it was sooo good!! We will be back asap!
… moreAtem Amur
This is literally the best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life. I highly recommend this place. This place is a gem and worth the drive to come here. The staff are very kind and friendly and you feel so cozy eating this yummy delicious food. The best bang for the buck, portions are amazing for the prices.
… more