Marvin
Nino’s Pizza is truly a hidden gem in Hillsdale. From the moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. My girlfriend and I enjoyed the lasagna along with a few slices of their signature square pizza topped with cupping pepperoni and a drizzle of Mike’s Hot Honey. The combination of flavors was nothing short of exceptional—sweet, spicy, and savory all at once—and will definitely be a repeat order whenever we’re back in town.
The owner’s vibrant personality immediately made us feel welcome, adding to the charm of the experience. If you’re looking for authentic Italian cuisine crafted with ingredients sourced straight from Italy, Nino’s Pizza is the place to go. Delicious food, genuine hospitality, and a cozy atmosphere make it a must-visit spot in Hillsdale, New Jersey
… moreLauren S
Love this pizza shop! They have so many different types of pizza and don’t forget the apps! Every pizza is made fresh by hand which is hard to find! The staff is friendly, and the service is quick, whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout. If you’re looking for great pizza, Nino’s is the place to go. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreDmitry Naumov
Pretty good pizzeria, everything was fresh, clean and tasty. Bathroom was spotless. A lot of kids working there, so a lot of childish vibes, I guess owners kids. Overall very good.
… moreDena H.
The food here is absolutely delicious and they have many items on their menu to pick from!
I highly recommend the grandparents pizza or if you like pepperoni you can’t go wrong with that. They also have delicious crispy pizzas and white pizzas.
I loved their appetizers too, especially their fried mozzarella bites! Even their penne Ala vodka pasta was delicious!
If you’re in the area definitely check out Nino’s!
… morejessica
Just had an amazing experience at Nino’s Pizza and I’m still thinking about it ✨
First of all, the place is spotless. Seriously, one of the cleanest pizzerias I’ve ever been to. The whole vibe is warm and welcoming. You can tell they care about their customers and their food. Highly recommend their drunk grandma pie and the vodka sauce garlic knots my husband’s fav is the cheesesteak eggs rolls. Enjoy!!!!!
… moreRebecca Ferrick
We’re from Massachusetts but come to Hillsdale often. Every time we’re here we always HAVE to get Ninos. The pizza is delicious, subs are excellent (especially the drunk grandma), the vodka sauce is the best and we love their salads as they’re always super fresh. Everyone there is also so friendly and helpful. Highly recommend!
… moreRossella Scoleri
Hands down BEST pizza in New Jersey! Thank you for the incredible service, absolutely delicious food and warm family atmosphere! Will definitely be going back whenever we visit New Jersey ☺️
… moreMichael Personette
This place is a hidden gem. The pizza is always fresh, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. The staff is friendly and the service is quick. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, the quality is consistent every time. Highly recommend for anyone looking for great pizza in the area.
… moreClara Whalen
Popped into Nino’s the other day for some slices of ‘za. I’d eaten it before at local gatherings a few times but never been in the restaurant. Cute and quaint and very busy with families around dinner time. The slices were absolutely delicious and perfectly warmed up. Even got a caesar salad to share with my fiance which was perfectly dressed and some Mike’s hot honey to drizzle on the pepperoni slices. Soooo good
… moreIvy colon
An amazing pizza joint that is serving up so much more than slices! They have great wings and also some very creative pasta dishes ! Anything with vodka sauce always has my vote.
But don’t sleep on the pizza the big Roni is by far my favorite !!
… more