Marija Manojlovic
Tony’s pizza is absolutely amazing pizza shop, a true hidden gem! From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed with a warm, friendly atmosphere. The pizza is delicious-perfectly baked crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and fresh, high-quality toppings in every bite. You can really taste the care and passion that goes into making each pizza. The shop offers variety of desserts and is open late. Tony and staff members are always friendly and greet their customers with genuine enthusiasm!
… moreJ Santiago Sr.
I have tried the pizza through another person and I decided to go and try for my self. Small shop on Detroit Ave in Lakewood, Oh. Nice store front went in side and was greeted by a very friendly guy. Decor inside was nice. I had ordered a small pepperoni with beef pepperoni and it was very good. The flavors are great and my best part was the crust. I have my favorite pizza shops that I typically order all the time and it’s good to always change it up and appreciate other pizza recipes. I love pizza and always looking for that next good shop outside my home area. I recommend this pizza shop.
… moreAlex Ni
Got a Large pizza with extra cheese, 8 slices. Most New York style pizza I’ve tasted in Ohio. The boss man also recommended me the Dubai Cheesecake which was quite literally the most rich, dense, and creamy cheesecake I’ve ever had. Would go back again. Definitely on my recommended for Pizza in OH.
… moreAshley Callahan
Toni’s Pizza is the best NY style pizza I’ve found in Ohio yet! Only here for less than 6 months I’m so glad I found this hidden gem. It’s owned and operated by Toni himself and you can taste the difference in the pizza made here.
After searching for and finding the place I’d order pizza from, I placed a call and put my order in. It was quick, easy and pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I chose to pick up so I could see the location and learn more about this new pizza spot. They also offer delivery, and they are open till 4 am!!!
They even have more than just pizza! Burgers and wings are on the menu also, as well as subs. For desert lovers, the cheesecake is out of this world!
We ordered the cheesy bread and an 18″ pepperoni pizza. Prices here are great and the quality is above and beyond. First the cheesy bread was sooo tasty and their marinara paired with it just had my taste buds singing. The pepperoni pizza had me feeling like I was back in NY enjoying a slice.
So happy I stumbled across this and took a chance. Top of my list for future pizza nights!
… moreDavid O’Connor
Phenomenal hospitality and even better food! Finished up work late night and didn’t want to settle for traditional fast food. Thankfully Toni’s offered an alternative option. I didn’t have high expectations as it was a late not option, but it blew me away! Highly recommend the Toni Signature Pizza, the Wings and the brownie for desert!
… moreAshley Harris-Jackson
My daughter is a picky eater and she wanted some pizza on our way home so I just looked up pizza places that we were close to us at the time and I found this place. Nice little shop. Great prices, good sweets and there chesse pizza is good as well. We like the thin crust and the sauce you can tell that it was homemade. Just right!!
… moreP. Danielle
Went in tonight for a pizza and cheesey bread. Both were delicious, just wish the marinara sauce was warm already. The pizza had a really good thin crust. The shop looks nice and it’s very inviting. Toni was very enthusiastic about his pizza shop it seems like he takes pride in his ingredients. Will be back again to try the gyro pizza.
… moreCarl Fowkes
Wandered in without a plan because I was unexpectedly in the area for work.
Pizza was delicious. Service was great. Staff was friendly. Food was ready faster than expected. Had a small pepperoni pizza and some cheesy bread. I’ll be back next time I’m in the area.
… moreMichael Jervinsky
Boy oh Boy! First discovered this place March 2020 due to lockdown and covid. Traditional styled New York / Philly / Jersey slices. Thin, foldable, melt in your mouth, cracker like yet chewy crust. Wings phenomenal, appetizers great. Service awesome.
Fast forward 2021 of July. Hankering for a cheese steak. I’d frequent Philly regularly and grown accustomed to the working mans hoagie. Well not taking a 6 hour drive to Philly so I went searching in Cleveland. GET YOUR CHEESESTEAK HERE! Better than anything in Philly! I’m Philly it’s widely known, you get your cheese steaks from a pizza shop. Why didn’t I figure that out!?!?!
… moreJacob Weaver
Best late night pizza and wings in Cleveland! Toni is his team are top notch. I recommend the Toni’s signature and dry rub wings.
… more