Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Thursday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 8257 El Paso St, La Mesa, CA 91942
Phone: (619) 642-6274
Website: http://extraordinarybananapudding.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Extraordinary Banana Pudding: EBP
… ESC to close. Close Search. EBP. Menu. Home · Menu · Shop · Cart · Events · Our Story · Franchise · Locations · Contact us. EBP. Extraordinary FOLLOW US BANANA …
Toran Grays (@extraordinarybananapudding) · La Mesa, CA
/ No-fuss dessert shop serving one thing, Banana Pudding (with variations) @extraordinarybananapudding – La Mesa, CA (San Diego) Love stores …
Extraordinary Banana Pudding | La Mesa CA – Facebook
Tomorrow, in honor of National Banana Pudding Day, we will be offering all puddings for $5. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to try our latest flavors!
Reviews
Kevin
Unironically some of the best pudding i’ve ever had! The owner was kind and probided us with free samples of the pistachio pudding. I got the Biscoff Pudding and was utterly impresed with how GOOD it tasted! Never had pudding that made me want to get more right from the bat! Awesome small shop will come again for sure!
The Biscoff comes with two pieces but it was so good I couldn’t help digging in before taking a picture! So good would recommend 5× over!
… moreThe Biscoff comes with two pieces but it was so good I couldn’t help digging in before taking a picture! So good would recommend 5× over!
Trystan Tabingo
This establishment is absolutely amazing. There are so many tasty flavors to choose from. The flavors I personally admire are the Ube Banana, Banana bread pudding, and the standard banana pudding. The employees are very kind and helpful. Even if you’re not a huge banana pudding lover, I think it’s worth a visit .
… moreDave Fogerson
Never had banana pudding before this, but I can say, any others would be hard pressed to be better than what this shop has to offer. Absolutely delicious! We also tried the Oreo cheesecake pudding and it was equally delightful. We will definitely be back to try the other flavors!
… moreEvelyn Ohrel
This has to be some of the best banana pudding I’ve ever had. I didnt know what to expect since I had just heard about this place from tiktok, but it sure did not disappoint can’t wait to come back again
… moreAlyssa O.
LOVE THIS PLACE OMG!! This is the greatest banana pudding I’ve ever had!! Never been a fan until I tried this place absolutely worth the money. My favorite is biscoff it’s so smooth creamy & perfect amount of sugar! They have so many unique flavors to choose from go visit it’s an experience you won’t regret!
… moreDillon Hoban
I went in earlier this after wanting to try the place out for a couple years. I came at around 6pm and met the owner Toran. He gave me happy hour price on 3 different puddings AND allowed me to try some others he had available as samples. Absolutely incredible product, you can taste the love. Toran was incredibly welcoming and kind. Will be back when I’m in the area for sure!
… morePek K (Pek)
Walk past here all the time and finally decided to try it out. I got just the OG banana pudding flavor. I don’t think I’ve ever had banana pudding so I have nothing to compare it to but very good. Older gentleman running the register was super hospitable also. Definitely will be back
… moreEthan Litton
As a man from the south, being out in California makes it hard to find things that remind me of home.
This was a great reminder of home and the pudding my grandmother would make at family gatherings.
Customer service was amazing, the owner is super friendly and welcoming to his buisness. He had samples out that helped me make a decision on what I wanted.
My only critique is that the website does not have all the flavors that he had in store. Granted I dont mind since it was a nice surprise to see stuff I definitely will try my next visit.
… moreThis was a great reminder of home and the pudding my grandmother would make at family gatherings.
Customer service was amazing, the owner is super friendly and welcoming to his buisness. He had samples out that helped me make a decision on what I wanted.
My only critique is that the website does not have all the flavors that he had in store. Granted I dont mind since it was a nice surprise to see stuff I definitely will try my next visit.
Carlito Espudo
My partner had ordered a cake with the owner via Instagram, received confirmation. On the day of the agreed upon pickup, the current worker had no idea about the order, had no record of the order, and told her that the owner handles the Instagram and they had no cake for her. This was as she was on her way to the party!!!!
However, the most unbelievable part to me is that after all of this coming to light, the worker’s solution was that they could sell her banana pudding they had in stock. Full price. To make up for the owner’s mistake of never submitting the order. The owner never reached out after the fact, either.
The pudding WAS delicious, but the customer service / interaction has made this a place we would not patronize again.
… moreHowever, the most unbelievable part to me is that after all of this coming to light, the worker’s solution was that they could sell her banana pudding they had in stock. Full price. To make up for the owner’s mistake of never submitting the order. The owner never reached out after the fact, either.
The pudding WAS delicious, but the customer service / interaction has made this a place we would not patronize again.
Rhea Huff-Warner
The gentleman was super kind and helpful!
The place is very open and clean but the pudding….oh my gosh.
It’s life-changing I didn’t know that I was missing this from my life. A texture similar to a dense mousse or like a whipped pudding. Airy, pleasantly fragrant, and the perfect amount of sweetness.
Absolutely the best pudding I’ve ever had in my life.
… moreThe place is very open and clean but the pudding….oh my gosh.
It’s life-changing I didn’t know that I was missing this from my life. A texture similar to a dense mousse or like a whipped pudding. Airy, pleasantly fragrant, and the perfect amount of sweetness.
Absolutely the best pudding I’ve ever had in my life.