Heather Dolland Tamam
Citarella exists for those who want to eat well but have no desire to spend your time in the Hamptons cooking.
Although they sell fantastic fresh vegetables and fruit, and their butcher is extraordinary. The win is definitely the very wide range of prepared meals. Take it to the beach, or take it home. The only thing you have to be prepared to do is stand on a long line.
… moreMark Hannigan
No longer a fan, each year we participate in a Bicycle Fundraiser “Bike to the End for a Friend” where about 30 people ride from East Islip to Montauk to raise money to help any community member who may be in need. We purchase products when we stop at this point, but their staff does not allow anyone to use the bathrooms. We are directed to use Starbucks, which is across the street of a busy intersection.
… moremike okinov
Bought tuna salad. It is not a salad, it is tuna in a lot of mayonnaise. No vegetables at all, brand new fast food recipe. Some food is good but some is obviously prepared by inexperienced cook. Disappointment.
… moreGary L DiClementi
There are many choices of things that are pre-prepared and prepped for a variety of meals. I definitely would stop again on my way out to Montauk for something to eat.
… moreDanny Bernstein
Nicest help there.The M&M boys behind the meat department r the best, marc also at meat and fish couldn’t be any nicer and Jesus runs a solid place
… moreJohn D’Amico
Food there is really good. Service is okay. Very busy when we went grocery shopping
… moreDanila grey
Citarella is always a great choice When you need to do some grocery shopping I was such a high quality food and friendly staff
… moreTito S
Great fresh produce, delicious prepared foods, everything looks tempting. Best rugelachs!
… moreJoseph Messing
Expensive but very high quality. Great seafood and bakery departments,
… moreDennis Flanagan
The East Hampton store needs to either have their employees learn English, or hire people that can
… more