Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Silver Bay Bagels in Toms River NJ is a premier bagel shop serving delicious breakfast and lunch options. Enjoy our renowned pork roll egg and cheese, fresh lox bagels, and the popular French toast bagel. Our commitment to fresh ingredients and friendly service sets us apart, making every visit a delightful experience. With a lively atmosphere and a cozy seating area, Silver Bay Bagels is perfect for locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a meal with friends, you’ll love the warm community vibe at our beloved bagel shop. Visit us today for the best bagels in town!
Bagel-centric deli offering breakfast plates, sandwiches & coffee in a simple space with tables.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1831 Hooper Ave, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 255-8131
Website: https://www.silverbaybagelsnj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Silver Bay Bagels: Home
For over 40 years, our family has been serving up great food and warm smiles. What started as my parents’ restaurant has grown into our own little corner …
Silver Bay Bagels | Toms River NJ – Facebook
WE ARE OPEN, until further notice! Beat the cold with a BAGEL. Call for pickup at 732-255-8131 Stay off the roads and order for delivery through the Silver …
Silver Bay Bagels 1831 Hooper Avenue – Order Online
Silver Bay Bagels 1831 Hooper Avenue. 1831 Hooper Avenue, Toms River, NJ. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 1831 Hooper Avenue, Toms River, NJ. Schedule your order …
Last Updates
Reviews
Thomas Lander
Silver Bay Bagels gets 5 gold stars. Wish it was near me in Florida. The bagels are always fresh and the breakfast platters are grand was suprised that it was 3 eggs! It’s just a quaint home town vibe with a welcoming atmosphere and seems everyone knows each other. Really like the coffee nook where you get to pour your own coffee, hot or cold. Then if you get cold or you need to cool off the hot cup they have an ice machine with coffee ice ! How cool !
… moreJoey FLORIDA
Good food here by hard working people. Lots of fresh bagels. NY bagel w/ lox was great. Fresh orange juice was good. Clean place. Not too busy on Tuesday 8am, but steady flow of people in and out. I imagine they get busy weekend mornings.
… moreNicholas Nigro
cheddar habenero with BEC salt
pep ketchup.. toasted best ever
don’t be bashful, grab an iced
coffee with COFFFEE ICED CUBES
… morepep ketchup.. toasted best ever
don’t be bashful, grab an iced
coffee with COFFFEE ICED CUBES
Rob R
Silver Bay Bagels – Visit 1/26/2024
Delicious Food – Pricing on the higher end
Would I go back? – Yes
Would I Recommend? – Yes
Would I go regularly? – No, because of the prices.
Food: The food. Perfectly cooked and tasty. Every bite had flavor. If you are in the area, it is a must try.
Counter Staff: The front desk was clean, but I was distracted by the amount of non-business conversations going on with the employees. I will still state that they were polite, friendly, and courteous. The food was even delivered right to my table unexpectedly and it was quick, polite, and friendly.
Menu: I attached the current menu they had on had the day of my visit. It appears they covered the usual breakfast amenities. Menu was easy, clean to read.
Overall Experience: The bagel shop was not overcrowded, and still had a decent amount of people in it. The staff was polite, and the food was good. Definitely will be going back but not as much as I would like due to the cost. I would say try it. Enjoy pictures of the food I ordered. Thank you Silver Bay Bagels, and before you say that your prices are in-line with competitors in your area, I already checked. They are a little bit higher.
… moreDelicious Food – Pricing on the higher end
Would I go back? – Yes
Would I Recommend? – Yes
Would I go regularly? – No, because of the prices.
Food: The food. Perfectly cooked and tasty. Every bite had flavor. If you are in the area, it is a must try.
Counter Staff: The front desk was clean, but I was distracted by the amount of non-business conversations going on with the employees. I will still state that they were polite, friendly, and courteous. The food was even delivered right to my table unexpectedly and it was quick, polite, and friendly.
Menu: I attached the current menu they had on had the day of my visit. It appears they covered the usual breakfast amenities. Menu was easy, clean to read.
Overall Experience: The bagel shop was not overcrowded, and still had a decent amount of people in it. The staff was polite, and the food was good. Definitely will be going back but not as much as I would like due to the cost. I would say try it. Enjoy pictures of the food I ordered. Thank you Silver Bay Bagels, and before you say that your prices are in-line with competitors in your area, I already checked. They are a little bit higher.
Randy Ward
My first time purchasing at Silver Bay Bagels was on Thanksgiving morning. They were crazy busy and handled the traffic with ease, but luckily I had put the order in the night before.
I’m not necessarily a bagel connoisseur, but I felt the bagels were quite tasty, though a little on the thin side …which is my only negative comment. Conversely, I’ve had bagels from other stores that were overly puffy and thick, too bready and less tasty, and I couldn’t even fit them into a toaster. I find that actually less appealing.
Along with the bagels I bought an array of cream cheese spreads and whitefish salad and lox and everything was stupendous! I will be coming back ☺️
… moreI’m not necessarily a bagel connoisseur, but I felt the bagels were quite tasty, though a little on the thin side …which is my only negative comment. Conversely, I’ve had bagels from other stores that were overly puffy and thick, too bready and less tasty, and I couldn’t even fit them into a toaster. I find that actually less appealing.
Along with the bagels I bought an array of cream cheese spreads and whitefish salad and lox and everything was stupendous! I will be coming back ☺️
Samantha Shinn
What an excellent experience with silver bay bagels! I needed to order for a large catered breakfast for a work event. I was easily able to order the night before, the order was on time waiting for me when I arrived the next morning. The staff even helped me carry it to my car. Great food, great service!
… moreDan Hoffman
tried these guys via uber eats because of their really high rating on there. the high rating is well deserved. breakfast sandwiches are 10/10. bacon is tasty and crispy, eggs tasty and cooked right, cheese melty, bagel fresh. comes nice and hot, double wrapped in foil. they obviously care about their product and how it is presented and how it tastes. will ALWAYS order from these guys because you never know what low quality garbage you’re going to get from a food place these days. thank you Silver Bay Bagels.
… moreKaren Meakem
They really are the best bagels around!
The staff is amazingly pleasant, and the place is clean and cozy.
… moreThe staff is amazingly pleasant, and the place is clean and cozy.
R C
The girls at the counter are completely miserable. No one ever smiles and are just short with you. Every single time. Its not a pleasant experience going there.
… moreHovsep Kourbouchian
I was staying in Brick for the week and this place was my go to for bagels and coffee the entire trip. staff was very welcoming, kind, and food was as great. Did I mentioned they have coffee ice cubes for the ice coffee?! Total game change I recommend you try them out if you’re in the area
… more