Rebekah Laughlin
Delicious pizza, Salad, and hoagies! The service is warm and friendly. We stopped there for Saturday night dinner after seeing the snow geese on Middle Creek. The medium pizza was more like a large. Not crowded and fast service. Street parking or a lot in the back.
… moreTori Kramer
My family went here for many years but we stopped due to the shrinking portion sizes… We decided to give it another try and we realized why we stopped going. They consider this a “small” buffalo chicken cheesesteak? $7 for basically bread with buffalo sauce… they really skimp out on the meat when it comes to their cheesesteaks. Breaded mushrooms were soggy and greasy. Stromboli has good flavor but once again, a small portion. Very disappointed. Theres plenty of better pizza places in the area.
… moreValeria Russo
I have been going here for 15 years. I have known these people for half my life. They have amazing service, are friendly no matter what, and are professional. The food is always fresh and flavorful. The portions are satisfying. The staff here treats you like family. You can tell this restaurant really cares about its customers. I will definitely be coming back, P & J’s will always be my go to when I’m in the area. Highly recommended.
… moreAshley Pilozo
This Amazing Tavern and restaurant is a unique secret space, it has many outstanding homemade dishes. (highly recommended) Excellent cocktails like Lemon Drops, Manhattans, and Margaritas. Friendly, knowledgeable service and efficient. Perfect for family and friends of all ages. It’s also perfect for a casual/comfort food. With this restaurant you get the unique Sicilian flavors. This place makes it great for both locals and visitors, that want take out or even dine in. An amazing experience of a local family business!!! 10/10
… moreMichael Gerber
We ordered a cheeseburger and meatball sub and they were delicious! Clearly the bread is homemade for both and it adds so much to the flavor and texture. Also the cannoli is DELICIOUS. Like maybe the best we ever had, and clearly made fresh. I’ve had the pizza before and while it’s rock solid, for me personally the sandwiches and cannoli are the stars of the show. Also everyone is so friendly there too which is always a plus A
… moreCJ Hertzog
I’ve been coming to this place for years, ever since I was a kid. I’ve always loved their food, always loved the friendly faces and warm welcomes they give when you walk in. All the food is amazing, I’ve had Chicago’s pizza and let me say. This place wins by a landslide. Seen this business grow and grow and it’s awesome. Thank you guys for making such amazing food!
… moreFran Long
The food was delicious!!! Loved the sampler! Had family over and pizza was their request. We just moved to area so this order was first time and it will be forever time!
… moreLori Heacock
This place is so quaint, the staff is always very pleasant! If you live Tuna Salad….this place is a must….best ever! The pizza is fantastic too! I don’t think we’ve ever had anything we didn’t like!
… moreKirk Duncan
The pizza here is amazing. I got the Sicilian and I have nothing but good to say about it. The sauce was great the texture of the dough was amazing and the cheese , one of the best cheese pulls ever. The service was top-notch. I was greeted when I came in and the pizza was handed to me by the Cook with a thanks and a smile. Great experience. The atmosphere was fun and everyone there was smiling. Great place for family and friends.
… moreEric Barrall
We’ve stopped in a few times over the past year, some dine-in, some take-out. Pizza, to Dinners, to Sandwiches. This time we got a Calzone … very good, plenty enough for leftovers even, filled with plenty of the good stuff.
The owners there, VERY friendly, happy to talk about their food and what goes into it. Nothing but passion for a quality product.
Friendly service and great food!
… more