Ananya Gupta
Vegetarian review: The veggie pizza at Island Time Pub is quite good – even if it’s their own version. The crust is interesting and the sauce+toppings are flavorful. You can’t go wrong with this place, especially if you’re starving.
It can get awfully windy on the upper level as you’re fully exposed to the elements so dress warm to break the wind.
Both their sauces, white and red, are flavorful and the pizza that comes out is great. If you have Pepper Palace’s The Big Easy Hot – it will take this pizza to the next level.
… morePetra Satter
Have been coming here for 8 years & it’s always a hit! When I first moved to the island I was here about 5 days a week for happy hour, such a beautiful place to unwind after a long day at work. The view is amazing, the breeze is always perfect.
Now, the food? I’ve never had anything bad! I’ve gone through just about the entire menu at this point & absolutely love it all. The oven-baked wings are a MUST TRY. We love to get them tossed in buffalo, with mango habanero on the side. I ALWAYS order a Greek salad. It’s a good size & their house-made dressing is so good. The new burrata app has quickly become a favorite of mine too. Now, let’s talk pizzas. Our go-to is the Kig Kahuna! The Spicy Cherry Pepper pizza comes in as my 2nd favorite. Always Potterize your pizza of you like a garlic crust! Lastly, the calzones are amazing! We usually keep it simple with just some pepperoni, it is gigantic & so good.
The staff at ITP are always so great, even when it’s slammed they’re attentive & helpful. Tommy is absolutely amazing & we always hope he’s there to brighten our day!
… moreMarissa Williams
Had the Alfredo pizza and parm garlic wings. Probably the best wings I’ve had in my life.
… moreValerie Osmer
I’ve been here twice this week and haven’t had a complaint on anything I’ve had to eat or drink. The food is so good! The Salmon Poke Bowl is a must try if you’re looking for something light and fresh. The shrimp scampi pizza was perfectly cooked. The crust was crunchy, not doughy and floppy like you get in the States, and the flavors were amazing! The staff is also amazing! So friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend anyone stop in here for a bite to eat or a delicious frozen drink.
… moreNate Hartrich
We checked reviews for this restaurant and were very pleased with the result. Understand that the directions guide you to the wrong place a parking lot. This restaurant is on the second floor of a shopping plaza. It’s mainly an outdoor restaurant with a bar directly in the middle as you walk up the stairs see picture. This seems to be a local’s spot. My kids were happy there was pizza on the menu. My wife ordered the ITP DELUXE, my kids ordered the CLASSIC CHEESE PIZZA with pepperoni and I have the TUNA POKE. Everything was on point and delicious. Brian our waiter was attentive and got our orders in quickly. They share bathroom’s which were disgusting, usually if you follow my reviews you know I take away a star for bad bathrooms. This one was shared so I really couldn’t. This restaurant is a hidden gem. Check the views on my pics.
… moreJake Carpenter
Great pizza and wings. There was a little bit of a wait and I think there was a mixup in the kitchen because we waited a pretty good while for it while others after us got served, but in the end it was good food and good beer. Would go back!
… moreCassidy Louise
Awesome service and food! I meant to write our waitresses name down and completely forgot! We ordered a couple drinks and the Shrimp for an appetizer. Then we shared the Turkey Chipotle Club. Both of them were SOOO good! We ordered a pizza and again SOOO good! We are very happy that we stopped here before getting a taxi back to our resort. Definitely recommend! I believe it is all outdoor seating which we usually always choose so we were happy. Also they have amazing views there!
** We loved the Beware of Attack Redneck sign!
… moreMeg G
Pizza has fresh ingredients and not greasy at all. Greek salad is descent. The bar tenders were rude and seemed annoyed when asking for service. Overall, I will just order to go rather than dining in due to the poor customer service.
… moreTodd Wisconin B
We were looking for a place that had a view of the water, not too pricey, but still good food. This checked all those boxes. I would recommend the pizza, which is what we are. 1 large pizza- we had 4 toppings I think could feed 3 or 4 if everyone had drinks and shared an appetizer. They were out of 2 of the appetizers I wanted, but that sounded unusual.
… moreJoe Gray
Superb pizza, great combinations of toppings. The thin crust is interesting- the best of the more substantial thins ever. Service is quick and friendly. Prices reasonable. Great views, but watch out for the wind taking your paper plates and napkins! It’s overlooking the ocean after all.
… more