Founded in 1958, this local pizza chain also offers casual Italian sandwiches & entrees.
Johnathan Beck
Memory Lane in York, PA, is a delightful find! With its cozy small-town vibe, this eatery serves up phenomenal pizza and subs. The subs are delicious with a plow portions. The bread is perfectly baked, and the toppings are fresh and delicious. The friendly staff makes you feel right at home. If you’re in the area, don’t miss this gem!
… moreE C
The pizza here is awesome. The Tiramisu dessert is terrible though. They either make it in large quantities or order it in large quantities and freeze. I’ve tried it three times at completely different times of the year (March, July, & December) it was the same bland, freezer burnt stuff each time. So steer clear of the dessert here but the pizza is great! (Don’t let look of it in pic below fool you. It’s okay looking-tastes awful) I never eat inside because it looks run down, worn on the inside, dusty, & weird layout. Needs remodeled.
… moreMatthew Payne
Best pizza in York. crust is perfect and the toppings are properly portioned and tasty. Service has always been quick and nice for us. Most bad reviews look to be years old so not sure what changed but this is our go to for pizza, etc.
… moreRich German
Been by this location so many times but never stopped, but finally yesterday I did with 5 Senior Men from our Church. I am glad we did – from the moment we walked in, the gal at the Register was quite patient as she took all of our orders with different requirements, in doing so she was a treasure, kind, laid back and good looking to boot! We all ordered something different, to include sides of fries and onion rings. The Gal brought all our food out in a timely, efficient manner, all our orders were right (which means there were no whoops), fries and onion rings were cooked to perfection, there were zero complaints and the price was right. Walking out, we knew we would be going back
… moreJoseph DeVito
We stopped here late at night with a group of youth hockey players, and everything was great. The food was good, and the service was excellent — friendly, fast, and welcoming even at that hour.
… moreRay Metzger II
Fairly mid level. Nothing great, nothing terrible. Perhaps that is a good thing. Food was hot & fresh. Marinara was average, Mozzarella average (these may be house made), cheeseburger sub was eh, no seasoning… The interior & exterior were cute. If you are looking for no frill, this will do the trick.
… moreRosin C
Ordered online for pickup.
Ordered large fry, chicken fingers basket, meat lovers stromboli and the xalifornia chicken cheese steak sub.
Everything was amazing! Quality was top notch. Prices were great for the large portions. My favorite was the stromboli and fries.
The person that handed my order tk me was very friendly.
Stopped in from Pittsburgh area. Will for sure order from here again!
… moreRon Z (TheDict8or)
It looks, mostly, like a generic neighborhood joint. The friendly staff and fantastic food transcend appearances. Early evening on a Saturday, not many of us eating in, but a steady stream of pick up orders. My Stromboli was huge, perfectly prepared and delicious. The crust (the defining factor) was chewy, crispy and tasty all at once.
The staff were friendly and the right amount of attentive.
No hesitancy to urge you to support this fine restaurant.
… moreEric Miller
Wow, the staff were super welcoming and helpful! We enjoyed the black and blue pizza which was new to us. The crust is very good and not greasy at all. We will be back! Also, check out the philodendron which must be nearly as old as the restaurant.
… moreMichael Shenberger
Usually when I visit my family in York I avoid pizza at all costs because many places are subpar. However, decided to give Memory Lane a try and was very glad I did! Pizza was absolutely delicious and reasonably priced. Would highly recommend.
… more