Daytime diner serving homestyle breakfasts & lunches in retro, 1950s-style digs with outdoor seats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: W 8th St, Barnegat Light, NJ 08006
Phone: (609) 494-0155
Website: http://mustachebills.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mustache Bill’s Diner
Check in with our host upon arrival to be seated in our classic dining car or enclosed patio and we’ll add you to the wait list.
Mustache Bill’s diner in Barnegat Light closed – Facebook
SOMEONE PLZ BUY & SAVE this James Beard Foundation #RegionalClassic Winner on #LBI in #NJ! Have several million dollars lying around?
MENU – Mustache Bill’s
VIEW OUR NEW MENU. Click below to view all 3 Pages. Download PDF. Loading files. 1/3. Next. Copyright © 2020 Mustache Bill’s – All Rights Reserved.
Reviews
Sean Hyde
The classic Jersey Shore diner experience. Been going here since I was a kid and now I’m bringing my wife and kids. Everybody loved their food and the cool lobster design in the kids pancakes were a big hit. Always great, friendly service here, fun old school diner ambience, and really solid Jersey diner food.
… moreRocky R.
3.5 Stars. Took a day trip with friends. It was raining so we went here to wait for the sky to clear so we can go out with our boats. Food was okay. Basic. Nothing Special. Foodwise.. hust don’t expect anything much. Service was very good though. Very attentive. All the servers were nice.
… moreTyler Aviles
Miss this place . Best shrimp and grits I ever had. Would kill for the recipe. If the owner / chef sees this please send me the recipe
… moreNatalia Spinelli
CASH ONLY. For a diner this place is fantastic!!! The food is fresh! The service is great! Clean! Open for dine inside or outside. Their omelets are wonderful. Our favorite was the liverwurst & onion sandwich! Second best was the potato skin omelette. My son loved the fried clam platter (I thought they were a little chewy). Thumbs up to this place. One of the best diners we have been to with regard to the food!
… moreAlexa Quinn
Mustache Bill’s has been a favorite of our family for decades. It’s a classic New Jersey diner experience and important part of Barnegat Light. We especially love Amy, our usual server, who has memorized our family’s order and is always so kind. We hope Mustache Bill’s will be around for a long time when it’s time for a new generation of folks (like Amy) to run it!
… moreLisa S
I could only give this place three stars just based on the good service. The staff is extremely friendly and welcoming. The prices are very reasonable. The food on the other hand is a different story. After reading so many rave reviews about this place (which I don’t know why) I had to check this place out before going to the Barnegat Lighthouse. I got an omelet with home fries. Now being from Brooklyn, NY I know how home fries are supposed to look and taste. These home fries tasted like boiled potatoes with a sprinkle of paprika for color. These potatoes were definitely not fried or baked. No salt. No pepper. No onions. No flavor. The omelet was decent. The spinach that was in the omelet tasted like it came from a can, which I was kind of bummed because I love fresh spinach in my eggs. The best thing on the plate (or paper plate that is) was the toast. The overall appearance of this place had a 1950’s look that needs an upgrade. Would I come here again if I am ever in the area? Maybe not.
… moreVicky Lee
Fun, cozy diner with fabulous food! Although the menu would be considered “typical American breakfast”, the quality of the cooking & food is unsurpassed. The flavor of their grits was heavenly as were the english muffins and everything here is done to perfection! Fun, friendly servers and a must-visit while on LBI! Go early to avoid wait times. Cash only. 5-stars across the board!
… morePriya S
Pancakes are undoubtedly the best on the island and quite possibly the best I’ve ever had. Everything is made fresh to order. Eggs are always cooked perfectly. You won’t find a better breakfast on LBI.
That all being said, this place gets VERY busy. Like there will be people waiting outside from 9am-noon busy. There is almost always a wait. I would recommend calling ahead of time and seeing if you can get put on the waitlist if you plan on eating there. Also cash only.
… moreThat all being said, this place gets VERY busy. Like there will be people waiting outside from 9am-noon busy. There is almost always a wait. I would recommend calling ahead of time and seeing if you can get put on the waitlist if you plan on eating there. Also cash only.
Matt O’Shea
I haven’t been to this diner in a while, but I recall really liking the Irish coffee. If this Irish coffee is still being served, what is the name of it and can it be purchased retail? Thanks,
… moreMichael Dannemiller
My first time at Mustache Bill’s Diner – the food, service and prices were all better than I’d expected at such a convenient place.
… more