Dan Lucian Ilie
A straight 5 shooter place with no questions about it.
Lobster roll was great, lobster bisque was amaizing, calamar steak was wonderful.
Place is packed, you don’t need booking ahead, prices are reasonable, service is fast and efficient, there is nothing wrong about this place except the bathrooms: restaurant is located in the Market so going to restroom will be a small trip and one floor to climb.
… moreAlyssa Clark
Came here for my birthday! We had a reservation, but since it was so busy we still had to wait 20-30 minutes. I got a mule to start, which was very good. Started off with the calamari which I have to say is some of the best calamari I’ve had because of the breading. You can’t find the types of oysters on the regular menu, there are slips of paper with the oyster types, their descriptions and prices at the table. You write the quantity of each oyster you want and any sides. The others that I was with aren’t a fan of oysters, so I had five to myself. I had two of the classic Blue Point oysters, one of the Irish Point, and two of the Salty Mainer oysters. All the oysters were great! The Irish Point were crisp tasting and the Salty Mainer’s were indeed a little salty. For an entree I got the Maine Lobster Roll. The bun was nicely toasted and buttered, the lobster was fresh and had a great taste to it. I always love a good coleslaw & fry too. Great experience, great food, I will be back!
… moreJoshua Valdivia
First time trying visiting the St. Paul Fish Company in the historic Third Ward. During our visit, we had the lobster roll meal and a cup of lobster bisque. The bisque had pieces of the shell in the soup, so we ate with caution. There are bits of meat in the soup, so it wasn’t the traditional bisque you’d expect, and would have benefitted from being smoother. Overall, I would say it was decent but forgettable.
The lobster roll was good; the bread, fries, and coleslaw were all fantastic. I will say the lobster filling was very dry, and it made it hard to eat the roll. It would have been great to top the roll with some liquid butter or just add more dressing to the roll. The staff was attentive but seemed overwhelmed during our visit, which could have been improved.
… moreChadwick Domack
We stopped into the Public Market for the first time, and wanted to grab some food. We stopped here to check out the menu. The Food seemed reasonably priced, and our wait time wasn’t that long. Our server was very nice, and attentive. The food was good for portion size and flavor. We sat in the dinning table area, and not the bar after seeing the bartender reviews.
… moreMornNYtester
Fish smells fishy….. everything ordinary.Only staff so good when he was so busy.
… moreKathryn O’Donnell
This place was supposedly slow, when I took the last seat at the bar. It is definitely in the mix and a destination spot. The bartenders were all wonderful. I ordered the lobster roll and then the recommended calamari steak. Everything was delicious. The pina colada with rum float was also perfect in every way. Dogs are welcome.
… moreJessica Arenas
I had the White Fish Sole Piccata and it was absolutely incredible! The flavors were so fresh, light, yet filling—truly a must-have if you’re looking for something that tastes both comforting and refined. Everything was perfectly prepared, and you can really tell the quality of the ingredients. Highly recommend this dish if you want something fresh and satisfying. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreThe Borg Cooking Show
The Margarita’s are great and strong. The bar is usually too crowded, to get a seat with personally space but the atmosphere is great. Its like a small tiki oasis in the concrete jungle.
You just have to put up with the bartenders’ personalities while sipping on some mai tais
… moreNathan Matheney
Had the fried perch one night and well.. flavorless.. and a few bones. Next night I had the blackened grouper and bingo! Great flavor and was very enjoyable. Get the fruit salsa with it. Service was good. Worth the visit.
… moreTanya Stefanova
Visiting The Historic Third Ward at Milwaukee Public Market. Found the seafood place Sr Paul Fish Co. Ordered East Coast Crab Roll sandwich and it was delicious. Fresh food and generous sizing.
… more