4.7 – 75 reviews • Pizza restaurant
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Yo Pauly’s New York Pizza Co. | Welcome
Somethin’ To Munch On · Old School Garlic Knots — (6) $3.50 (12) $5.99 · Totally Cheesy Knots — (6) $4.99 (12) $8.99 · Manhattan Meatballs — $7.50 · Fried Rav’s — ( …
Reviews
Steve Parrish
Man, I love this place! I went three days in a row last week and have loved everything. Started with a slice/salad/drink. A bigger than expected salad and delicious pizza…perfect crust. My coworkers had the same and were both impressed.
Came back solo the second day for the baked ziti…it tasted homemade…DELICIOUS! Probably the best I’ve ever had, if I’m being honest…and this is coming from a guy born in Italy who’s mom learned to cook from the Italians.
Returned the following day (with another coworker) to try one of those huge Italian sandwiches that floated by my table on the first visit. Another home run!
Yo Pauly’s will definitely be in my weekly lunchtime rotation going forward. Keep doing what you’re doing and don’t change a thing!
Edit: Came back with my wife for the wings and a calzone. Both were excellent!
… moreRyan Nia
This place genuinely makes a running for the best NY pizza in the valley. If you want to try genuinely good pizza with exceptional service and hospitality, I’d recommend trying Yo Pauly’s. You absolutely won’t be disappointed. Their Scottsdale location is incredible, and I’m so happy to see they opened a second location that’s closer to me! Also, their wings are underrated and in my opinion are some of the best out here. And definitely get some garlic knots on the side. Highly recommend!
… moreSabrina Yasso
We came in for the grand opening and everything was exceptional. The food, the service. Absolutely amazing. Would recommend to all my family and friends!! You’ve gained a regular!
… moreAndrew Hirning
My Calzone took longer than the pizza but we’ll worth the wait. The atmosphere was straight out of New York and food was amazing! There really isn’t reason to go anywhere else in my opinion.
… moreJ Anderson
Happy to see they have so much more besides pizza on the menu (though I will be trying their pizza soon!). We had stromboli and spaghetti and it was delicious. Friendly service, and a lot of food for the price. Will definitely be back!
… moreChris Phillips
Awesome NY style pizza. Fold it and let the grease run lol. Growing up in Philly this is the closest to home that I’ve found so far out here.
… moreMatt Hudson
They were swamped for the grand opening but did a nice job handling the rush. And the most important thing outside of the outstanding and friendly service, the pizza is a 10/10. As an east coaster(Philly) I always complain about Arizona pizza and unable to find good crust. This is hands down no questions asked not even a close competition THE BEST New York pizza in Arizona. 10/10 and definitely will be back! Wyatt is a great dude as well
… moreDavid Paul
Very nice, very Italian restaurant tucked away in a strip mall. The food was exceptional, we had a pizza and drinks. Service was great, the atmosphere was very nice. Prices are good and well worth the drive no matter where you’re coming from.
… moreMatt Powers
Excellent NYC style pizza with super friendly staff. Got some slices on their opening weekend and they were great. It was super busy but the staff made sure everyone was taken care of. Will def be back wanna try their stromboli and Chicken parm sandwich.
… moreChristofer Gendreau
I guess I’m in the minority. My first time trying this place and it sure didn’t live up to the hype.
The pizza was underwhelming. It’s good enough pizza, but certainly didn’t live up to the hype. Considering the hype and the price I expected better.
Next, there is no way to order online. Unless you want to pay up for a delivery service you actually have to call in to order (welcome to the 90s!). I called in and waited on hold for almost 15 minutes then was disconnected. I called back and got someone after another short hold. Surprised because when I picked up the pizza they weren’t busy at all.
Considering it’s so close to me I may try some of their other food, but this definitely isn’t the best pizza in the valley as I’ve read and heard. It’s not bad, but not great.
… more … View more