Eric Krempa
As someone who orders a cheesesteak pretty much everywhere I go, I can easily say this is top 3 for the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever had. Absolutely competes with Angelo’s and Lilo’s without question. A massive amount of seasoned meat, smothered in cooper sharp, and perfectly cooked onions. It’s not a cheap steak by any means, coming in at about $20, but the quality and portion size makes it justifiable. You could do way worse somewhere else paying a very similar price. My wife ordered a meatball parm sub vodka sauce and it was also excellent and massive.
I’ve had the pizza at Peppino’s in the past, and while it isn’t my favorite (I prefer thinner, crispier pizza) I’ve heard many people really like it. I’m sure it’s more of a style preference for me verses it not being a good slice. Nothing wrong with that.
But if nothing else, since we know there are many great pizza shops around the area, the sandwiches, specifically the cheesesteak, sets Peppino’s above. Highly recommend.
… moreSherrie Mooney
Get the garlic knots!! Sandwiches were stuffed you can’t eat at one sitting but don’t worry, tastes even better next day!! Their marinara sauce rules!! Did I mention they have a Dubai chocolate pizza?
… moreScott Phillips
Some of the best Italian I’ve eaten in south Jersey. Hank and Gia are forces to be reckoned with. Authentic Italian at its best. The picture is a serving for ONE person. So worth the visit and prices can’t be beat
… moreTony White
Well no need to go over the bridge or hit Merchantville for a great cheese steak!! This place is number 1 in my book!! Cooper Sharp, seeded roll and mouth watering Ribeye can’t be beat! The Chicken Cutlet with Vodka sauce blew me away!! This is a must try spot!! 2 thumbs up!!
… moreStephanie “Stef” Smith
Saw a recommendation on Tik Tok and I am so glad I went to check it out! The food did NOT disappoint, and the staff was so friendly! I really wanted mega fries but also mozzarella sticks, so I asked if it was possible to get the mozzarella sticks with the mega fry toppings, and it was AMAZING!!!! It definitely needs to be a new menu item. I also ordered a cheese steak. It was big enough to share, and STUFFED with meat. This is definitely going to be my new go to place! Highly recommend!
… moreKaren Gregorio
I’m SO HAPPY to have finally found great pizza in this area!! My husband and I both gave it a 9.25/10 (only because we like our crust to be crunchy). The crust has a great flavor and is very soft, the sauce is excellent, and I don’t know what brand of mozz they use but it has so much flavor! Very unique! I loved it. I can’t wait to try more on their menu. Not to mention everyone working at the counter was extremely friendly. We will definitely be back soon!
… moresamuel swanson
The best cheesesteak I’ve had since moving to Jersey. The options for the bread taste the sandwich to another level. I can eat a lot and I could only finish half of my sandwich and I did not ask for extra anything!
… morerphoenix rphoenix
Probably the best cheesesteak i ever had. It was Incredible . I added Long hot and grilled onions and it tasted amazing. Excellent meat quality.
… moreKamryn
Absolutely worth the 3 hour drive from NYC!!!!! My friends and I came all the way to Peppino’s just for the food and it did not disappoint. The vodka chicken parm sandwich is a must try — so flavorful and perfectly made! The cheesesteak was amazing too, super juicy and packed with flavor.
Everyone there was so friendly and the service was incredible. Super casual spot with seriously phenomenal food. 10/10 all around. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreM S
I found this place on TikTok and drove 45 mins to try. Very good food. The Buffalo wings were tasty and Blue Cheese dressing seemed homemade. The cheesesteak was so cheesy and soft. I’m satisfied. Yum.
… more