4.5 – 544 reviews • Pizza restaurant
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: vitospizzaofmechanicsburg.com
Order: Order online
order.toasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Manisha Sabat
We tried the Grandma’s pizza and it was okay. The pizza was little salty so maybe they can use the sweet tomato sauce. The chicken tenders was good. The people working there were friendly and nice. Overall, a good casual place for pizza.
… moreK S
Used to be the best pizza in area. Finally got to try the pizza again with the new owners and complete opposite. Not even eatable. This is very unfortunate as you can buy a frozen pizza at giant next door that is better. Please bring back original ingredients!
… moreM
Cheese pizza was good, the layered sandwich pizza was cold and it had just come out of the oven! Cashier person kept a baby on her hip the whole time we were there, didn’t seem sanitary or safe.
… moreMonica Ferguson
It was our first time here & WOW! Everything was amazing! We were welcomed in & immediately felt like we found our new favorite place. From the minute we got there, we felt taken care of. The dining area was very comfortable & the added Italian music from the televisions was so awesome. The kitchen was visible from the counter & was immaculate & we got to watch our host make our pizza right in front of us. We watched as he generously piled on top quality ingredients & sliding it into the pizza oven. Our salads were huge & had freshly grated cheese on top & a hot breadstick. Our Buffalo pizza was incredible. He customized our Buffalo pizza with half with really hot sauce & my husband’s half with mild sauce. This place is a must visit! The menu was endless! The friendliness of our hosts exceeded expectations! Hearing him greet regulars in person & when taking orders by phone with genuine value & appreciation really resonated with us! We will definitely be back! Thank you, Vito’s Pizza!!!
… moreAmanda Mazzurco-Wright
Vito’s is not what it used to be. It is chaotic in there and they have no idea what they are doing. The new owners have changed the bread that they use for the meatball parm sub from their seeded italian bread to pizza dough, which is horrible! When you order a sandwich, you want actual bread. It also costs the same amount of money as it used to, but is a smaller portion size. Would definitely not order this again. The meatballs must be frozen, not homemade like they used to be because they were soggy and water squished out of them. This is how you lose business. Why would you change a good thing? We are from Long Island, N.Y so we know good pizza. This place used to be halfway decent for Pennsylvania pizza. As New Yorkers, it was a place we could handle. Not anymore unfortunately, bye bye Vito’s.
… moreTyler Mowry
My wife and I ate here for the first time tonight. Amazing food, amazing service. Definitely our new pizza shop. Look forward to trying more items on menu!
… moreShani Stanley
The owner kindly greeted me upon entrance along with an interesting odor. It was almost enough to make me walk away and I should have. But I stayed because the majority of reviews are decent. I initially came for pasta, but decided to try the pizza first instead. So I ordered the two slice with drink special. I requested the Grandma’s pizza which there were only two slices left. The picture and description is a lot different than what I received. It looked and tasted like a regular Sicilian slice to me. Barely any sauce and a huge crust which should have been more pizza.
Aside from that, every single table was dirty. The owner knew I planned to stay and eat because he asked, but he didn’t bother to wipe down any tables. The only decent one was the one we sat at. There were also no visible high chairs for use so I had to tussle with my granddaughter the entire time. The floors were extremely sticky as well.
I came around 3 pm. I heard a lot of calls coming in for orders being placed. It’s seems as though they need a little more help in order to manage better. I decided against ordering the pasta to go.
The owner has really good energy. Positive and welcoming I wish them all the best.
… moreCarol M
Edit – I finally got my pizza after waiting an hour. I was given a refund and a two liter bottle of soda. The pizza did taste good, so I’m giving back 3 stars and hoping the new owners correct the online ordering issues and settle into the workflow soon.
Ordered online at 4:00 for pickup at 4:50, using Takeout7.com since it said “preferred by business.” Arrived at 4:53 to be told the order was not received – along with 5 other people. I was to arrive with pizza at a gathering at 5:00. It’s now 5:20, still no order, and it’s chaos behind the counter. I just learned it’s new ownership. I hope the food is worth the wait as it was under prior ownership. Will update if l ever receive my order.
… moreRich Thornton
This place is great! The workers are friendly and seem to enjoy each other and working there. The man who took my order came over to my table and asked what I thought of the pizza and introduced himself. I told him the pizza was great, which it was. I had cheese pizza and decided to get two slices instead of one because there was a special for that and a drink. I was so full! It was so good! I definitely recommend this place. Check it out!
… moreD S
Great local pizza shop. Super friendly staff and well prepared fresh food. These breadsticks are best in PA! The sub rolls are the best I have ever had. We had a large order and all food was very fresh. Margarita pizza is insanely good! Owner is super friendly and appreciative of guests. They have their own line of wine which is high quality and tasty. Love this place!!!! Get there!
… more … View more