Jamie Slavin
Food was AMAZING! Our families tried a little bit of everything from pizza to spaghetti, ravioli, appetizers and cheese bread. It was all wonderful. We had the best waitress, Darien… We might be a little bias on that. She is truly a rockstar, we love her❤️
Wish I would have known about Benny’s when we lived in Garden City.
Now we live an hour and 13 mins away… We definitely will be ordering from Benny’s when we are back in town.
… moreJosh Campbell
We came in for a family lunch to celebrate my son’s birthday with around 20 people. We called a few weeks ahead and booked it, and even though they normally open at 2:00 PM, they opened an hour early just for us so we could have a private lunch before regular hours. That was really appreciated. The staff was friendly, the food was great, and everything went smoothly. It made the day extra special for our family. We will absolutely be back.
… moreBrian P
Great food and friendly waitress that was always there when we needed anything! Salad was fresh, dip sticks are a must and the pizza was perfectly cooked with plenty of toppings. Excellent location with plenty of room for larger groups at very competitive prices to even the pizza delivery places (and better tasting). Support your locally owned businesses !!
… moreChris Gamblin
We visited recently and found ourselves wanting to leave right away. Our waitress, Gabby, did an excellent job all night even though she was the only one serving almost 40 people. We ordered appetizers and were seriously dismayed. We got the sampler and everything was overcooked, even though it was early and only a few patrons in the place. The bar ran out of 3 different liquors that night because their delivery had not come. But being around the industry for a long time I knew they had other options. You would think they would keep a full stock bar when you have a party of 40 plus a band and their followers coming in. Poor judgement. The pizza we were served rated on of the top ten worst pizzas I have ever eaten. Tasteless.. sawdust would have been better. Through all of that, our waitress kept a smile and did her job as best she should. Management needs to look at staffing more people on nights they know they are going to be full and check the quality of food they serve. Also, keep a well stocked bar as I probably would have spent an additional $100 just in drinks and stayed longer.
… moreDan
I’ll start off saying the food was awesome, no complaints there!
I want to raise attention to an issue that i’m guessing goes on often since no one seemed to care nor notice that my server was evidently drinking/drunk on the job. I could smell liquor on her breath when she took our order. You could hear her words slightly slurring together. This was Friday night. I don’t know if maybe the owners are okay with this type of behavior but I find it embarrassing towards the establishment. It was very noticeable in my opinion.
This really seems to be a great place and the food was very good but I would hate to see it shut down if an undercover came in and noticed what I noticed. Just wanted to draw some attention to this without calling out any names or talking bad about the restaurant in a whole.
… moreMightymommy 101214
The pizza is good. Solid 4. I’m a pizza snob so I’m a hard sell. To get a 4 from me is quite the achievement. The drinks on the other hand, not great. I ordered a vodka/cran. All i could taste was Cranberry juice. I stirred it up thinking maybe it just didn’t mix… no, there’s no vodka in there. I flagged the girl back to tell her there had been a mix up and she insisted she had in fact put vodka in the glass but very kindly offered to bring me another shot. Even if this added shot it hardly tasted like there was anything other than Cranberry juice in that glass. Idk what kind of vodka they are using, but i definitely don’t recommend it. Needless to say i didn’t order a 2nd one. But was service was good. Over all, 4 stars.
… moreKerry Partin
Great first time there. Good pizza and atmosphere. Entertainment was Smith Factor band. They were great! Recommend.
… moreJonas Sostakas
Benny’s, your neighborhood bar and pizza joint, with a stage where local bands entertain!
Benny’s sponsored my daughter’s softball team dinner years ago and we’ve been coming back ever since.
A fully stocked bar with a good section of beers on tap compliment the excellent pizza and salads.
… moreSarah Ealy
The food here is excellent. As much as I love the pizza I have to say that the cheese bread is my favorite – the marinara dipping sauce is to die for. They have full bar service and do trivia nights too. I’m only giving 4 stars because the staff is completely disengaged, I have never in my life seen a group of people who put so little enthusiasm into their work. It’s worth dealing with the disengaged staff to eat here though.
… moreBryon Morell
Good food, love they added the windows to the front. Waite staff are always great. Good local neighborhood hangout
… more