Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We offer various delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Whether you’re staying at the resort or just passing through, our restaurant is the perfect place to satisfy your pizza cravings. Come and enjoy a slice or two while taking in the stunning views of nature surrounding the resort. We look forward to serving you!
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Classic Pizza in Island Park at Blue Buffalo Pizzeria
BLUE BUFFALO PIZZERIA … We offer a wide variety of delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection. Whether you’re staying at the resort …
Blue Buffalo Pizzeria | Island Park ID – Facebook
Blue Buffalo Pizzeria ; Details. . 2 Reviews. . $$. . Closed now. . 3402 N Highway-20 , Island Park, ID, United States, 83429 ; Links. . bluebuffaloresort.
Blue Buffalo Pizzeria, 3402 Buffalo St, Island Park, ID 83429, US …
Get more information for Blue Buffalo Pizzeria in Island Park, ID. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Danielle Westerhausen
Amazing pizza! Handmade and absolutely delicious. We ordered the all meat and it was piled high with meats and cheese. Sauce and crust were awesome. Glad our cabin wasn’t quite ready (we were early) so we could experience it!
… moreJ Mae
Excellent pizza shop! Ordered 5 pizzas to-go over the phone and the guy was very helpful with my questions. Arrived and our pizzas were ready on time and staff was very friendly. Easy to park and the pizza shop itself is very nice with cute decor and a relaxing, rustic feel.
The pizza was delicious! Customizations were correct. The family loved it – especially the kids! Highly recommend.
… moreThe pizza was delicious! Customizations were correct. The family loved it – especially the kids! Highly recommend.
Vanessa Rodriguez
Their pizza was amazing and the friendliness of their staff (both of them) was inviting. We ordered the supreme and meat lovers (they call it something else, but I can’t remember). All of my family devoured them, this included our two young kiddos. Thanks for the great service and even better pizza.
… moreDustin Rigg
Driving “17” hours to move to a different state, because I’m a dad fighting cancer, my kids bullied in school and a school district that is unfit to teach h children…
On the drive back, my 6 yr old son had to use the bathroom, so I thought it would be nice to feed the family and ordered a cheese pizza for the kids and a meat pizza for the adults…
At 5pm The guy behind the counter wearing glasses took our order and stated name for the order “Dustin” we’ll call ya when it’s ready…
An hour goes by now 6pm an hour later staff continues to look at us, doesn’t ask why we are still there when everyone leaves and keeps talking laughing behind the counter!
My wife goes up and asks where the “2” pizzas are… the guy with the glasses was in the back… this other guy said what did ya order? Oh I have the meat pizza (which the crust was burnt to hell and how does this happen when it goes on a short conveyer belt)? The kids cheese pizza dough was under cooked?
Why did we receive poor service? I’m struggling with cancer, kids struggling in society and we’re being judged for getting “2” pizzas?
This place has a lack of empathy for people they do not know!? Did you want a $100 tip? We are broke and driving back on fumes!?
This business seems to be ran by boys in high school maybe college who act through defensive aggressive narcissistic behavior and poor judgement!
If the owner catches wind of this review here’s how you fix it and self correct:
-fire the boys that worked at 5pm on 10/3/25
-tell them their not meant to work in the food industry with poor behavior
-to take my name “Dustin” but hand us a box named “Hannah” is ridiculous!
But to treat a cancer patient and his family tonight was uncalled for and these boy talking trash behind the counter and had us wait now over an hour is inexcusable and this attitude fits there job description as garbage men where making trash can be a perfection their good at!
No I don’t want a call, refund or a reply fix your business and take charge of this poor behavior!
… moreOn the drive back, my 6 yr old son had to use the bathroom, so I thought it would be nice to feed the family and ordered a cheese pizza for the kids and a meat pizza for the adults…
At 5pm The guy behind the counter wearing glasses took our order and stated name for the order “Dustin” we’ll call ya when it’s ready…
An hour goes by now 6pm an hour later staff continues to look at us, doesn’t ask why we are still there when everyone leaves and keeps talking laughing behind the counter!
My wife goes up and asks where the “2” pizzas are… the guy with the glasses was in the back… this other guy said what did ya order? Oh I have the meat pizza (which the crust was burnt to hell and how does this happen when it goes on a short conveyer belt)? The kids cheese pizza dough was under cooked?
Why did we receive poor service? I’m struggling with cancer, kids struggling in society and we’re being judged for getting “2” pizzas?
This place has a lack of empathy for people they do not know!? Did you want a $100 tip? We are broke and driving back on fumes!?
This business seems to be ran by boys in high school maybe college who act through defensive aggressive narcissistic behavior and poor judgement!
If the owner catches wind of this review here’s how you fix it and self correct:
-fire the boys that worked at 5pm on 10/3/25
-tell them their not meant to work in the food industry with poor behavior
-to take my name “Dustin” but hand us a box named “Hannah” is ridiculous!
But to treat a cancer patient and his family tonight was uncalled for and these boy talking trash behind the counter and had us wait now over an hour is inexcusable and this attitude fits there job description as garbage men where making trash can be a perfection their good at!
No I don’t want a call, refund or a reply fix your business and take charge of this poor behavior!
Alexandria Wenninger
Very good sandwiches. I thought the prices seemed a bit high when we were ordering but when we got our sandwiches the ingredients were all high quality, the price makes sense. The ham had a very nice subtle smokey flavor. I also was very happy that they let me order the kids half sandwich as I’m a pretty small person, if I had ordered a full sandwich half would have gone to waste because the sandwiches have a lot of fillings!
… moreJackson George
Their were very quick to get out big order out! The pizza was really good. I’ve had a lot of pizza in my life and wasn’t expecting too much here. I was mistaken and blown away. Get the meat lovers pizza and the cheese sticks.
… moreRoman Ramirez
Waited over an hour for my order. I feel bad for other customers. They showed up before me and waited for 2 hours. When the customer went to check on her order they informed her it wasn’t even in the oven yet. I stayed at the Blue Buffalo Resort. When I checked the menu it said they had kids pizza. But when I went to order it they said they do t have kids menu. So they need to update that.
… moreBrooklynn Leavitt
Ordered our pizza ahead to be ready at 7pm. Went to pick it up when they said it was ready at 7… and it was cold. They must have made it when I ordered it hours before. Would not recommend ordering ahead.
… moreSnyder Boughton
Ordered two sandwiches behind approximately 3-4 other similar sized groups. Waited over one hour before asking a time estimate to which we were informed it would be 10 minutes. Waited 20 more minutes before asking again to be informed it would be 10 minutes. The workers stated they had not begun the order yet. The restaurant was almost empty and the employees were clearly disinterested in the customers or working. The kitchen was filled with smoke and no care was being taken to any patrons and no orders appeared to be worked on in the hour plus of waiting. Cancelled order and left, would not recommend the stop unless you want to waste your evening and time
… moreMelissa Orozco
We had lunch here after a day of hiking. We ordered sandwiches and they were absolutely delicious and hit the spot. The ingredients were high quality and it was filled with plenty of meat. The price did reflect the quality of the sandwich. The staff was super friendly. I would recommend this place to anyone.
… more