Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Laid-back local pub offering sports on TV, cocktails, beer, hearty sandwiches & other comfort grub.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 61 S Van Buren St, Nashville, IN 47448
Phone: (812) 200-1999
Website: https://www.facebook.com/outoftheordinaryrestaurant/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Out of the Ordinary Restaurant and Hickory Sports Bar – Facebook
A cozy and friendly restaurant and bar in the heart of the Village of Nashville, Indiana. Bar & Grill · $$ · (812) 200-1999.
Out of the Ordinary Restaurant & Hickory Sports Bar – Brown County
They serve homemade favorites with huge portions and friendly service. Stop in for: Tasty starters; Big salads; Fresh soups; Hearty sandwiches; Delicious dinner …
Out Of The Ordinary Restaurant & Hickory Sports Bar – MapQuest
Out of the Ordinary Hickory Sports Bar in Nashville, IN offers a unique experience for sports enthusiasts and those looking for a lively atmosphere.
Reviews
Ariana Warren
My husband and I stopped here for lunch. I was about two bites into my meatball hoagie and bit into something hard, almost like a bone. It ended up being a piece of glass. Our waitress was so sweet and kind, very apologetic. She said the manager felt bad but the manager never came out to say anything.
They did remake my meal but I was a bit nervous to eat it. Food was okay. But for $52 and glass in my food – it really wasn’t worth it.
The waitress was fantastic though! She was a sweetheart.
… moreThey did remake my meal but I was a bit nervous to eat it. Food was okay. But for $52 and glass in my food – it really wasn’t worth it.
The waitress was fantastic though! She was a sweetheart.
Callie Main
We LOVE Out of The Ordinary and Hickory Bar! ☺️ Their pork tenderloin was SO good and huge! It has a fun atmosphere with lots of exposed wood and green plants. The staff was super friendly and our waiter was fantastic! I absolutely recommend stopping by if you’re in the area.
… moreNatalie C
Flip of a coin whether you’ll like the food here. The reviews are all mixed opinions, and my family experienced the same thing. I liked my pulled pork sandwich, but the pork tenderloin and Cuban were just alright.
The pulled pork was well-seasoned and juicy, a nice thick layer on a soft bun. I paid $4 extra for the side of onion rings (which were very good) and I liked putting some on my sandwich.
The pork tenderloin was tender and the vegetable side was fine, but neither made much of an impression. Veggie of the day was zucchini, peppers, and onions.
The Cuban sandwich didn’t have much meat on it but tasted okay as well. The side of chips were just regular ruffled potato chips.
Overall our experience was ordinary, and didn’t leave a strong impression one way or another.
… moreThe pulled pork was well-seasoned and juicy, a nice thick layer on a soft bun. I paid $4 extra for the side of onion rings (which were very good) and I liked putting some on my sandwich.
The pork tenderloin was tender and the vegetable side was fine, but neither made much of an impression. Veggie of the day was zucchini, peppers, and onions.
The Cuban sandwich didn’t have much meat on it but tasted okay as well. The side of chips were just regular ruffled potato chips.
Overall our experience was ordinary, and didn’t leave a strong impression one way or another.
P Mae
The staff are very friendly and helpful.. makes this restaurant feels like visiting family. The food is great, I would recommend the fettuccine with steak. Wow!
… moreHosannah Latham
I got the tenderloin with onion rings, my boyfriend got the steak sandwich with fries. Both were wonderful- especially the fries and onion rings. The onion rings came with a sauce very similar to outback’s bloomin onion sauce. The tenderloin was on the thicker side which isn’t my preference but it was still good.
We also got loaded potato skins as an appetizer which were great- I think probably my favorite park of the meal. They have a great house-made ranch.
Our host and server were both very sweet and provided great, fast service. Everything came fresh and hot, and in very good time. I’ll definitely come back here next time I’m in the area!
… moreWe also got loaded potato skins as an appetizer which were great- I think probably my favorite park of the meal. They have a great house-made ranch.
Our host and server were both very sweet and provided great, fast service. Everything came fresh and hot, and in very good time. I’ll definitely come back here next time I’m in the area!
Andrea QB
Warning, its very ordinary. Menu is typical sandwiches and salads, nothing interesting. Food wasn’t bad, but wasnt good either. A $15 tenderloin sandwich comes with chips
that are probably Ruffles Very salty. Atmosphere? Music from the 70s, but only the most mainstream and ordinary- Eagles, Bob Seeger (boomer music?) So, if you’re a fan of these ordinary things, this is your place! Server was very attentive and helpful. I didnt drink at the bar, so maybe there’s something extraordinary there ♀️
… morethat are probably Ruffles Very salty. Atmosphere? Music from the 70s, but only the most mainstream and ordinary- Eagles, Bob Seeger (boomer music?) So, if you’re a fan of these ordinary things, this is your place! Server was very attentive and helpful. I didnt drink at the bar, so maybe there’s something extraordinary there ♀️
Audrie Burton
Came to Nashville for my bachelorette party, where we decided to dress up as hillbillies and go out to dinner. We chose out of the ordinary, and before we even entered the restaurant we were greeted by amazing staff, and an awesome waiter who handled a group of 7 drunk girls acting like rednecks AMAZINGLY. Everyone was so kind and inviting, the food was good too. If you’re in Nashville on a girls trip, or for any reason, and you need a place with a fun, laid back atmosphere, I highly recommend!
… moreMelanie J Watkins
In town for a little getaway. I heard a lot about their ribeye steak and decided to give it a try. I, of course, ordered the ribeye *blackened*with a side salad w a side of the pesto vinaigrette and the vegetable of the day (zucchini and roasted peppers). The salad was very good, but tiny for the price. It had spring mix, cucumbers, tomatoes, broccoli, cheese, onions, seeds, and croutons. The side of zucchini & peppers were a VERY SMALL portion. I counted about 9 half thin slices of zucchini with a couple of pepper slices/red onion. The ribeye was ok. It had a few tender parts, but the middle of the steak was pretty tough (meat grain was comparable to a sirloin). It’s definitely not worth $30. My husband ordered the Cuban sandwich with potato chips and the meatball sandwich for later on. He said the Cuban was very good, but the meatball sandwich was excellent. Our server was very friendly and attentive. If I were to go back, I would stick to a sandwich. It’s a little pricey for what you receive. I took about half of my steak back to our hotel and bought a full house salad for later. Overall, the establishment was nice and cozy.
… moreThalia Taylor
Out of the Ordinary – Nashville, IN
Out of the Ordinary is a delightful spot in the heart of Nashville, IN, offering hearty, flavorful dishes with a welcoming atmosphere. Their pork tenderloin is a standout—perfectly cooked, juicy, and generously portioned, it’s a must-try for anyone who loves a classic Midwest favorite. The onion rings are crisp and golden, providing the perfect accompaniment, and the generous portion of pulled pork is rich, tender, and bursting with sweet and smoky goodness.
One of the most impressive aspects of this restaurant is their attention to dietary needs. They offer a special Alpha-gal menu, a thoughtful inclusion for those with this specific allergy. Additionally, they have no problem accommodating dairy-free adjustments, making it a stress-free dining experience for those with dietary restrictions.
With its inviting vibe, great service, and creative approach to ensuring everyone can enjoy their meal, Out of the Ordinary lives up to its name in the best way possible!
… moreOut of the Ordinary is a delightful spot in the heart of Nashville, IN, offering hearty, flavorful dishes with a welcoming atmosphere. Their pork tenderloin is a standout—perfectly cooked, juicy, and generously portioned, it’s a must-try for anyone who loves a classic Midwest favorite. The onion rings are crisp and golden, providing the perfect accompaniment, and the generous portion of pulled pork is rich, tender, and bursting with sweet and smoky goodness.
One of the most impressive aspects of this restaurant is their attention to dietary needs. They offer a special Alpha-gal menu, a thoughtful inclusion for those with this specific allergy. Additionally, they have no problem accommodating dairy-free adjustments, making it a stress-free dining experience for those with dietary restrictions.
With its inviting vibe, great service, and creative approach to ensuring everyone can enjoy their meal, Out of the Ordinary lives up to its name in the best way possible!
Bonnie Putney
We ate dinner last night here, food was excellent, tenderloin was huge, my daughter and I shared, steak and potatoe soup was delicious. And Darian our waitress was so attentive and gracious, excellent waitress.
… more