Michaelangelo’s Pizza & Subs

  4.0 – 560 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Local pizzeria chain serving a menu of NY-style pies, subs & pasta in casual surroundings.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs 28584

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Michaelangelos | Pizza & Subs

At Michaelangelo’s Pizza we go the extra mile to ensure that your pizza, subs, salads, appetizers, and desserts are all prepared using the freshest available …

Michaelangelos Pizza (@MichaelangelosPizzaNC) – Facebook

Michaelangelos Pizza. 7815 likes · 24 talking about this. Michaelangelo’s Pizza is serving up NY Style Pizza and Subs in Atlantic Beach, Cape Carteret,…

Menu – Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs

Appetizers ; Bruschetta · 7.95. With tomato and olive oil ; French Fries · 7.95 ; Fried Calamari · 17.95. With marinara sauce ; Fried Dough · 9.95. With Sauce or …

Reviews

Honest foodie
You won’t be disappointed stopping for pizza here. I ordered a couple slices to dine in for lunch and it was a nice thin crispy crust slice.
… more
Christa Plaugher
Pizza… great! Salad, horrible. And the guy on the phone when I called about the salad… even worse.
Included photo of our $6 house salad pizza. I get that it won’t be gourmet, but serving the core is the head of lettuce? Not cool.
… more
ES
We ordered online and were quoted 20 minutes. Got there 25 minutes later and pizza wasn’t done. The girl behind the counter gave us our receipt and told us it would be a few minutes. We proceeded to sit there for 25 additional minutes while they checked in with every other customer except for us. When I finally got fed up and checked in with them again (we had been sitting right in front of the counter) she got our pizza down and said it had been ready for several minutes. So we waited 50 minutes for 1 plain pizza and a turkey sub. The pizza was cold by the time we got home because they couldn’t be bothered to check in with us at all.
… more
Angela Moore
We stopped in for a quick lunch and we enjoyed our experience. The staff are welcoming and attentive. The pizza was good and tasted fresh. I had the Pepperoni slice my husband had the stuffed slice. Both very good. We also decided to share a Italian sub. It was fresh and very good. I can’t wait to return to try more of the menu.
… more
Josh Frazier
We always order from here and have it delivered, but tonight we ordered two large Italians and one ham & cheese but that’s not what we got. We ended up getting three ham & cheese instead and when i called in I asked to speak to a manager, And when he answered I explained to him that we always order from them and we have never had a issue until tonight. I told him we didn’t want a refund or anything replaced but we just wanted to let him know what happened and he ended up arguing with me and saying he watched the guy make all 3 subs and two of them was Italians and I told him im not saying he didn’t make them, I just said maybe they ended up in the wrong bag and then he said oh if u are trying to get free food then this isn’t the way!!!!! Excuse me, I told him I don’t do that shit and how dare he talks to a loyal customer that orders from them like 8 to 10 times a month and then I said well u lost my business for good. I can’t believe that happened but it did so beware if u order something from them and its wrong, don’t bother calling them because they will just accuse u of trying to get free food…. smfh
… more
Carolina C.
Disappointing! Went today for the first time, be advised that their slice pizza, calzone and stromboli are not fresh, they are sitting all day on display. I ordered a calzone and it was extremely hard to eat, they are not made fresh and are precooked, I couldn’t finish it after a few bites. Also, you cannot customize the calzones, they are already made and cooked before you order. My husband disliked the sub he ordered, he didn’t like the taste. We won’t be visiting this place again.
… more
Carla Alexander
Ordered two Italian subs. Bread was hard and didn’t put all the meat on it. Was surprised as usually this sandwich is very good
… more
Dave Conley
Food was fantastic service ehh was like girl was mad she had to wait on people. But food came out great. Will b back again though.
… more
Robin L.
Got a large supreme pizza here on Sunday evening 7/20/25. The pizza was really good! The group working that night was great. Good service. They were smiling and having fun while also doing their work! Nice to see that in fast food restaurant, which we all know can be stressful! Good job all around
… more
Rob Myrick
Placed a takeout order online. Said it would be ready at a time, I got there 1 min before and it was being packed up. Perfect timing.

Everything stayed warm for the 20 min ride home.

Calzone was one of the best I’ve had and my fries was crispy. My wife’s cheese sticks were perfect according to her and the salad was fresh.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment