Kelvin Klemm
We had lunch outside on the covered deck on Saturday. We got a basket of fries for an appetizer. My friend got a chicken cobb salad and I got the Saturday special of buffalo boneless wings. I wish the boneless wings had more sauce on them but overall the food was delicious. I always enjoy going there especially when you can watch the golfers play.
… moreHeather Wynn
If you’re looking for an event space for a party/reunion/whatever in Mechanicsburg, book this place! We had my dad’s 80th birthday party in the large event room next to the restaurant, and it was perfect. We had about 40 folks there, but it could definitely fit double that at least! It was such a smooth and straight-forward process to reserve, pick food for the catering, etc. But the stand-out of the show was Sam, who helped manage the event and even helped me set up. While attempting to decorate before the party, I had to run and pick something up. When I returned, everything was set up beautifully. I nearly cried. The food was great and everyone was just so nice. Thank you Caddy Shack!
… moreJosh VanBuskirk
Never had a bad meal or service here. Great specials during the week.
… moreMichael Swauger
Food and service was great. Can get really busy. Unique offerings with a golf theme.
… moreJanet Richey
Normally the wings make up for any short comings you might find with the service, but this visit left us disappointed with both. The wings were not nearly as crispy and they were cut at odd angles, making some pieces have more bone and less meat. Our server hardly engaged in any conversation, and I am not sure if he ever cracked a smile. This has been a family favorite for us because of the wings, because of its view of the golf course, and because it’s locally owned. I am willing to give this place another visit, hoping this one was an isolated incident. Otherwise, I’d have given it 2 stars
UPDATE (approximately 1 year later) Things seem to be back on track. We love this locally owned establishment. Our server was friendly and helpful. The wings were meaty and cooked to perfection. The kids menu had a variety of options, and was a bargain for $3. 99. So glad we didn’t give up on this place. It surpasses any of the chain restaurants you’ll find on the Carlisle Pike. .
… moreTia Rende
This place is one of my new favorite spots! The overall experience was great! Great servers/staff, and wonderful food and drinks!
Michelle was our server and she was so kind! If you havent tried it here yet I 100% recommend you do!
… moreM Lawrence
Great food and great service. Ask to sit on the deck. I got the jumbo basket of wings and my wife got the taco salad. We had a super nice evening and the bill came out to $40 with an appetizer and 2 meals.
… moreJohn Broody
We used to love this place but things have really gone downhill. The wait staff is really friendly but the long wait for food can be a bit of an issue.
The real problem though was the cooking and a potential health hazard. My family recently went to eat and ordered med well burgers. My son bit into the burger only to find it was completely raw. Not even rare but raw.
I got the waitresses attention and she put the order in again only for another 30 minute wait for the replacement burger.
There are a lot of good pub food places out there. Save yourself from getting sick and go somewhere else.
… moreShaun Steckley
Had a decent meal. Nice deck to sit outside. Wings were good. It’s close so we’ll be back probably quite a few times.
… moreDinesh Durai
found it to be a mixed experience. The drinks were a highlight and a good selection of beers made for an enjoyable evening. The atmosphere was lively, especially with the outdoor seating overlooking the golf course, which added a pleasant touch to the visit.
However, the food left something to be desired. While the menu offers a variety of options, including wings, burgers, and seafood, the dishes we tried were just average in taste and presentation. For instance, the fish and chips were okay but lacked the flavor and crispness one might expect . It’s worth noting that some patrons have praised certain dishes like the wings and prime rib specials , so experiences may vary.  
The staff was friendly and attentive, contributing positively to the overall experience. If you’re looking for a place with good drinks and a casual atmosphere, Caddy Shack is worth a visit. However, if you’re seeking a standout culinary experience, you might find the food offerings to be just average.
… more