Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Welcome to Tammy’s Pizza – The Locally Owned & Operated Pizzeria in Grove City – where we proudly blend tradition with quality. As a locally-owned, family business, we Craft Every Pizza With Love, using only high quality ingredients. Our dough and sauce are made in-house every day. We source Local Breads, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian & Special Blend Sausage and Salami. This ensures fresh and authentic flavors in every bite. Our Team Members are also local and are your neighbors (and ours). Check out our Tammy’s Porker & Tammy’s Works Pizzas – and don’t forget The Super Italian Sub. Whether you’re dining in, picking up, or opting for pizza delivery (order delivery online only) in and around Grove City, Tammy’s Pizza strives for a gr…
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3984 Broadway, Grove City, OH 43123
Phone: (614) 875-2345
Website: https://tammyspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tammy’s Pizza – Grove City, OH
Welcome to Tammy’s Pizza – The Locally Owned & Operated Pizzeria in Grove City – where we proudly blend tradition with quality. As a locally-owned, …
Tammy’s Pizza – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Tammy’s Pizza – Broadway 3984 Broadway. 3984 Broadway, Grove City, OH.
Tammy’s Pizza – Grove City Town Center, Inc.
3984 Broadway and 5913 Hoover Road. Owner or Manager. Mark Youngs. About. Welcome to historic Grove City’s Town Center, located in the heart of Grove City, Ohio …
Reviews
Dan Acton
Tammy’s Pizza was ranked highly as we gave it a try. Pizza was very good but very light on sauce. No fountain drinks, only y the bottle. After opening, we found the 2 liter was barely cool and asked for ice. They don’t have ice. Salad was generous large enough to share but only had 1 small packet of dressing. Extra dressing $1. Jalapeño popper breading mushy and only after delivered to table discovered no dipping sauce included. Want dip like every other place in the world, get out another $1. I dislike getting nickel & dimed when I spent nearly $50 on a 14” pizza, salad, poppers, and a 2 liter. No plans on returning soon.
… moreJosey Acton
Tammy’s Pizza on Broadway is popular with others, but I wasn’t impressed. Ordered a $6.75 chef salad that was good, but the 1 packet of dressing not nearly enough. Asked staffer for another and he asked me up front to PAY $1.02 for another dressing. Tried the Jalapeño poppers 6 count for $7.50. Breading was mushy and noticed no dipping sauce. Asked for some dipping sauce that is included every other place we’ve gotten them. Yep, another $1.02. 14” BBQ chicken pizza $22.95 basically very good, except very light BBQ sauce. Ordered soda – no fountain only 20 oz & 2 liters. 2 liter = $3.75. Only offered 12 oz plastic cups. Thinking they forgot ice, I asked for ice as pop barely cool. No ice – not even an ice machine. Total bill for mostly aggravation? Nearly $49
… moreSteve Norris
For those of you who live in the Columbus area and are familiar with Massey’s and Tommy’s, it’s kind of a mix, probably one of the better places for pizza. It’s a small shop but they know how to do pizza.
… moreLloyd Napper II
This is my favorite place to go for pizza in Grove City. The food is always great and the people here are very friendly. I love local mom and pop shop vs the chain pizza shop. If you are the same, you will love this place. The dine in area is kind a small. They do have some outdoor dining (weather permitting).
… moreKJ H
We passed this business after having lunch at another restaurant in town but after looking at reviews and seeing pictures we come back for dinner. Restaurant and bathroom was pretty clean, the place seem run by a lot of very young kids and they as kicking butt! They stayed busy, great communication, customer service, polite. It was a pleasant experience and our order was right!
Very heavy on toppings, nice crisp bottom crust, the cheese was like cheese on pizza used to be back in the 80s where it will string for a mile! It was great! We would definitely eat this again!
… moreVery heavy on toppings, nice crisp bottom crust, the cheese was like cheese on pizza used to be back in the 80s where it will string for a mile! It was great! We would definitely eat this again!
Jim Weaver
04/18/2025
Another amazing Tammy’s Pizza tonight! Best in Grove City!
We love Tammy’s Pizza! The crust is nice a crispy, cheese and pepperoni are plentiful, and flavorful! Sauce is delicious! We like sitting on the sidewalk on Broadway.
… moreAnother amazing Tammy’s Pizza tonight! Best in Grove City!
We love Tammy’s Pizza! The crust is nice a crispy, cheese and pepperoni are plentiful, and flavorful! Sauce is delicious! We like sitting on the sidewalk on Broadway.
Kareem Harris
I called and placed my order and the young woman was pleasant and professional. I called back a few minutes later and added wings because I’m a sucker for wings and she added them with no problem.
The pizza was good but had barely any sauce so if you’re into sauce ask for extra sauce. I asked for more (on the side) paid it and was satisfied.
The wings are good but a tad bit salty. I had to take a break because I felt my blood pressure rising as I ate each wing. I think it’s the sauce being used (it’s not Franks).
Honestly, I wouldn’t go back because the food in my opinion was just thrown together.
… moreThe pizza was good but had barely any sauce so if you’re into sauce ask for extra sauce. I asked for more (on the side) paid it and was satisfied.
The wings are good but a tad bit salty. I had to take a break because I felt my blood pressure rising as I ate each wing. I think it’s the sauce being used (it’s not Franks).
Honestly, I wouldn’t go back because the food in my opinion was just thrown together.
David Zesati
The pizza was delicious!! Was very happy and the staff was was friendly, made me feel welcomed. It was my first time trying this place and loved it, won’t be my last!
… moreGobot’s on the trail.
This is my second time back here placing a takeout order coming in on late Friday evening the store was chaotic busy. When picking up our order all of our order was ready but one item wasn’t done cashier was very confused and gave her my number she’s like our u sure you ordered here!! Yes we did I repeat my number many times couldn’t find my order gave her my name found it….. Meatball sub was a very big huge disappointment and let down it must have been sitting for awhile and by time we got home it was soggy I would not recommend getting it. Now the pizza was the best but the garlic bread we got was way overpowering tasting! Oreo cheesecake we got was very bland not appealing at all waste of money overall I definitely do recommend there pizza and there sauce
… moreCarielle Rankin
Tammy’s is consistently one of the best places to get pizza. They never disappoint! The inside seating area is a little small, but during warm months, there is plenty of outdoor seating as well.
… more