Jessi Eldred
This location is terrible. First time we went the crust was burned and the Italian breadsticks were nothing like the ones in colwich. Have it a second chance last night and the cheese wasn’t even all the way melted, it was cool and hard.
Won’t be going again 🙁
… moreDavid Hammar
Absolutely great place to eat!! The staff is wonderful, friendly, helpful, just plain awesome!! The pizza is so good!! We are reminded of our childhood every time we eat here. My family and I recommend this as a must when you are needing pizza!!
… moreHolly
Not sure what’s going on at the Newton Location, but this location is not consistent. Sometimes is good, but mostly it’s just not. Tonight it’s horrible. 12/31/25. No management around and I think the food is made whatever way the cook feels in the moment. I mean how hard is it to make a pizza? Or even a sub sandwich. Not worth the price. I expect more from Gambino’s.
… moreDonni Thomas
Fantastic pizza, friendly service, clean dining area and restrooms. They have a great lunch buffet, and the salad bar is excellent. Highly recommend
… moreNick Sullivan
Everything has Alfredo sauce. Asked it they would be putting out red sauce meat lovers and was told we don’t. Only hamburger or supreme on buffet. Save your time and money.
… moreProfessor Spindler
Great pizza buffet. A little pricey but pizza was hot and fresh.
… moreAllissa Marie
Food was delicious, workers were friendly. They keep the buffet food freshly i love that they bring different types pizzas out as well! Price was good. We’ll come back in the future.
… moreShaylee Arena
Great service, ordered carryout and it was ready In 10 minutes. Super friendly people too. The Italian cheesestick pizza was good and super cheesy, just yum!! The very cherry dessert one was Amazing!! Highly recommend. They’re doing something right here!
… moreJ E
The best pizza place in town. Love the pizza, pasta, sandwiches and wings. I haven’t gotten anything that isn’t delicious. They also have a great staff and are very welcoming.
… moreAmy Orem
Ordered my pizza with no one is house eating. Was told my wait would be 20 minutes. Meanwhile staff is talking and my order was shoved on top of a shelf while I sat for 45 minutes waiting on my order. Sorry we forgot you were here. Got home to cold pizza and breadsticks too hard to eat. My bill was $70 for 2 pizzas and breadsticks that we were not able to enjoy.
… more