Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Trophy Pizza is a legit pie and slice joint making Cincinnati’s best authentic New York style pizza as well as gourmet, fresh salads and the best cheesecake you’ve ever had. – Grab a fresh slice for a fast lunch – Bring dinner home to your family – Feed the office with a stack of pies – Get hot pizza delivered to your door – Cater your next party or event We can’t wait to share our love for truly great pizza with you. See you soon!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 10325 Reading Rd # 102, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Phone: (513) 769-1111
Website: https://mytrophypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Trophy Pizza
Trophy Pizza exists to make the best slice of pizza in Cincinnati. Pizza connects us to a simple joy we’ve all experienced since we were children. We created …
Trophy PIZZA (@TROPHYPIZZA) – Facebook
Trophy PIZZA is in Evendale, OH. Sep 5, 2023 . . Mama, we made it! Thank … Thank you so much, @cincinnatimagazine for featuring us in the top 25 pizza parlors …
Trophy Pizza – Evendale, 10325 Reading Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45241 …
Trophy Pizza – Evendale is a vibrant eatery located in Cincinnati OH known for its mouth-watering artisanal pizzas. With a welcoming atmosphere and a …
Reviews
Dave Schrank
I’ve been to Trophy Pizza at this location five times now, and never had anything but a great experience!
The eating area is always clean and bright, and the staff has always been exceptionally friendly and helpful!
The pizza itself is delicious! It comes out of the oven quick, so it’s hot, fresh and the crust is nice and crispy!
There are always many different types of slices under glass to choose from, so I usually make it a point to ask about something that I haven’t tried before, and then add it to my order.
I highly recommend this place!
… moreThe eating area is always clean and bright, and the staff has always been exceptionally friendly and helpful!
The pizza itself is delicious! It comes out of the oven quick, so it’s hot, fresh and the crust is nice and crispy!
There are always many different types of slices under glass to choose from, so I usually make it a point to ask about something that I haven’t tried before, and then add it to my order.
I highly recommend this place!
Josh
This was my first time trying Trophy Pizza. I recently saw Dave Portnoy do a review of this pizza and gave them a great score and now I know why! This was probably the best pizza I have ever had. 100% would recommend and I will be back soon for more.
… moreB SNOW
High expectations… exceeded! This place has a great vibe and some killer pies. The crust is light with a nice crisp and has the perfect amount of toughness for ease of chewing.
… moreRene Valdez
Went in there today at 4pm was able to get the 2 slices and a drink deal ( its their daily lunch deal 11 am -4pm). I dont remember the specific pizza slices i tried but can describe them. The first one was peperoni with what i think is buratta cheese. Peperroni was crispy and the cheese was soft and goey. Secon slice had pepperoni, sausage, and bacon which was delicious. Ordered some garlic knots and wow those were delicious soft, fluffy , and great garlic flavor which also came with a side of marinara to dip in . Lastly got the giant cookie which the owner says is delicious and it was amazing the cookie was crispy outside but goey in the center not to sweet . Overall this place is great met the owner and had a great conversation with him you can tell how passionate he is about the quality of his food which is always amazing to hear .we definitely came because of barstool video and we will be coming back when we are in the area. 10/10 recommend trying . 🙂
… moreTaylor Ragle
This place is legit. They are 20 inch pies, they also sell by the slice too. Garlic knots are a must. Skip the chain pizza places and support these guys!! You won’t be disappointed
… moreadam fink
I don’t know why I haven’t written a review for this place yet; it’s incredible!
These slices are the closest thing you’ll find to a NY slice in the Cincinnati area. I’ve had just about every slice by now and they’re all delicious in their own way. My favorite is the grandma though. For lunch you can’t beat getting two high quality slices and a drink for the price.
We have ordered pizzas for work before and the carry out quality of the pizza is still great, although if you have the ability to eat it dine in, do so! I was genuinely surprised with how good a whole carry out pie was though.
The owner and his staff are very accommodating and hospitable. I always feel like a valued guest in someone’s house when I’m here and that’s what hospitality is all about. I’m always asked about how I liked the food before I leave and I never have had anything but great things to say.
If I’m having a bad day at work, I’ll always have Trophy Pizza as a reason it was worth driving 30 miles from my house to here!
… moreThese slices are the closest thing you’ll find to a NY slice in the Cincinnati area. I’ve had just about every slice by now and they’re all delicious in their own way. My favorite is the grandma though. For lunch you can’t beat getting two high quality slices and a drink for the price.
We have ordered pizzas for work before and the carry out quality of the pizza is still great, although if you have the ability to eat it dine in, do so! I was genuinely surprised with how good a whole carry out pie was though.
The owner and his staff are very accommodating and hospitable. I always feel like a valued guest in someone’s house when I’m here and that’s what hospitality is all about. I’m always asked about how I liked the food before I leave and I never have had anything but great things to say.
If I’m having a bad day at work, I’ll always have Trophy Pizza as a reason it was worth driving 30 miles from my house to here!
Chris Mucha
Can’t believe I only learned about Trophy in the last year even though I’ve lived in Cincinnati for 14. Some of the best pizza in the area. Straight forward and not flashy. Great char on the crust. Highly recommend.
… moreKurt Hirons
I really wanted to try this place after seeing photos of the pizza. My wife and I love NY style pizza. She got the Margarita pizza in the photos. It looks great but it was undercooked in the center and overcooked at the crust. It was the same story with my gluten free pizza. They were good but could have been great! Maybe they were having some oven temperature issues. Oh well it was definitely very good pizza and we will be back. Hopefully next time they will blow us away with great pizza. Update 12/12/24 Trophy now delivers to my house with doordash. I ordered a gluten free NY style cheese pizza. It was perfect. Exactly what I wanted crunchy crust no flop this time not undercooked. It was cooked to perfection! This is the best NY style gluten free pizza CRUST in cincy at the moment. Brooklyn in Montgomery has more cheese topping and wins if cheese quantity over crust quality is your preference. I buy from both places regularly.
… moreMisty Weatherford
Amazing pies! Great customer service! The cheese and sauce taste like grandma in new York crafted the pizza perfection
… moreThe Corriveaus
I lived in NY (in Soho). This is real NY style pizza. Large pieces you have to fold. Dripping down your hand. Its the real deal.
… more