Alexander Emmanuelli
Had a really nice meal here last night. Server was really nice. Cocktails and food were great. We really loved all the sauces used in the dishes. And the Flan/tres leches desserts at the end of our meal were delicious! You can tell the kitchen puts a lot of thought into the menu.
… moreRob Mo
We stumbled on Mayahuel after our first choice was closed and were glad we did. This family-run Mexican spot in Astoria focuses on northern and coastal flavors, with an emphasis on seafood. It was our first visit and the service stood out—friendly, attentive, and genuinely accommodating.
Appetizer: We shared the Camarones Zarandeados. The prawns were cooked perfectly and the sauce—with guajillo butter and mole oil—lifted every bite; I found myself trying (and failing) to scoop up every last drop.
Mains: The Pulpo Encacahuatado was flavorful, slightly spicy, and incredibly tender—my friend said it was the best octopus he’s ever had. The Carne Asada was also excellent, with a tender, well-textured steak.
Dessert: We followed an owner’s recommendation and chose the flan. It struck the perfect balance of firmness and sweetness, finished with crunchy cacao bits that made it irresistible.
A small cultural note: in Mexican tradition, Mayahuel is associated with nourishment and transformation. Overall a warm, delicious find—definitely worth a visit.
… moreCarin Rudich
We had such a great time last night!
The food was a surprise with its elevated simple but complex flavors.
We ordered several dishes to share but honestly my favorite was the tuna tartare served with the silkiest avocado mango puree and lightly fried sweet potato chips.
Highly recommend!
They have happy hour which we didn’t even realize till we received the bill. The drinks were really nice, you have plenty of options from the traditional to more swanky type.
The staff was so friendly and our server was very attentive. It was our friend’s bday and they sang and treated her to dessert.
The restaurant is pretty spacious and has three different areas to sit in. It’s great for large parties, they easily can slide tables together.
I’m definitely going back for the tuna tartare appetizer and excited to try other dishes.
… moreElaine Kang
Wonderfully surprised at the beautiful atmosphere, with outstanding, knowledgeable service, by Angelique, and high quality, gorgeously plated food.
We came here with a groupon, but will definitely be back as regulars.
Service was amazing and knowledge with great reccomendations .
Creative, unique cocktails Luis-absolutely delicious!
Delicious, fresh food!
Will be back to try everything on menu!
… moreneha nischal
It’s a 1 time deal! Order was messed up! Our server Tiffany was sweet but she needs to be more focused at work and the orders. Atleast she agreed she messed up 2 of our orders. And as a courtesy she offered tequila shots . Overall good was ok . No wow factor. I have had better mexican food. Drinks were good! And its extremely noisy .. the place is cute and cozy but that reason wont be enough. They need to work on the taste and service.
… moreJennifer
For starters we thought the menu was way too small for a Mexican restaurant. The two enchiladas they had both only came with chicken. We started with chips with a variety of salsas after the waitress recommended it. We can’t understand why she recommended this after she asked if we liked spicy, and we told her only if it’s light spicy. All the salsa except one were so spicy they were barely edible. The one that wasn’t spicy tasted terrible. It tasted like a green oil. What was quite weird they gave us more salsas than they did chips, and we were three people. They did give us extra chips after I asked for them. For entrees my sister and I had the enchiladas suiza. The sauce was good, but we didn’t care for the meat or the enchiladas themselves. The only saving grace was the sauce. The rice and beans it came with weren’t good. My husband had the shrimp tacos, and he thought they were good. I asked for sour cream and I specifically told the waitress we each wanted our own. She came back with one tiny serving of sour cream the size of a dime! Then I had to get up and get the waitress for more water. She should have saw the water was almost gone when our entrees arrived and immediately refilled it. We definitely won’t be back.
… moreA A (Juji)
The restaurant is pretty! The decor is lovely and on theme. The shrimp ceviche is delicious and fresh. The drinks are exquisite and attractive. We had fish tacos, steak tacos and the chicken mole. Everything was great. I enjoyed the chicken mole. The sauce was really tasty.
… moreJOVANNA ACOSTA
The BEST Mole ever!! Hands down!
Place is absolutely gorgeous for a cute date or girls night out. Menu is small yet full of flavor, please try the enchiladas de mole superb!!
Service very attentive and welcoming
Definitely recommend it!
… moreValentina.
I loved this place, a different type of Mexican food but it remains delicious! I went with my brother for the first time and it is definitely a place to go with friends, family or as a couple, good music and zero noise! I will definitely try different dishes again. Happy hour is also worth it!
… moreSergio Montes
The restaurant is pretty nice. The ambience is cool. Angelique really took care of us. She was very attentive and helpful. We’ll definitely come back.
… more