Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1811 Golden Eagle Way #25, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Phone: (904) 579-3488
Website: http://nypizzafi.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza
Local Family owned New York style pizzeria located across from the Fleming Island High School. Voted best pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza.
PDF Menu – Pizza in Fleming Island – New York Pizza
Pizza. TOPPINGS: Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Chicken, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Jalapeno Peppers, Black Olives, Broccoli …
New York Pizza FI | Fleming Island FL – Facebook
Call today to pre-order your football feast and guarantee your pizza arrives when the party starts! Call now at 904-579-3488 to guarantee your delivery or …
Reviews
Joshua Huddleston
Great Pizza. Super flavorful. I loved it because it wasnt super greasy!!! Would have been 5 years but they charge over 3 dollars per topping. A bit steep to sprinkle a few black olives on a pie. The buffalo fries were the best fries I have ever had.
… moreJason Hubbard
Best NY pizza I have had. Crispy crust, no bubbles, generous delicious toppings. Staff are sugar sweet and greet you warmly. Reasonable prices and huge pies if you want one!
… moreCrystal
Our new favorite pizza joint! Amazing pizza and super friendly service!
… moreDanielle Laraway
Update: got the caesar salad; t was delicious!
For my lunch of 2 slices of pizza (BBQ and chicken & ranch), 2 garlic knots, and a drink, it was just over $10. It was plenty of food for the price. The pizza was really good, my favorite being the ranch one. The garlic knots were amazing, as well as the garlic butter drizzled over them. Their drinks right now ate bottled only, but a variety to choose from including Gatorade, soda, energy drinks, tea, or water. The restaurant was clean and modern. The staff were friendly and efficient in their service.
… moreFor my lunch of 2 slices of pizza (BBQ and chicken & ranch), 2 garlic knots, and a drink, it was just over $10. It was plenty of food for the price. The pizza was really good, my favorite being the ranch one. The garlic knots were amazing, as well as the garlic butter drizzled over them. Their drinks right now ate bottled only, but a variety to choose from including Gatorade, soda, energy drinks, tea, or water. The restaurant was clean and modern. The staff were friendly and efficient in their service.
John Deluca
I’LL Definitely be back…. it was delicious, reminds me of my younger days in Philly and NY. The grandma’s pizza ..???? Muah delicious and the normal cheese slice is a true NY SLICE… You guys hit out the park, Best around here hands down.
… moreJohn Linehan (Ahab)
The food was good, but with literally nobody waiting for food, how is it possible that a small boat of fries takes half an hour to prep, cook, and box? With 6 employees?
And a credit card charge for USING A CREDIT CARD?? How about you get a better system, and stop adding charges for PAYING FOR FOOD?
Trust me: won’t happen again
… moreAnd a credit card charge for USING A CREDIT CARD?? How about you get a better system, and stop adding charges for PAYING FOR FOOD?
Trust me: won’t happen again
Tamoa Arroyo
Love the Pizza! We’re New Yorkers who have NOT had good NY Pizza in Florida. Well, the search is over! New York Pizza delivered! My husband and I are very please. The crust was perfect! Crunchy, but not Burned. The sauce and cheese ratio was distributed perfectly. What a delight! I can’t wait to try other items on the menu.
… moreFISHER SANDRA
Ordered a Margherita pizza to go. 18 inch for $33. Very disappointed. It was basically a thin layer of tomato sauce (you could see the dough), sprinkled with bits of tomatoes and patches of square mozzarella cheese placed here and there. I thought I was on Candid Camera.
… moreDonnell Wyatt
This was my first time trying this place. The lunch special was expensive, $10.74 for 2 slices and a drink. Sadly, it wasn’t good. I had the works and the chic fil a pizza slices. To be honest, I have had frozen pizza that tastes better than this. The only plus was the convenient location. I honestly cannot return to this place again. The dining room is also used for store near the back. Don’t know why this is the case, since they have another storage space next door. Their food quality really needs to be improved. Right now, their pricing has surpassed their quality.
… moreJames Davitt
First time eating here and I went based on the reviews. It was a bit of a drive for us but I have to say definitely worth it. I was born and raised in NY and the pizza is very close. So fresh and greasy and fabulous. Absolutely going back
… more