Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–1:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2344 E 53rd St, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Phone: (317) 995-7925
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Keystone Diner | Indianapolis IN – Facebook
Keystone Diner · We will be closed on Monday, January 26th 2026. · We are closed for Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. · Closed for the weather today….but we …
Keystone Diner – Best Breakfast in Indianapolis
Nestled at 2344 E 53rd St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, this local gem offers a delightful combination of hearty meals, friendly service, and a warm, inviting …
Keystone Diner Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Keystone Diner is a beloved gem located in Indianapolis, known for its warm, homestyle atmosphere and generous portions. Renowned for …
Reviews
Ro Indy Realtor
There was a small wait before being greeted at the door. Once I sat down, I was taken care of right away. The food was made to order. My potatoes came out cold. I let my waitress know. She apologized and had a fresh plate delivered to my table in minutes. The pancakes were probably the best I’ve ever had. The outside had a perfect crunch while the inside was super fluffy. I ordered grits and didnt have a chance to fix them up. They were delicious with just butter after eating my pancakes and potatoes. I can’t wait to go back. They also had old school music playing on the TV. You pay upfront.
… moreCarl Kalota
What a fun and delicious experience. The staff were excellent, efficient, and friendly. The corned beef hash is come back again, and again, yummy. Plenty of parking and accessible. Big menu. Quick service.
… moreJstar Marie
I am writing to express my profound dissatisfaction concerning a recent experience at a local establishment, the Keystone Diner, which my grandmother and I visited for breakfast this morning. Our expectation for a standard breakfast was unfortunately unmet, leading to a highly disappointing encounter.
The service quality was notably below acceptable standards from the outset. Upon our arrival, we were not greeted at the entrance, which set a rather unwelcoming tone for our visit. Following our order, the food was served lukewarm, giving the distinct impression that it had been prepared some time ago and held inadequately, significantly compromising its freshness and appeal.
When I raised these significant concerns with a manager on duty, the response received was unsatisfactory. While I did not explicitly request a discount, the manager’s immediate dismissal of such a possibility, coupled with an explanation regarding another manager’s absence, did not adequately address the core issues of service and food quality that we experienced. Although an offer to remake the meal was extended, by that point, our trust in the establishment’s ability to provide a quality experience had diminished, and we declined.
Furthermore, upon settling our bill, we discovered an erroneous charge for an additional portion of gravy. This was necessitated by the initial serving being insufficient for the accompanying biscuit, and regrettably, this extra portion was also served cold.
As a long-standing patron of this establishment, it is with considerable regret that I must conclude this was an entirely negative experience. Consequently, we will be discontinuing our patronage and will be seeking dining services elsewhere. This decision comes after a cumulative disappointment in the service and quality provided today.
… moreThe service quality was notably below acceptable standards from the outset. Upon our arrival, we were not greeted at the entrance, which set a rather unwelcoming tone for our visit. Following our order, the food was served lukewarm, giving the distinct impression that it had been prepared some time ago and held inadequately, significantly compromising its freshness and appeal.
When I raised these significant concerns with a manager on duty, the response received was unsatisfactory. While I did not explicitly request a discount, the manager’s immediate dismissal of such a possibility, coupled with an explanation regarding another manager’s absence, did not adequately address the core issues of service and food quality that we experienced. Although an offer to remake the meal was extended, by that point, our trust in the establishment’s ability to provide a quality experience had diminished, and we declined.
Furthermore, upon settling our bill, we discovered an erroneous charge for an additional portion of gravy. This was necessitated by the initial serving being insufficient for the accompanying biscuit, and regrettably, this extra portion was also served cold.
As a long-standing patron of this establishment, it is with considerable regret that I must conclude this was an entirely negative experience. Consequently, we will be discontinuing our patronage and will be seeking dining services elsewhere. This decision comes after a cumulative disappointment in the service and quality provided today.
Becca Dvorak
This is the BEST diner breakfast in Indy. The service is always so friendly and quick (and my coffee mug is never empty!)
The cinnamon roll pancakes are the reason every other pancakes are ruined for me. I can’t eat pancakes in my own home without daydreaming about being at Keystone Diner and having cinnamon roll pancakes. I’ve literally brought every member of my family and all of my friends here so that they can experience it too. Don’t miss out!!!
… moreThe cinnamon roll pancakes are the reason every other pancakes are ruined for me. I can’t eat pancakes in my own home without daydreaming about being at Keystone Diner and having cinnamon roll pancakes. I’ve literally brought every member of my family and all of my friends here so that they can experience it too. Don’t miss out!!!
The Dining Grandpa
Back at the Keystone Diner.
Nothing fancy—just solid, satisfying food the way it ought to be. Doesn’t matter what time you walk in, this place is always busy, and for good reason.
Today’s order: Bill’s Breakfast—country fried steak smothered in rich, peppery sausage gravy, scrambled eggs, white toast, fried potatoes just like your mom used to make, and a side of bacon. There are options, but that was my pick.
Now add a cup (or three) of bold, hot, never-ending coffee, and it’s hard to beat.
Free parking, fast and friendly service, and dependable, no-nonsense diner food. That’s the Keystone promise—and they keep it.
… moreNothing fancy—just solid, satisfying food the way it ought to be. Doesn’t matter what time you walk in, this place is always busy, and for good reason.
Today’s order: Bill’s Breakfast—country fried steak smothered in rich, peppery sausage gravy, scrambled eggs, white toast, fried potatoes just like your mom used to make, and a side of bacon. There are options, but that was my pick.
Now add a cup (or three) of bold, hot, never-ending coffee, and it’s hard to beat.
Free parking, fast and friendly service, and dependable, no-nonsense diner food. That’s the Keystone promise—and they keep it.
David Townsend
I haven’t been here in a long time and a lot of things have changed. You have to actually come in the diner to place your carry out order which was fine and I did. I ordered a ham, egg and cheese that traditionally is the bomb. This time around was different. There was only two thin slices of ham in the sandwich where as before it would be loaded. It was very tast but way too pricey for what you get in return. The sandwich set be back $13.00 and this was highway robbery.
… moreTed Moore
Love the service and it’s a perfect lil place to go and get some really good food for a good value!! Every person had a smile on their face and they all had great conversation which is rare. I definitely recommend this place.
… moreRanae Michell3
Amazing Ribeye steak corn beef hash grits potatoes and eggs was amazing and Debbie (like the cake) has the best service and is so kind truly a home experience i would recommend and im coming back! Thank you for a great experience
… moreTasha Elhag
A coworker took a few of us to the Keystone Diner. I ordered the vegetable omelette with potatoes. The omelette was so greasy it made my stomache upset. Also it wasn’t very tasty, there was barely any cheese in there, well at least I couldn’t taste the cheese, maybe because whatever oil was used saturated the taste. Potatoes and toast were the only thing good on the plate. I thought with there being slot of customers there that the food must be pretty good. I wouldn’t recommend the omelette.
… moreLauren Ditchley
Had a nice little breakfast date with my son here! I had oatmeal (one of the few vegan options) and he had a waffle and bacon – which is exactly what he wanted. Love the old school vibe. If you’re looking for a traditional diner with awesome prices, this is your place!
… more