Welcome to Stumpy’s Pizza – Castle Rock’s Go-To Spot for Great Pizza & Good Times At Stumpy’s Pizza, we believe great food and great fun go hand in hand. Located right in the heart of Castle Rock, Colorado, we’ve been serving up handcrafted, flavor-packed pizzas in a laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere that locals love. Whether you’re here for a quick bite, a casual date night, or a family outing, Stumpy’s brings something special to the table—authentic, house-made pizza and a nostalgic, game-filled vibe you won’t find anywhere else Pinball & Pizza? Yes, Please. Our wall of vintage pinball machines adds the perfect retro twist to your night out!
Casual pizza place with a bar serving a variety of thin-crust pies in strip-mall surrounds.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 138 S Wilcox St, Castle Rock, CO 80104
Phone: (303) 814-1800
Website: http://stumpysnewyorkpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Stumpy’s NY Pizza
PIZZA THE WAY IT SHOULD BE! · For more than 25 years, Stumpy’s Pizza has been a Castle Rock original, proudly serving up authentic New York-style pizza. We bring …
Stumpy’s New York Pizza | Castle Rock CO – Facebook
We are now open for Dine-in and pinball too! Our current lunch special is Two slices of cheese pizza with your choice of soda for $5.49!
Stumpy’s NY Pizza, 62 Founders Pkwy, Castle Rock, CO 80104, US
Stumpy’s Subs & Pizza, located in Castle Rock, CO, has been delighting locals and visitors alike with their authentic NY style pizza for over 15 years.
Reviews
Logan Flanagan
The food was excellent and very fresh. Prices were very affordable! I was absolutely blown away by the pinball selection- they have games from every era which were in fantastic shape! There are so few places in the area where you can play genuine classic EM pinball machines that are in full working order so this was such a pleasant surprise.
… moreSarah Trimble
WE LOVE THIS PLACE! Always delicious and has been serving our community for 26 years. Everyone feels welcome here and more than satisfied with the amazing menu offerings and family friendly atmosphere. I would truly hate to see this place forced out of their home all for the sake of a pastor who had a schizophrenic epiphany that told him to destroy local businesses. This new church will destroy this part of Castle Rock with parishioners who can’t or won’t park correctly and it has no need to be so close to downtown like it’s going to have foot traffic. What a joke. Stumpy’s forever!
… moreCorndawg 7th Sage of Sabian
Outstanding service, and food. The garlic cheese bread, will break your heart! The pizza sauce has a great taste, and the cheese blend is surprisingly flavorful. Gretchen took top notch care of us, and made sure my beer was frosty cold. I definitely recommend, and I will be going back.
… moreRuth Ginsburg
Can’t beat their 2 slice (or 1 slice and a salad) lunch special WITH A BEER!! (Or soda)
Very good east coast style pizza with fun pinball games. No frills atmosphere. Great lunch spot.
… moreVery good east coast style pizza with fun pinball games. No frills atmosphere. Great lunch spot.
Zachary Fienen
I enjoyed my visit to Stumpys in Castle Rock. The food was pretty good and it arrived quickly. They also had good appetizers. The atmosphere was friendly and they also had arcade games and pinball. Definitely a fun place to go for a bit to eat.
… moreJady Lynn
Good Pizza, GREAT Lunch Special (Less than a McCombo for 2 Slices and a beer – WhAT!) Dive Bar atmosphere with pinball machines, sports on the tv, and no interior designer hired – Just good pizza, burgers, and prices!
… moreScott Owens
Somehow, maybe a decade ago, Stumpy’s fell off our list of “Go-To” pizza places in town. It was so long ago, I can’t even remember why. On a wild hair, we decided to give them a try again, and I’m glad we did. We really enjoyed our pizza!
… moreMolly L
I was patiently waiting at home for this pizza, I love NY style pizza, I grew up on it. When I opened the box I was so excited, the pizza was perfect if only we didn’t eat it before I took the picture. The crust, crispy and flakey, it had the perfect amount flop when easily folded. Cheese blanketed the sauce like the first snow of the year. The sauce was sweet, with hints of oregano. Dave Portnoy would say 10/10
… moreTom Wolford Jr
Excellent pizza and they have a great lunch special.
… moreSarah Costin
We have been coming here for about 5 years. We have dined in, place takeout orders on almost a weekly basis, and have celebrated numerous events here. We liked that the food was pretty good and it was a fun atmosphere for kids/families. Things have since changed, they have become very strict with the size of parties. We have come in the past to socialize in group gatherings with friends and family. On this visit we were here at 4:15 PM to about 5:40 PM, on a Thursday. Not a busy or high demand time, there were numerous open tables, about 3 low tables were taken and 1 high top in the bar area. This time another family in our group asked to start a separate tab from the one we had, and they were turned down. The waitress told us that it had to be on our tab and that if more people joined our party then the 8 seats available at our table, they would not be allowed to occupy another table. I just don’t understand turning down business or making people feel awkward or uncomfortable if they have a large party. There was also another parent in our that tried to order from the bar, when the kids were playing the games, and again they were denied. I feel like this restaurant has the type of atmosphere we have utilized it for and promotes social gatherings in a casual environment, where you can enjoy food and drinks, and the arcade area. After our experience today, we will no longer be taking our business here nor will we continue to recommend Stumpy’s. Very disappointing.
… more