Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-owned and serving Florida’s Treasure Coast since 1996, Goodfellas Pizza is known for handcrafted pizzas, hot wings, subs, fresh salads, and homemade pasta. With nine locations across Port St. Lucie, Jensen Beach, Fort Pierce, Jupiter, Vero Beach, Sebastian and more! We offer fast delivery, takeout, and reliable corporate catering. Whether you’re craving a meatball sub, Caesar salad, or the best pepperoni pizza around, Goodfellas brings bold flavors and quality you can count on.
Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 148 NW California Blvd, Port St. Lucie, FL 34986
Phone: (772) 446-7777
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
goodfellaspizza4.hrpos.heartland.us
Related Web Results
Goodfella’s Pizza Pasta Subs | Family Pizza Restaurant near me
Goodfellas Pizza serves fresh pizza, pasta, subs, wings, and family meals across the Treasure Coast Florida. Order online for pickup or delivery from your …
Goodfella’s Pizza – 148 NW California Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL 34986
Homemade Lasagna. Tasty Meat Sauce, layered with Pasta, Romano, Ricotta & Mozzarella Includes fresh Tossed Salad & Homemade Garlic Knots · Homemade Spinach …
Goodfellas Pizza (7550 S US Highway 1) Menu Port Saint Lucie
7550 S Us Highway 1, Port Saint Lucie, FL 34952 · Pizza • Pasta • Desserts • Alcohol … COLD SUBS. HOT SUBS. PASTA DISHES. PASTA DISHES BAKED. ENTREES. DESSERTS …
Reviews
Sasha
Stopped here on the way up to Orlando. Absolutely delicious food and great prices. The guy with the glasses at the front was wonderful. Very clean inside as well as the bathrooms. While looking at the menu I saw they have a location close to where I live, I would like to visit there soon and hope to have an experience as good as I did here!!
… moreMelissa North
LONG BUT NEED TO KNOW
I have to say by far the worst customer experience. Now I remember why I haven’t ordered from them since I moved over this way.
Called at 3:37PM and girl was super nice when she took my order I requested it be delivered at 5:00PM. 5:00 comes around 5:10 comes around said he was almost here 5:26PM comes around and still no delivery and I had to call again. To top it off the “rude guy” who answered the phone stated he could void it and tell the guy to turn around. I said I planned nothing else for dinner. He should have gave me my money back.
Mind you I have to pay them on a link before I get the order and tip and all. Odd…
We get the good barely any sauce on the kids pasta and my pasta. And the sauce tastes sour. AND FOOD WAS ICE COLD.
… moreI have to say by far the worst customer experience. Now I remember why I haven’t ordered from them since I moved over this way.
Called at 3:37PM and girl was super nice when she took my order I requested it be delivered at 5:00PM. 5:00 comes around 5:10 comes around said he was almost here 5:26PM comes around and still no delivery and I had to call again. To top it off the “rude guy” who answered the phone stated he could void it and tell the guy to turn around. I said I planned nothing else for dinner. He should have gave me my money back.
Mind you I have to pay them on a link before I get the order and tip and all. Odd…
We get the good barely any sauce on the kids pasta and my pasta. And the sauce tastes sour. AND FOOD WAS ICE COLD.
Anonymous
Absolutely loved the pizza here — easily a 10/10. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and honestly couldn’t have been better. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. I’ll definitely be coming back again.
… moreShawnna Mckelvey
Ordered was told it’d be 20/25 mins no problem, my husband went to pick up after his two hour drive home to sit there for 45 minutes watching our wings get cold he says something twice the cook in the back gets an attitude tries to serve him raw pizza, we refused of course I mean it was obviously undercooked and he was told to leave the shop. Craziness won’t be going back.
… moreLouis Lewis
A great little genuine Italian pizzeria in a shopping area. It’s in close proximity to a gas station, Walmart etc.
The service is excellent fun the time you enter the door. There’s seating available if you choose to dine in. And the tables are preset, so you feel welcomed.
The pizza and other offerings are decent for a place this size. The food is very tasty and comes in good time. You also have the option of sitting outside to dine.
Good value for money!
… moreThe service is excellent fun the time you enter the door. There’s seating available if you choose to dine in. And the tables are preset, so you feel welcomed.
The pizza and other offerings are decent for a place this size. The food is very tasty and comes in good time. You also have the option of sitting outside to dine.
Good value for money!
jahsun
Pizza is tasty. Wings are cooked well and they have a great variety of flavors. 2 slice lunch special with a fountain drink is filling.
… moreck warfair
I have always loved goodfellas I get their calzone and the chicken Alfredo with broccoli and bacon and this store did not disappoint
Maris is the BEST!! Great vibe, she makes grabbing lunch so entertaining I could talk to her all day!! Owners here know what they’re doing!
… moreMaris is the BEST!! Great vibe, she makes grabbing lunch so entertaining I could talk to her all day!! Owners here know what they’re doing!
Angela Cummings
Oh my land. Pizza slices bigger then my hand. And I enjoyed every bite. Even thou it took me two days to eat the different slices.
… moreJay “Mobile Web Nerd” Raffa
Simplicity of the food makes this place a nice stop off not far from me and I love their pizza and pretty killer calzones too
… moreKerry Mathews
The service was great grilled blackened chicken salad was delicious. Wings and pizza delicious
… more