Hans Harris
Mimmo’s Pizza is an absolute gem and hands-down one of the best pizza spots around. The crust is that perfect balance of soft and chewy with a light crunch, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and you can tell they use super fresh, high-quality toppings in every bite. The breadsticks are ridiculously good and taste just as homemade and comforting as the pizza itself.
The staff is always friendly, welcoming, and quick, which makes every visit feel easy and enjoyable. You never feel like “just another customer” here they truly care that you’re happy with your order. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch slice or ordering a big dinner for family and friends, Mimmo’s never misses. If you’re anywhere nearby and craving amazing pizza, this is the place you need to go!
… moreCorky Lorenz
The garlic bread knots are fantastic. Came with cheese and marinara dipping sauce cups. My order was for pick up, and it was ready on time, and hot. Worth a try if you’re in the area.
… moreLindsey Robbins
We ordered an Extra Large pizza & breadsticks. Delicious pizza! You can tell they use quality ingredients. The sausage, green pepper and onion had a lot of flavor. Customer Service was top notch!
… moreN Van (Ratz)
I’ve lived in Mishawaka for 6–7 years and somehow never tried Mimmo’s Pizza until recently. After having it twice in one week, I can confidently say it stands out as some of the best pizza in the area. The crust is perfectly balanced—crispy on the outside with a soft, airy interior—while the sauce is well-seasoned without overpowering the toppings. The quality of the ingredients really comes through in every bite. Mimmo’s has officially become a go-to for me, and I’m looking forward to working my way through the entire menu.
… moreIan Polando
This pizzeria has the best pizza I’ve ever tasted. I’m an Italian-American, and I don’t say this lightly. Mimmo’s is a great choice for all pizza lovers!
… moreRobert Nieman
We moved to the area about a year ago. After a little trial and error, we found Mimmo’s Pizza. They do a great job. I am from New York and difficult to please when it comes to pizza. A large Mimmo’s Favorite feeds the family for a couple of days and is a spectacular pizza. Every time we order I do a literal chef’s kiss after the first bite. Do yourself a favor and give it a shot.
… moreAnthony
Wanted to try a different pizza location, asked for well done. All cheese was white, not even a hint of yellow anywhere. First slice grabbed it , hangs down with a soggy base. Already disappointed before taking a bite, sauce left desire for any type of flavor…. on top of it $50 for a small cheese pizza and a large pepperoni pizza…. highly avoid if you like well done pizza
… moreNicholas Volsky
This place is fantastic. The food was absolutely delicious and they were super helpful with taking a large delivery order for us on a football weekend. Received multiple comments from our guests about how good the pizza, breadsticks and knots were. Mimmo’s salad was also a hit, essentially a deconstructed Italian sub. Will definitely be ordering again.
… moreKathleen Eberhard
Ordered a pizza for pick up last night & was charged a $3.99 “convenience fee”? What is that?!! We will never order from Mimmo’s again.
… moreJoe Klosinski
TERRIBLE customer service! I have ordered here several times and I keep coming back when I say I won’t. It keeps getting worse. I called in an order for 5 pm pick up, arrived at 4:50 and was told it would be ten minutes. At 5:23 PM I finally get my order. The food may be OK but their service is very terrible. So loud people hanging around TV blaring you can’t even hear yourself think. I don’t care how good the food is. If the service is terrible, the food is terrible! I will tell my family not to order from here anymore As we always have bad service.
… more