Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Stalwart counter serve providing classic pies, stuffed breads & sandwiches in a snug, unfussy space.
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 425 Derby Ave, West Haven, CT 06516
Phone: (203) 389-1603
Website: https://michaelangelo.froogleorders.com/
Menu Photos
michaelangelopizzaandsubs.froogleonline.io
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs
We’ve been serving the West Haven, CT community with mouthwatering pizza, delectable subs, and much more for years.
Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs
Michaelangelo Chicken Hot Sub. Onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheese. Made on our fresh baked Italian bread! $ …
Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs Restaurant – West Haven – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs Restaurant in West Haven. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Last Updates
Reviews
Michael Wayne
One of my favorite spots for pizza, spaghetti, there’s always enough sauce in the spaghetti, you may ask them to go easy on the sauce if that’s not your thing. I love the tomato basil slices, at times I’ll get the whole pie. Right up the street from home to. So I can run out on a Sunday for a lunchtime meal.
… morewalter altamirano
Sometimes we go back to a place to relive good memories , but not today. The person working behind the counter was simply not personable. I was hoping to get a couple of subs, but her attitude told me this was not going to happen . I ordered two pastries and an Italian loaf of bread instead. I guess these are changing times and won’t be going back.
… moreSamantha Endres
Unfortunately, I will not order from them again. Amazing food but we have a tomato allergy so we always get the sauce (not extra just what comes with it) on the side. Now, they will charge us for the sauce. Again, we are not asking for extra just what typically comes on it. I will not endanger my child for amazing food. We were so excited to find them and when we first did, I even asked them if they could accommodate this allergy and request, which they said they could. Now there is a charge to keep my child safe. I would gladly pay 10-25 cents for the container but that was not an option. The women at the front have always been friendly and kind, the food amazingly good, but this was my last order from them.
… moreGabe Cruz
Im not sure why I never tried them before i had them on Saturday, but this place is amazing!!! Not only do they make their own bread fresh daily, but their food quality is top notch!! The staff was super nice and welcoming as me being a first time customer and even offered me one of their signature baked cookies! They were so convinced i would like it that they offered to give it to me for free if i didnt! it was amazing btw. they will see me plenty of more times and their bread is absolutely heavenly and doughy and fresh with their sandwiches! Add this place to your restaurant must gos
… moreJenna M
I gave a 1 star because me & my husband are regular customers , Today we both placed an order online, My husband placed his & I placed mine, then, 2min. later my husband gets a call from the girl with blond hair that is taking orders & calls,she asks my husband & if he hit the order twice by mistake, My husband says no.. that he placed an order & his wife placed an order She then kept repeating herself that’s when my husband says it’s 2 different card numbers so how did I hit it twice, she just been being difficult & argumentative, Something you never do to get a customer upset, My husband is a black guy & I’m a white lady, makes us think she was having a problem with not wanting to come into work & have this big order come through, then when my husband goes to pick up our food, She had her lips all poked out as my husband went in to pick up our food, no apology or nothing, I was sitting in the truck watching her lips poked out. & Heard her tone on the phone when she called my husband & she was arguing with him & she simply just wasn’t understanding.This girl has bad poor customer service & wasn’t the first time from her, we gotten bad service from her before, just first time saying something, we won’t be back at least anytime soon. We will go where our service feels welcomed. Dont get me wrong nothing wrong with the food. It’s the service. Can’t help you made yourself sound dumb on the phone, & she really wanted to be right.
… moreBrian Hollander
Basic pizza joint set up. But I bite into their mushroom and sausage slice that they make all day and I’m brought back to childhood. Their prepared dishes, their subs and specials (like their spinach stuffed bread), and of course their pizza are all fabulous.
They also make fresh bread!
… moreThey also make fresh bread!
Denise P Clement
We enjoy their pies all the time but we really look forward to Christmas Eve whilst I am enjoying the 7 fishes of course the pizza is there because it’s just tradition with us. Thank you Michaelangelo’s
… moreNykia Hampton
Went on 11/19/25 around 6pm. It wasn’t busy, one other person in line. Counterperson was very rude and messed up my order after asking me about it like three times. I ordered two slices and a cup of soup. Very disappointing experience. There are so many better pizza places around I probably won’t go back again.
… moreCherina Hamilton
The lady in the front was on the phone when I walked in, I waited for her to get off the phone, I told her what I wanted as she ignored me and had a conversation with the lady behind her, proceeds to look me in my face and say one minute. Nah I have you 5 with no acknowledgment. I heard the pizza was disgusting anyway
… moreEvelyn Schwartz
Had the best Philly cheese steak, I still think about it, helped me pr in my track race too
… more