Social Profile: 
![]()
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2213 Main St, Bethlehem, NH 03574
Website: http://supersecreticecream.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Super Secret Ice Cream – New Hampshire Ice Cream Shop
Discover small-batch, handcrafted ice cream made with locally sourced ingredients in Bethlehem, New Hampshire. At Super Secret Ice Cream, a women owned …
Super Secret Ice Cream | Bethlehem NH – Facebook
Our vanilla bean ice cream is made using the whole pod, beans and all! We source our beans from a small farm in Hawaii called @laievanillacompany (huge thanks …
Super Secret Ice Cream (@supersecreticecream) – Instagram
Open 12-9 Thurs. – Mon. | Made from Scratch Local Dairy | No Weird Stuff | White Mtns NH ️ | ’24, ’26 Semi-Finalist & ’25 JBF Finalist …
Reviews
Chloe Kwak
This place is pure happiness in ice cream form! The person helping us was so nice and told us we could sample as many flavors as we wanted, total dream come true. I got the Earl Grey Tea ice cream and OMG it was unreal. I honestly thought Toscanini Ice Cream in Cambridge, MA had the best Earl Grey Tea ice cream, but this place totally wins. My husband got the Honeycomb in a waffle cone and was obsessed with both the cone and the ice cream.
Their logos give total designer vibes and are just too cute. The sweatshirts are adorable and there were so many souvenir options I wanted to take one of everything. We also got a pup cup for our dog and he finished it in one second. Can’t wait to come back for round two! ✨
… moreTheir logos give total designer vibes and are just too cute. The sweatshirts are adorable and there were so many souvenir options I wanted to take one of everything. We also got a pup cup for our dog and he finished it in one second. Can’t wait to come back for round two! ✨
Jea Kim
Wow. This might be the best ice cream I’ve had so far in the U.S.
At first, I thought the high ratings were just people riding a post-hike sugar high (and honestly, that might still be partly true). But most of the flavors I tried were genuinely fantastic. The ice cream flight came out to almost two pints, and even in shorts on a 50°F evening, we wiped it clean in under five minutes.
The flavors weren’t wild or experimental. Everything’s made in small batches, so the lineup seemed to change often. I didn’t see many of the flavors mentioned in older reviews, but 5/6 were hits. The sugar level was relatively restrained (by U.S. standards), so no sticky, sugary aftertaste. Also liked how they made the berry ice cream with yogurt.
Ranking the lineup:
Cantaloupe (my Melona bias) > Honey Comb > Mount Cabot Maple > Honey Berry Chip > Baa Baa Brambleberry >> Sugar Pie Pumpkin Chai (never been a pumpkin ice cream person).
… moreAt first, I thought the high ratings were just people riding a post-hike sugar high (and honestly, that might still be partly true). But most of the flavors I tried were genuinely fantastic. The ice cream flight came out to almost two pints, and even in shorts on a 50°F evening, we wiped it clean in under five minutes.
The flavors weren’t wild or experimental. Everything’s made in small batches, so the lineup seemed to change often. I didn’t see many of the flavors mentioned in older reviews, but 5/6 were hits. The sugar level was relatively restrained (by U.S. standards), so no sticky, sugary aftertaste. Also liked how they made the berry ice cream with yogurt.
Ranking the lineup:
Cantaloupe (my Melona bias) > Honey Comb > Mount Cabot Maple > Honey Berry Chip > Baa Baa Brambleberry >> Sugar Pie Pumpkin Chai (never been a pumpkin ice cream person).
Cole Riel
Had the wonderful privilege of stopping at Super Secret twice in two days on a recent trip! Both times the service and quality was just beyond compare. The staff is kind, knowledgeable, and accommodating. The ice cream is always amazing and features expertly executed twists on common and uncommon flavors.
The Blueberry Basil with a hint of cinnamon and the Slopeside Mint Chip were the standouts for our group. Can’t wait to go back!
… moreThe Blueberry Basil with a hint of cinnamon and the Slopeside Mint Chip were the standouts for our group. Can’t wait to go back!
Mia McDonald
Delicious ice cream. Small menu of local flavors with local ingredients and artisan prices ($5 for one small scoop.) In addition to unique flavors, they also had chocolate, strawberry and an awesome vanilla. I recommend a flight for economy and taste: they don’t have these flavors anywhere else. Try them here!
… moreBill King
Amazing ice cream and waffle cones. We did not get any food just ice cream. Only coffee and chocolate are recognizable. All the others are unique flavors and very yummy.
They will let you taste any or all of them. The waffle cones are delicious.
Highly recommended.
Great service. Best ice cream around.
Today’s flavors in picture below.
… moreThey will let you taste any or all of them. The waffle cones are delicious.
Highly recommended.
Great service. Best ice cream around.
Today’s flavors in picture below.
aa way
We saw that they were a semifinalist for a James Beard award and decided to drive over to have some ice cream. It is SO good! The honeycomb ice cream was great. My favorite was the Meyer lemon and blueberry. Very creamy excellent flavors! The waffle cone chips and waffle cone toffee were great. Definitely recommend stopping here.
… moreJen B.
Super Secret is still as delicious as always, very busy but don’t let the long line scare you, it moves fast
We’ve been back several times and recommended Super Secret to our friends and they all love the amazing flavors; last visit I got Chamomile and Hyssop anise.. so good!!
Even in the winter it’s busy, the flavors are so fresh and delicious!
Omg!! The best icecream ever!! I am an icecream connoisseur and this is one of the very best icecream ever and this is why: homemade flavors, not bought ingredients, their honeycomb is absolutely to die for … Slopeside mint chip is so creamy and fresh, the blueberry sorbet was absolutely phenomenal! The flavors are delicious, the icecream is so creamy, the sorbet was full of flavor, absolutely unbelievable!
Great service. They give excellent recommendations.
Many gluten free and vegetarian options.
Really fun & cool environment.
… moreWe’ve been back several times and recommended Super Secret to our friends and they all love the amazing flavors; last visit I got Chamomile and Hyssop anise.. so good!!
Even in the winter it’s busy, the flavors are so fresh and delicious!
Omg!! The best icecream ever!! I am an icecream connoisseur and this is one of the very best icecream ever and this is why: homemade flavors, not bought ingredients, their honeycomb is absolutely to die for … Slopeside mint chip is so creamy and fresh, the blueberry sorbet was absolutely phenomenal! The flavors are delicious, the icecream is so creamy, the sorbet was full of flavor, absolutely unbelievable!
Great service. They give excellent recommendations.
Many gluten free and vegetarian options.
Really fun & cool environment.
BLT
Our favorite ice cream spot ever!!! This place ruined all other ice cream spots for myself and my family! We drive 2 hours just for their delicious ice cream and waffle cones! Definitely stop in and give them a try. Plus take some pints home for later! We are addicted! Beyond yummy!!!! Can’t wait for our next visit very soon!
… moreHeather Boswick
Amazing & adorable Ice cream shop with all the best vibes & hand made high quality scoops! Super adorbs decor! LOVE that they offer hand made ice cream including vegan! The vegan blueberry was yummy. My partner got their regular cream & said it was perfect! Super friendly staff & welcoming vibes!
… moreHolly B
Some unique and more traditional flavours available but the ones we tried (blueberry pie and raspberry yuzu) were very authentic and tasty. The homemade waffle cone was also very good! They also serve a flight of ice cream in a mini egg carton like container so you could try multiple flavours if you prefer. The establishment is bright and nicely laid out and has a restroom and some activities for kids. There is also a cute, covered seating area outside for warmer days!
… more