Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Snug, casual Italian choice with a warm vibe featuring pizzas, pastas & other traditional eats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 391 Crooks Ave, Paterson, NJ 07503
Phone: (973) 998-9055
Website: http://www.leftysnj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Lefty’s Pizzeria Online Ordering
… Lefty’s Pizzeria 391 Crooks Avenue Paterson, NJ 07503. View Map. +1(973) 998-9055. Print Menu. About Us. A family owned and operated Italian restaurant and …
Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant :: Best American in Paterson
391 Crooks Ave, Paterson, NJ 07503. Lefty’s Pizzeria and Restaurant is known for its Dinner, Lunch Specials, Pasta, Pizza, and Sandwiches.
Lefty’s Pizzeria & Restaurant (@leftys_pizzeria) – Instagram
391 Crooks Ave, Paterson, NJ (973) 998-9055 10am-9pm – MON-SAT Closed Sundays for Italian Cuisine …
Reviews
D. Sanchez
I called to make an order and lady at the phone made fun of me when I ask where do I pick up the order when is my first time to even go to this restaurant. I had pasta meet sauce and meatballs. There was probably not even a quarter of the pasta and 90% sauce. I called and they only said sorry. Nothing offered. Definitely don’t recommend it.
… moreMelissa Santos
The food is great!!!! But if they only knew how to remember to send in your drink every time I order, they forget my soda is ridiculous already I ordered from here cause my kids love it, but sometimes it’ll be nice to have your drink with your meal
… moreAlex Hernandez
First time here, saw this guy’s online and it was the best. Met the owner, really cool guy! The girl cashier was also very nice and recommended me this great sandwich. It’s a great place, great food, great staff. Thanks guys.
… moreBecca Boo
Best pizza in town? Honey, best pizza of my life. That’s coming from a born and raised Jersey girl. Shout out to the man in the back that makes my tri color grandma’s pie PERFECT every time, without fail. My stomach loves you
… moreEJ T.
Refered to this place after complaining there were no good places to eat to a friend. Honesty been eating here once a week since my initial visit. This place has set the standard for Italian. I’m going again today, second day in a row.
Best sandwich’s around. Have almost tried them all. Entrees are equally as good. Can’t wait to try the pizza.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
… moreBest sandwich’s around. Have almost tried them all. Entrees are equally as good. Can’t wait to try the pizza.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
victor reinoso-sosa jr
Back with another BYOB review. I’m sure you haven’t had a better Grandma Pie! I promise you. Lefty’s for decades has been a top 2 pizza spot for Grandma Pies, in my opinion, and today they are clear at #1. A first today was my dine-in experience. Spacious place you can grab a quick slice to-go, also decent amount of tables you can sit down and enjoy a nice dinner with the family. They also offer a full arrange of Italian dishes that smelled great coming out of their busy Friday night kitchen. But we came for the Grandma Pie, and well, it’s never a disappointment.
… moreTony Rame
First time customer here. Picked up 2 pies Monday night, regular and one with vegetables. I ordered it crispy and thin. The lady at the counter remembered me when I came to pick up my order and made sure I liked how it was made. I asked for a hot sauce and they quickly brought it. This place is booming and the pizza is fantastic, it exceeded my expectations. I had no idea that all their meats are non pork products and will definitely be back ordering a pepperoni or sausage pie. Their pizza is fantastic and so is the staff.
… moreCarma
Definitely didn’t live up to my expectations. I ordered ahead for lunch the order was almost 20 minutes later than the expected delivery time. The food was definitely not worth the wait. I ordered the eggplant panini with fries. The fries were cold and not fresh. They tasted like they were thrown back into the grease to reheat them. The eggplant in the sandwich was soggy and bland. I was expecting fresh food. I could tell it has been frozen and thrown in the oven to heat. I was very disappointed in the quality of my meal. On top of that to have had to wait an additional 20 minutes for mediocre & cold food does not make me want to order again.
… moreYvette Marin
Best Pizza and Amazing Staff. Born and raised New Yorker, Jersey is home for last 15 years so I have had my share of great pizza and Lefty’s is Outstanding and the people top notch. Go and try it. You’re Welcome!!
… moreSal Alfda
Food was good but i didnt like watching people splitting their tips all over the tables all night long
… more