Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
What happened to My Sister’s Pizza in Winthrop Maine? – Facebook
I called my sisters pizza today and there was a message saying they were closed and sounded like for good. Anyone heard anything about it?
My Sister’s Pizza – CLOSED, 6 Union St, Winthrop, ME 04364, US
My Sister’s Pizza … My Sister’s Pizza located in Winthrop ME is a cozy eatery known for its delicious handcrafted pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. With a …
My Sisters Pizza (@mysisterspizza) · Winthrop, ME – Instagram
117 Followers, 32 Following, 641 Posts – My Sisters Pizza (@mysisterspizza) on Instagram: “”
Reviews
AMIE SHURMAN
Awesome pizza, large selection of favorite meals like chef salad and pasta. Easily accommodate a group of 10 at the 2 large dining tables. 5 private booths are perfect for a family meal or a business meeting. The zen atmosphere is welcoming and the staff is very friendly.
… moreEvan Gerstenblith
They had very good service along with decent food. While I did not eat the food as it was not gluten free, my family said it was great. The lady at the front was very nice and even gave us a large bag of chips for free. According to my family, the salad here is better than the nearby TJ’s pizza, but they like the cheese flavor at TJ’s more. The food seemed to be great quality, and very fresh for the price.
… moreJohn Banville
Before you get blindsided by the price increase make sure you ask. Was expecting to pay around $25 according to the prices I saw online for a 14” pepperoni pizza and a 4 piece chicken tender and fries box. Checking out it was $37.. that was the first issue. Upon getting home and opening the food the fries were burnt and flavorless and almost cold despite living 2 minutes away and the pizza dough was still raw. I do not recommend this place at all. The one star given is being generous.
… moreJennifer
I don’t like writing bad reviews. I hope I found this place on a bad day. I’m not a fan of pizza, but I do love sandwiches. At the time, the place didn’t have roast beef or turkey. I opted for ham. It seemed like it took a while to make a basic ham Italian. The young man behind the counter didn’t seem personable. Again, I probably caught the place on a bad day. Oh, the decor was too much and confusing.
… moreTina Tarbox
I have eaten to many numerous types of dishes and both hot and cold sandwiches from My Sister’s Pizza to even list everything. However…I will say I have never had a bad experience with the food or the waitress/wait staff. I find the service phenomenal from start to finish each and every time. The food is always on time and prepared to perfection. I know when I’m told that it’s a 50 minute wait…there’s a good damn reason…they are very busy, so place your orders according to the time you like having your lunch or dinner. Don’t wait and call when your famished and be upset because you have to wait. Anything good is worth waiting for. Enjoy the delicious food that the kitchen staff works so preciously on to appease everyone’s appetite.
… moreConni Ault (Itsy)
Come in from out of town and the first thing we are hit with is the MASSIVE smell of weed the minute you open the door then proceed to just go next door to the tavern instead where the smell is of stale beer and mold instead of a bar.. we give our order of some drinks and food which was to be prepared from the other side (weed smelling place) and end up waiting over an hour and a half for our food to the point we have to go ask and they come over saying we never ordered! Lol! Which we then reply with ask your bartender here who was all kinds of lost when asked! I then tell my other half to just go wait in car and I’ll go deal it just to find out it still wasn’t ready and they billed us incorrectly! So for $75 we got a 14’ gas station pizza and some wings and mushrooms….. unbelievable! Their comment was if if we wanted McDonalds service we should’ve asked! As out of towners we expected much better service than that but in the end I think McDonald’s would’ve served us much better had they even had one in this ridiculous town or village or whatever this is!
… moreDouglass Bronk
Took an hour for Pizza & wings. Got home, pizza was still RAW in the middle.
The lady who owns the place was terribly rude and tried making excuses why it took so long.
The food was DISGUSTING. Also $48 a 14″ pizza & wings !! Wow !! Ridiculous!! I hope she goes out of business soon
… moreThe lady who owns the place was terribly rude and tried making excuses why it took so long.
The food was DISGUSTING. Also $48 a 14″ pizza & wings !! Wow !! Ridiculous!! I hope she goes out of business soon
Kyle Contento
Best pizza in town, and worth traveling for. Their steak bomb is fantastic. They mix the cheese with the chopped steak as they fry it, it comes out great. We had them make a steak and cheese pizza with onions and a little mayo and it was the best cheese steak pizza I have ever had!!
… moreKyu Wolf
This restaurant has some amazing nachos, some of the best I’ve ever had. And the steak bomb was delicious. Obviously try the pizza, but come back and give the other items on the menu a go. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreKatelyn Rioux
Pizza was good, waiter was rude. Terrible customer service. Food all came out separately and took over a half hour to come out (it happens, not a huge dealbreaker), but no check ins for refills during that wait and the few interactions we did have with our waiter were not pleasant. Might have gone back regardless of the slowness, however the waiters attitude ensured that will not be the case.
… more