Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Modest pizza, sub & wing specialist with an all-you-can-eat buffet, TVs for sports, beer & wine.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1245 E 2nd St, Jamestown, NY 14701
Phone: (716) 665-2555
Website: http://honestjohns.pizza/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Honest John’s Pizzeria – Pizza Delivery, Pizza, Wings
Order online from our very own site and NOT Door Dash or Slice and save 15%. Join our VIP Rewards and get free stuff! Pizza Wings Pizza Delivery Jamestown.
Honest John’s Pizzeria 1245 East 2nd Street – Order Online
Honest John’s Pizzeria. 1245 E 2nd St, Jamestown, NY 14701, USAOnline ordering hours: 10:30 AM – 8:35 PM.
Honest Johns PDF Menu
Honest Johns PDF Menu … Credit/Debit Card Prices! … Buffet hours may vary based on holidays, staffing, etc. Powered by.
Reviews
Michele D. Starwalt Woods
Lovely and helpful server, great food, Mom & Pop atmosphere at its finest! Awesome place to stop after visiting The National Comedy Center.
… moreJeremy French
Took the family for the first time a New Year’s Day 2026.
We got in order food we ordered pizza and chicken wings.
In the meantime they got very busy. Our food was brought out in a timely manner. The chicken wings were incredible. The pizza was a little undercooked.
But still was quite good.
I’d say all and all it was quite good definitely worth another visit prices were very reasonable and the service was good. Worth your time to try
… moreWe got in order food we ordered pizza and chicken wings.
In the meantime they got very busy. Our food was brought out in a timely manner. The chicken wings were incredible. The pizza was a little undercooked.
But still was quite good.
I’d say all and all it was quite good definitely worth another visit prices were very reasonable and the service was good. Worth your time to try
Allison Fowler
The gluten free pizza crust was so deliciously light, airy and crispy that I had to check to make sure I got the right pizza. It turns out it was just that good! Service was great, atmosphere is nostalgic, prices were very affordable. We will definitely make a trip here whenever we are near Jamestown.
… moreLJ Metzger
Updated review! May 2024
4.5 star! YUMMY!
Super friendly staff that are attentive, helpful, and fast.
Amazing pizza buffet,penne pasta, stuffed pepper soup, salad bar, dessert pizza, and wing refill. Everything was delicious!
Only slight thing was the first batch of wings that were in the buffet were on the drier sauce side and softer side when we first got there. I asked for Buffalo sauce they gave me to dip in which was so good! This is only a preference thing on my end. They had a great flavor though and 5 minutes after we got there they were replaced with absolutely perfect saucier hotter crisper wings we went nuts over. Such perfect wings!
I highly recommend the buffet. Perfectly priced buffet value.
I hadn’t been there in over 3 years because of a bad takeout experience with teenagers running it. I think it was a fluke experience. I’m so glad I stopped back in because the staff were perfect this time. The pizza was so much better this time too. I couldn’t be happier. I’ll be back for sure.
5 star staff
5 star freshness
5 star cleanliness
5 star nice casual atmosphere
4.5 star food
5 star location
5 star price
3+ years ago: 2.5 star.
Staff are pretty rude or impersonal sometimes. There is a long wait time on mediocre to average gas station quality pizza. Good wings though.
… more4.5 star! YUMMY!
Super friendly staff that are attentive, helpful, and fast.
Amazing pizza buffet,penne pasta, stuffed pepper soup, salad bar, dessert pizza, and wing refill. Everything was delicious!
Only slight thing was the first batch of wings that were in the buffet were on the drier sauce side and softer side when we first got there. I asked for Buffalo sauce they gave me to dip in which was so good! This is only a preference thing on my end. They had a great flavor though and 5 minutes after we got there they were replaced with absolutely perfect saucier hotter crisper wings we went nuts over. Such perfect wings!
I highly recommend the buffet. Perfectly priced buffet value.
I hadn’t been there in over 3 years because of a bad takeout experience with teenagers running it. I think it was a fluke experience. I’m so glad I stopped back in because the staff were perfect this time. The pizza was so much better this time too. I couldn’t be happier. I’ll be back for sure.
5 star staff
5 star freshness
5 star cleanliness
5 star nice casual atmosphere
4.5 star food
5 star location
5 star price
3+ years ago: 2.5 star.
Staff are pretty rude or impersonal sometimes. There is a long wait time on mediocre to average gas station quality pizza. Good wings though.
staticbird11
Nice place. The staff was awesome… mostly. I went to pay and asked if it was the same price cash or credit and the answer was “You can pay either way” WRONG! After I got the receipt i saw that she added 10% for the credit card. Why not have a sign at the counter saying this? This kind of thing is a factor in whether or not peo ok e return. The buffet was pretty good. They had the salad bar this time, but the price went up from last year. The wings, pizza and ice cream were all very good and new stuff was brought out often.
… moreMonroe Huckaby
First time to enjoy the wings at Honesty John’s. My inlaws eat here on a regular basis with the waitress recognizing them. We had the buffet with included the pizza, Buffalo wings, pasta, etc., and a separate salad bar. The pizza had nice flavor and there were two different type crusts. The thicker crust had a bit more crunch and was my favorite. The wings were the real star. Not all hot wings are cooked with respect. These were crispy yet not over done and had a balanced sauce with a medium heat. There were several other dishes, a pasta, a rice, baked chicken, mashed potatoes and gravy, also on the buffet. The blue cheese dressing was good and chunky and the ranch dressing is house made with a nice dill flavor. I’ll plan to return on my next trip. There is a second location in Lakewood and I’m told the quality is very good there too.
P.S. A small after meal ice cream sundae is offered and was a sweet way to finish our meal.
… moreP.S. A small after meal ice cream sundae is offered and was a sweet way to finish our meal.
Elisha Whitacre
Ordered from honest John’s tonight my partner took a bite out of her pizza and there was a long hair embedded in the cheese probably about 8 inches long. Absolutely unacceptable restaurant should be wearing hairnets. Did contact the manager and he is having somebody bring me a full refund which was over $40 cash update On February 18, 2025 Tuesday I called Ann Jones and tried ordering from them after this incident from three weeks ago the owner banded my partner and I from ever ordering from them again so because of their mess up, and because they had hair in the food, we are banned from ordering from them
… moreKingyuon Obryant
I absolutely love there starline steak stub omg it so delicious thats my favorite sub there so far. Thay make it really good.
… moreJohn Rachuna
Senior buffet includes drink and ice cream sundae for $12.99 cash. Good fresh salad bar with limited options, but it is always fresh. Buffet offers pizza, chicken wings, chicken tenders, baked chicken, sides, soup, desert pizza, fried dough nuggets.
… more