Brooklyn Pizzeria

Bay St. Louis; /; Brooklyn Pizzeria. Restaurant banner image. Italian. Brooklyn Pizzeria. 295 US Hwy 90. Bay St. Louis, MS 39520. Orders through Toast are …

Brooklyn Pizzeria of Bay Saint Louis – Facebook

Brooklyn Pizzeria of Bay Saint Louis, Bay Saint Louis. 5366 likes · 97 talking about this · 2467 were here. Slicing up New York style pizza in Bay St….

Reviews

Valerie Dale

Very good pizza and calzones for a reasonable price. Would love to try the lasagna in the future as it is on one of the daily specials. Perfect for our family of eight. Great customer service and easy location. Blessings for 2026.

… more

Gary v

I’d skip the meatball appetizer, the meatballs taste like frozen, and the garlic knots were hard. But, about that pizza, holy cow, it’s good, real good. We got the medium, not expecting it to be almost as big as our table. Besides the size, it was delicious. Thin crust, cooked perfectly, nice brown undercarriage. Plenty of toppings, you can taste the quality in the ingredients. We got pepperoni, sausage, and onion. Men’s bathroom was a little disturbing, but not too bad. Service was good. At first I thought the price was high, but after getting the pizza, I’d say it’s priced fair.

… more

Brian Hicks

Always try to find a good local pizza place when we are traveling and this place did not disappoint. Ordered 2 large pizzas and wound up taking a whole pizza home to enjoy later. Staff was amazing and place was clean. Would definitely recommend giving them a try.

… more

Jim Giangrosso

First time ordering tonight, OMG, it was sooo delicious, cooked perfectly, everything was fresh, and the large was so big it won’t fit in my fridge…one slice each for my wife & I was all we could eat despite how amazing it tasted!!!
Highly recommend, super nice, and if you’re looking for a great pie, then here’s your go to spot!

… more

Emma

I got the cauliflower crust (it has 8 pieces!) and I got it in the “chicken bacon ranch” flavor. SOOO good! Even better with the “mikes hot honey” on it!! Super delicious I’m from out of town and I 10/10 recommend!

… more

Terry Hebert

This pizza is awesome, the best in town for me, delivered to your table steaming hot, straight from the oven with many condiments available to complement. Brooklyn Pizzeria is renowned for its thin, foldable crusts, rich tomato sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. Whether you opt for a classic pepperoni slice, a specialty pie, or any of their other dishes the flavors are consistently top-notch. Staff were friendly/helpful and beer was cold!! Prices very reasonable. Only pic is of our leftovers!!

… more

Willie Willdogg

Friendly faces everytime I go in. The two-slice special is a go-to anytime. The italian roll is amazing as well. Finish it off with some cheescake. Best pizza in the Bay.

… more

Tineshia

This place has become my favorite pizza joint! I always go for the medium because the crust is just the right thinness—perfect every time. The pizza is delicious, the wings are pretty good (could be a little crispier on the skin, but still tasty), and the pasta hits the spot too. The workers are upbeat and fun… you can even watch them flip the dough in the air if you want a show. They’ve got a few booths if you want to sit and enjoy, but it’s also great for takeout. Overall, awesome pizza and a fun vibe that keeps me coming back!

… more

A Aust

I don’t know about the pizza, but the $15 grilled chicken salad was just edible, nothing special and WAY to many black olives, I had to pick about half a jars worth out to taste anything besides black olives. The grilled chicken was pretty bland and very mediocre. Definitely not worth the price. Also, stop asking people to tip on to go orders. Pay your employees.

… more

Tina Weller

The pizza, lasagna, and garlic knots are fabulous. The dough and sauce are wonderful. I grew up in an Italian household and I don’t like any other pizza but this was amazing 100 percent fabulous.

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results