Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Vibrant space for Mexican fare, margaritas & happy hour, plus a weekday kids-eat-free special.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 205 W Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066
Phone: (315) 632-4789
Website: http://papagallorestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Fayetteville’s Papa Gallo closed, but a new Mexican-Peruvian …
As Papa Gallo Restaurant in Fayetteville closes, new Mexican-Peruvian concept moves in … Fayetteville, N.Y. — Papa Gallo Restaurant …
Papa Gallo Mexican Restaurant | Fayetteville NY – Facebook
Papa Gallo Mexican Restaurant, Fayetteville. 3656 likes · 1 talking about this · 8306 were here. Serving house made Tex-Mex cuisine with an ecclectic…
Popular Fayetteville Mexican restaurant closes abruptly – WSYR
A popular restaurant in Fayetteville has served its last meal. Papa Gallo Mexican Restaurant, located at 205 W. Genesee Street, …
Reviews
Jennifer Tedesco
Wonderful Vibe the minute I walked in the door! Food was delicious served in a timely fashion! Kitchen staff extremely friendly! Bartender so cheerful and very knowledgeable! Definitely will be visiting again soon!
… moreCaitlin
Very good, fresh mexican food. Have Been Here multiple times and have never left disappointed. Prices are very reasonable, food is cooked perfectly, and the staff is always friendly and you never have to wait more than a minute for help.
… moreErin Maurno
These tacos were so good and they were able to make them gluten free on corn tortillas!! I visited their food truck at the Clinton Square Food Truck Rally and they were amazing!! The mango was the perfect topping for the pork and as soon as I was done I wanted more. I got the chicken and beef tacos today and they were also fantastic!
… moreNJ DeLapp
Actually got food from the food truck. Ordered the loaded nachos. They were good. Others that were with ordered the burritos & said they were very good. Looking forward to trying the restaurant itself.
… moreLynnette Mourning
Food was good with good service. And my Sister who is gluten free enjoyed her meal.
… moreTrish king
Really good food and nice atmosphere. I ordered the taco salad and the champagne margarita. Both were really delicious and their house made guacamole is very tasty. Our waitress was polite and checked on us enough that it wasn’t intrusive. I’ve had an amazing experience both times I’ve been here. I’d definitely go back!
… moreAlexia Clarke
I ordered fish tacos from them last night I didn’t finish them and today at work I was eating my left over and found a long black hair inside my taco this is very nasty I will never be ordering from this place again I am highly disappointed not to mention I was charged for extra sour cream and didn’t even get extra this is unacceptable and disgusting. HAIR NETS ARE NEEDED
… moreMike Richer
My family and I have been coming to this place since it first opened and it was always our favorite, we truly considered it fine Mexican dining. However, it’s gone down hill in recent years. You use to be able to go in, and order from a fantastic menu with amazing entrees like pollo releno – stuffed chicken breast with crushed house made tortilla chips as the breading. Amazing! Now unfortunately it has changed into just a taco joint. What they do serve is still decent mostly but little things that are different make it a much different experience. The salsa use to be Smokey and delicious, now I would rather get something from a jar than what they are putting out now. The wait staff (specifically the two sisters that work here) is fantastic and everyone is nice, but this message is for the owner in hopes that they realize something is going wrong so they can fix it. This place actually has sentimental value for me, it was the favorite spot for my late wife and I to go. They also advertise that you can place a takeout order up until 830 on Fridays and Saturdays but it sounds like management doesn’t want to be there late so it’s cut off as I call at 7:45 pm on a Friday night trying to get an order of tacos for take out. Looking at other reviews I’m obviously not the only one that feels this way. As a retail business owner myself, I’m taking the business as it comes in and as advertised as I would like to keep my customers coming back for more and stay in business for a while. Fix it guys, you’ve got something good there, but not for long on its current trajectory.
… moreJEFFREY MB
Took my daughter the other night. Had the best waiter and dinner! He helped me pick the best dish for me, and my daughter devoured her cheese quesadilla. The fried ice cream is a must! Great quality food, authentic feel, friendly staff. I would highly recommend !
… morePaige Crittela
First time here (i know shocking). Sat outside, hostess was very friendly. Food was good & fresh. I got Shrimp Taco(3) dinner with black beans & rice. I was shocked they didn’t give you complimentary chips & salsa (that’s a given for me). Prices seem a little higher than what’s given. It didn’t stand out like a real authentic Mexican place. Got a house margarita($10) (no lime) in a little glass. Waiter kept forgetting small things. The outdoor seating was nice. Personally, wouldn’t go back because i think there are some better spots around for the amount spent. Thanks PG
… more