Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A New York-style pizzeria with a friendly & casual atmosphere, Big John’s Pizzeria is known throughout Key West as the go-to spot for locals and tourists alike to enjoy the flavor of handcrafted pizza and classic Italian dishes that keep customers coming back for more. Family-owned and operated since 1997.
Spacious pizzeria provides slices & pies (including a stuffed version) plus signature garlic knots.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1103 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 293-9576
Website: http://bigjohnspizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Big Johns Pizzeria – Key West
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Key West, FL.
Big John’s Pizzeria | Key West FL – Facebook
Friendly reminder, you can schedule your Pick Ups or Deliveries online!! @ BigJohnsPizzeria.com Or give us a call 305-293-9576 … Big John’s Pizzeria is in Key …
Big John’s Pizzeria – 1103 Key Plaza, Key West, FL 33040 – Slice
Specialty Pizza · Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Sliced chicken breast, buffalo sauce + mozzarella, topped with zesty ranch dressing. · White Pizza · Golden BBQ Chicken.
Reviews
Shawna Marie
Wanted to try local pizza. We Ordered a white pizza and an “all the way” pizza along with some mild wings and ranch. 10/10. The pizza is great tasting, not heavy, and well made. I don’t like heavy tomato sauce so this was perfect. Took the pizzas to Ft Zachary and caught the sunset. Great pizza! Would order again!
… moreAdam Bentley
Great and affordable place to grab pizza. 12.90 for a full 12 inch plus a drink if you go between 11-5 every day. Closed on Monday but a lot of places don’t run on Monday in Key West or have limited hours. Waitress staff is always super nice the music is a great Key West atmosphere and never too loud. You don’t have to usually call ahead because your food is made really fast and accurate. Plenty of drink choices Plenty of parking and plenty of tables. Would definitely recommend. Every staff member from the cooks to the wait staff to delivery drivers to management is great. Easily my favorite appace to eat in Key West. Also other options besides just pizza. Deserves more than 5 stars.
… moreTracy Lamarque
I stop here for a slice of pizza, was on my way through the shopping plaza and notice you could buy by the sliver it was delicious. Next time you want some fresh pizza stop here we had a margarita slice with fresh basil and a meat lover sliceStopped by for a quick pizza slice today and it was totally worth it! I noticed they sell by the sliver, which is super convenient when you’re just passing through the shopping plaza. It felt like a real deli experience, grabbing a fresh, hot piece on the go. Definitely a great little find! #PizzaLover #QuickBites #DeliFinds delicious.
… moreJoseph C.
Got the Calzone with onion and sausage to-go. Barely Warm, 90% of crust on top was-gone? Sauce on side was also cold? unsure why. business was pretty, service was good.
… moreJennifer Brasfield
The best pizza in Key West! The blue cheese pizza is my favorite but every single one they have is amazing. The service is always great too!
… moreSecretary
This was a very pleasant surprise and definitely not your typical “pizza shop.” The chicken parm was a generous portion, full of flavor, and very filling. The garlic bites were a nice touch and paired well with the meal.
We also tried the shrimp po’ boy. The shrimp were plentiful and cooked well, though the sauce was a bit overpowering. Lastly, we ordered a large pizza—half plain and half with assorted vegetables and cheese. The pizza was spot on, and the crust was exactly what I was hoping for.
Overall, I’d say give this place a try. Whether you dine in or take out, I think you’ll walk away happy.
… moreWe also tried the shrimp po’ boy. The shrimp were plentiful and cooked well, though the sauce was a bit overpowering. Lastly, we ordered a large pizza—half plain and half with assorted vegetables and cheese. The pizza was spot on, and the crust was exactly what I was hoping for.
Overall, I’d say give this place a try. Whether you dine in or take out, I think you’ll walk away happy.
Adrian Conte Johnston
Vacationing in Key West and looking for a good local pizza joint. Big John hit the spot. Pepperoni pizza was delicious and chicken tenders were great. We did take out but the inside was charming and spacious and looked like a great place for a cozy, no-frills, and delicious meal.
… moreJoe Jones
Was a last minute decision to get pizza. We call and I must say they served a great pizza and fries that made the family happy and bellys full.
… moreDee M
Delish!
I must say we have encountered really terrible service at most every place we stopped at in The Keys. This restaurant was incredible; from taking our order, to serving our food, to saying goodbye.
I like they offer a single slice option. The salad was delicious and of course the mozzarella sticks were, too.
We may go back one more time before we travel back home!
… moreI must say we have encountered really terrible service at most every place we stopped at in The Keys. This restaurant was incredible; from taking our order, to serving our food, to saying goodbye.
I like they offer a single slice option. The salad was delicious and of course the mozzarella sticks were, too.
We may go back one more time before we travel back home!
Rockn’A
We got the Hawaiian, Blue Pie, and the Margarita pizzas.
I loved the Blue pie but no one else in our party liked it. Strong Gorgonzola flavor.
The side salad hit the spot. Skip the prepackaged dressing and go for the olive oil and vinegar.
Garlic knots were also a must!!
Would return, good prices!
… moreI loved the Blue pie but no one else in our party liked it. Strong Gorgonzola flavor.
The side salad hit the spot. Skip the prepackaged dressing and go for the olive oil and vinegar.
Garlic knots were also a must!!
Would return, good prices!