Social Profile: 
… View more
Narrow, pared-down locale offering milkshakes & bubble teas, plus ice creams in mason jars.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 8 Easton Ave, New Brunswick, NJ 08901
Phone: (646) 389-8867
Website: http://www.surrealcreamery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Surreal Creamery & Breaking Batter
Ice Cream, Cake, and Bubble Tea. View Menu. Ice Cream, Cake, and Bubble Tea. Locations. Get Directions or Order Online. NY NJ PA DE.
Surreal Creamery | New Brunswick NJ – Facebook
Details ; . 100% recommend (11 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 8 Easton ave, New Brunswick, NJ, United States, 08901 …
Surreal Creamery – New Brunswick, NJ Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Surreal Ice Cream Specials · Ice Cream Cup · $10.75 · Nom Nom Cookie Mason Jar Special · $13.75 · Chocolate Black Out Mason Jar Special · $13.75 · It’s My …
Reviews
Karthikeyan Rajaram
An ice cream place that’s straight out of a dream world – the artistry that goes into making these ice creams is of the highest order as much as the flavors that they possess.
I’ve not been here multiple times but the only time I got an ice cream from here and it was a yummy Taro in small cup and that too – “To-Go”.
Wish I had my hands on one of those fancy mason jars that a lot of people on their reviews.
The place is well lit with fancy decors but the parking situation will be a challenge as it’s right on the Main Street.
… moreI’ve not been here multiple times but the only time I got an ice cream from here and it was a yummy Taro in small cup and that too – “To-Go”.
Wish I had my hands on one of those fancy mason jars that a lot of people on their reviews.
The place is well lit with fancy decors but the parking situation will be a challenge as it’s right on the Main Street.
Katy Oian
Opened up in Nov 2018, the interior is minimalistic modern with edison light bulbs and a dedicated selfie wall. The menu has literally a bajillion choices for customization.
If you haven’t been here before, the staff is more than happy to provide the grand tour of your options.
1. Pick a base. Cup / cone is standard… OR get a cookie sandwich, donut sandwich, or… ube flan cake?! The cup is obviously meant for 2+ people but ambitious ice cream eaters can attempt serving of 1. Cones look gorgeous in their red velvet / matcha / birthday cake hues, but its difficult to commit to that much ice cream when its below freezing outside.
2. Pick an icecream. There’s more than a half dozen flavors and anything is available for sampling. However, note they’ll mix and soften it so it might not be the same texture as what you tried. And yes rainbow vanilla is just vanilla but slightly more colorful. Past me went for Cookie Monster but Present me would tell myself that the blue mess and blue aftermath is not worth it!!
3. Pick a cereal mix-in.
4. Pick up to 3 toppings (be aware of how easily the extra $$ adds up)
So this part is kind of confusing because cereals can be toppings, and toppings can be mix-ins. Which changes everything. If you are going for the perfect IG picture, you’ll need to think very carefully about what goes where.
But wait, there’s more! They also have edible cookie dough and milkshakes and all sorts of surreal cereal treats for sale. I want to try it all but Future me would not be happy with the extra gym time needed to work it off.
… moreIf you haven’t been here before, the staff is more than happy to provide the grand tour of your options.
1. Pick a base. Cup / cone is standard… OR get a cookie sandwich, donut sandwich, or… ube flan cake?! The cup is obviously meant for 2+ people but ambitious ice cream eaters can attempt serving of 1. Cones look gorgeous in their red velvet / matcha / birthday cake hues, but its difficult to commit to that much ice cream when its below freezing outside.
2. Pick an icecream. There’s more than a half dozen flavors and anything is available for sampling. However, note they’ll mix and soften it so it might not be the same texture as what you tried. And yes rainbow vanilla is just vanilla but slightly more colorful. Past me went for Cookie Monster but Present me would tell myself that the blue mess and blue aftermath is not worth it!!
3. Pick a cereal mix-in.
4. Pick up to 3 toppings (be aware of how easily the extra $$ adds up)
So this part is kind of confusing because cereals can be toppings, and toppings can be mix-ins. Which changes everything. If you are going for the perfect IG picture, you’ll need to think very carefully about what goes where.
But wait, there’s more! They also have edible cookie dough and milkshakes and all sorts of surreal cereal treats for sale. I want to try it all but Future me would not be happy with the extra gym time needed to work it off.
Maryam Mohammed
$10+ for an ice cream but well worth it for the size and quality – if you can finish it! This is a treat every couple of months because it’s just so much lol. The standard soft serve cup easily weighs a pound. Plenty of toppings to choose from and interesting ice cream flavors and combinations. Nice atmosphere and usually bustling! The taro matcha swirl is my favorite flavor. The boba is usually hard/crunchy, I’d recommend staying away from it
… moreMysura Reddy Kuchuru
We ordered the Taro and Chocolate Meltdown Jars(Small). The Taro jar tasted awesome and fresh.
… moreLithe
This place was delicious! The large signature jar sundaes and bubble tea floats are 100% worth the price – you get a ton of ice cream! They are big enough to share with a friend. I had the brown sugar bubble tea with earl gray vanilla on top (please note the ice cream was piled just as high as on the other sundae picture I posted, I just had already eaten quite a bit of it / it sank into my tea as I drank it). The ice cream was so smooth and delicious. And the bubbles were warm and sweet.
My bae is a chocolate connoisseur and loved the chocolate soft serve. It didn’t taste like usual chocolate soft at other places, had a great unique chocolate taste! Said the cocoa puffs were a tasty edition.
Also you can keep the jar, they have lids you can have for free to take it with you without getting messy.
… moreMy bae is a chocolate connoisseur and loved the chocolate soft serve. It didn’t taste like usual chocolate soft at other places, had a great unique chocolate taste! Said the cocoa puffs were a tasty edition.
Also you can keep the jar, they have lids you can have for free to take it with you without getting messy.
Dave Zatorski
Not sure what happened to Surreal creamery but they went downhill from a few years ago. The place is dirty, boxes everywhere, and lackluster customer support. My wife’s ice cream was melted before they even handed it to her! It went all over her dress. Shame. My ice cream had minimal toppings. Completely disappointed. Oh and a waste of money for expensive, mediocre ice cream.
… moreBecky Clark
4.5 stars. Loved the mason jar sundaes! It is expensive, but tasty. They only offer two sizes which are both pricey. There is a lot of ice cream included and I was not able to finish the jar. I had the monster cookie and chocolate. Both were delicious. Service was good, although a tad slow as only one person was making the sundaes. I wish they had more variety. They only have 6 soft serve flavors, 3 of which are for more adventurous eaters. Another bummer was it’s takeout only. Make sure you grab napkins! It was a great treat, but unsure if I would return due to the prices and lack of variety.
… moreJavier Quisbert
I moved to the area 3 years ago and everything I step in the shop I’m greeted by a rude guy with a bull nose ring. This guy is so unprofessional and sassy to everyone. The place used to be clear and the ice cream was tasty, now….not so much.
… moreRobert de Leon
The desserts were well-made and delicious. The place was bustling with college students with energetic music playing. The staff, though pleasant, didn’t go out of their way to make me feel like anything more than a number, as they were busy cranking out desserts. There was a bucket catching leaking water right next to where I was sitting. Still, I would probably come back, being that their ice cream, teas, and cake jars really hit the spot.
… moreNithila
Parking nearby is very difficult to find, so you will have to park further away and walk to the store.
HOWEVER,
This store is amazing!! So many different flavor combos and frozen deserts to try, including boba. There are also a huge variety of toppings (that can be found on the website), so you can fully customize your treat!
The workers are understanding and give out sample cups to try flavors. The prices are so worth it, and theres enough for a few people to enjoy! Overall, a great place to hangout and chill with a cool treat in the summer.
… moreHOWEVER,
This store is amazing!! So many different flavor combos and frozen deserts to try, including boba. There are also a huge variety of toppings (that can be found on the website), so you can fully customize your treat!
The workers are understanding and give out sample cups to try flavors. The prices are so worth it, and theres enough for a few people to enjoy! Overall, a great place to hangout and chill with a cool treat in the summer.