Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 23 Main St Suite 1, Middleport, NY 14105
Phone: (716) 735-9989
Website: https://www.ponysirishpub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pony’s Irish Pub Middleport – Facebook
Pony’s Irish Pub Middleport, Middleport. 6500 likes · 94 talking about this · 79 were here. Restaurant.
Pony’s Irish Pub – A Hidden Gem for Wing Lovers in Middleport, NY
Discover Pony’s Irish Pub at 23 Main St, Middleport, NY, where you can indulge in mouthwatering chicken fingers and incredible wings.
Pony’s – Vibrant Bar & Lounge in Middleport, NY for Great Drinks & Fun
Discover Pony’s, a lively bar at 23 Main St Suite 1, Middleport, NY 14105. Enjoy signature cocktails, great vibes, and a perfect night out!
Reviews
Matthew Wetzel
A small town bar to stop in and grab a bite to eat, or have drinks with friends. A friendly spot that was quite lively on a Friday night- nothing was overly great but not bad either. Drinks were fine, and food was good. I felt bad for the bar tender as she was holding down the entire place solo on a busy Friday night- through no fault of her own our service wasn’t great as it took awhile for her to get to tables, understandably however due to the other 30+ customers she was serving.
… moreAriana Antoniou
I recently visited Pony’s and had a fantastic experience! The highlight of my meal was undoubtedly the chicken fingers. They were perfectly crispy on the outside, tender and juicy on the inside, and seasoned just right. Overall, Pony’s delivers on both quality food and a pleasant dining environment. Highly recommended for anyone looking for top-notch chicken fingers and a great place to enjoy them!
… moreNic Graves
Bar was clean and nice. Bar tender was very sweet and attentive. Grill was off at 7pm on a Friday which was pretty disappointing. There was a guy far past his limit that needed to be cut off or asked to leave, loudly singing and walking up and talking to random groups.
… moreS Burns
Nice local bar, but don’t be fooled by the name…..There is no Irish food on the menu. Overall laid-back atmosphere, good service, and good selection of bar food. Highchair and booster seats are available for the little ones.
… moreFrank Robb
Great food, Good pub / sports bar vibe but hey need more TV’s in their dinning area. When your eating you can hear the game but not see it. All in all it’s a decent place in a small town.
… morePatrick Cross
Order chicken wings asked extra extra crispy got them they were kinda soggy and doughy you can get same quality wings at a little Caesar’s even a gas station they are not good quality at all wouldn’t recommend getting wings here only got them because village pizza was closed I’ll drive into town next time not worth it
… moreJames Kaczmarski
Delicious chicken fingers and breaded wings with their own tasty, slightly sweet spin on buffalo sauce!
… moreLeah Farrington
This place is amazing! They have the best drinks hands down! The best food ever!!!!!!! And to top it off they serve these family boxes now. Where you get like 2lbs of tenders, 2lbs of fries, mozzarella sticks, pretzel sticks, definitely enough to feed a family of 5 for less than 60 dollars!!!!!!! I can’t recommend this place enough!!!!!!!!!!!
… morePeggy Garrett
Stopped for lunch New Year’s Eve. Both had cheeseburgers with fries and some mozzarella sticks. Food was hot, cooked well. Waitress/bartender pleasant and prompt checking frequently with us.
Only draw back was a dirty table.
… moreOnly draw back was a dirty table.
Kris Muzzillo
Wow! What a transformation. If you haven’t been since the remodel, I highly recommend you go.
Atmosphere, food and staff – all great. Best fish fry we’ve had this year. Kids rated the burgers and chicken fingers a 10/10. Adults rated the fish fries the same.
… moreAtmosphere, food and staff – all great. Best fish fry we’ve had this year. Kids rated the burgers and chicken fingers a 10/10. Adults rated the fish fries the same.