Rachel Mccauley
We have an MM near us and the food, service, and atmosphere are consistent.
We had Caesar salad, pepp rolls, and a half and half pizza with Super Pepp/Holy Shiitake with added chicken. Our server was attentive. We would come again. Plenty of parking and price was fair.
… moreMarcus Fero
As per our daughter, this is the best pizza place she has been to in her live.
The pizza is really good, other dishes are good aswell.
This is the second Location of Mellow Mushroom we’ve been to. And it didn’t disappoint. Staff was friendly, and even on a very busy day (New Years Eve) we didn’t have to wait for very long to be seated.
… moreAri A
Very friendly staff, ordered a cheese calzone and it was so good and perfectly cheesy with a NIIIIICE cheese pull. Staff Id my grandmother who is 89 which was the highlight of the night!!! Hilarious. Would recommend coming and would eventually come back if I’m in the mood for a good pizza or calzone
… moreLindsey Penrose
We absolutely love mellow mushroom and almost fall out of our seats every time we have the Holy Shiitake pizza. At this particular location, while it was good, it just wasn’t like the location in STL. STL’s location has large, almost peels, of parmesan spread across the top, and it’s that tanginess along with the savory mushrooms that make the pizza to die for. There was no parmesan on this pizza, which while the pizza was still good, it just didn’t hit like the location I go to regularly.
The ricotta on the Great White was nice and the blistered tomatoes were seasoned well and gave a nice sweet tang. It was a more mellow (haha) pizza and not super flavorful like the shiitake, but it was what I had expected it would be. The basil could have been a bit fresher and more aromatic, though.
The ambiance was nice. We came during lunch on a weekday, so it wasn’t super loud.
… moreMelody Myers Grochowalski
I would’ve rated this higher but just couldn’t bring myself to since 4 out of the 5 things we ordered were 3/5 or less.. the best thing we ordered was the shiitake mushroom pizza, I loved the taste but definitely wasn’t worth $15 for a small. My husband had the small meaty meat pizza, which was worth maybe $7-9 at most.. just an “ok” pizza. The cheesy garlic bread was very tasteless and made very lazily… like they just baked some sub like bread and threw some cheese on it.. and as for the “new” lemon peppered wings… they didn’t know how to work a fryer. My husband had a beer which was good though.
Overall 3/5 and probably won’t be back. Wayyyyyy overpriced too. My husband would’ve rated this lower than me… if I ever did go back with some friends I would definitely get the shiitake mushroom pizza again though and that’s it.
… moreLaci Michels
We had tried Mellow Mushroom at The Island location in June of 2020. I had the Holy Shitake pizza and remember it being so good that I had trouble stopping. I was happy we were making the trip back down to TN (we come about once a year) because I had been craving a really good pizza. We were going to grill at our cabin for dinner but a rainstorm canceled those plans and we ended up at the location right on the strip. As soon as we walked in I looked over at the huge fireplace and it was filled with glitter lamps. Loved that. The atmosphere is kind of what you’d expect “trippy hippie colors and vibes”. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. I ordered my Small Holy Shitake pizza. My husband ordered the Mighty Meaty and buffalo wings. We shared the large Greek salad. My pizza was everything my memory said it was. And the salad hit my Greek Salad craving perfectly. My husband said the wings were delicious but he wished he’d gotten the hot buffalo. He said the original just didn’t have any kick. He enjoyed his pizza. I’m glad our grilling plans got put off because I was soooo pleased with our meal.
… moreCharles Jolly
Stopped in our favorite PF pizza place. Great pizza once again. Our server was outstanding. She had pink hair. Wished there was one in our Chicagoland. MM pizza is different.
… moreAndrew Smith
Great service and atmosphere. Destiny was awesome. Food was good but pretzel bites are misleading. Not actually pretzels. More like pizza crust.
… moreMiguel Sanabia
Family was super hungry and craving good pizza. Stopped here on a recommendation and glad we did. Plain cheese was so good. Only regret was not getting more with toppings.
… morevwjlis
We ordered two 10″ pizzas and they turned out OK. They just weren’t as flavorful as I remember Mellow Mushroom to be (I used to live down the road from one in Pooler, GA.)
The service was great though. The two ladies we interacted with were very polite.
The place is a bit dirty. The drink station looked like it hasn’t been wiped down all day and it was a mess.
… more