Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Cristy’s Pizza East and Tiki Grille in Lancaster, Ohio offers dine-in, carryout, and delivery for a variety of menu items beyond their normal menu of loaded and original pizza. This unique location offers appetizers, calzones, oven-baked subs, sandwiches, burgers, and even homemade desserts. They also boast a full sit-down bar with beer, wine, liquor and cocktails, making it a great destination for a casual dining experience. The location is well marked and easy to find on Tiki Lane, and is known by residents as one of the most popular local pizza shops in Lancaster, Ohio.
Unassuming eatery for pies, salads & subs, plus beer, wine, cocktails & a small outdoor patio.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cristy’s Pizza – Lancaster, Ohio
Cristy’s Pizza at Tiki Lane in Lancaster is proud to serve up fresh, made-to-order pizza with fast, friendly service. We offer pickup and delivery.
Cristy’s Pizza – Lancaster, Ohio
Been searching for pizza places in Lancaster, Ohio? Cristy’s Pizza is your ideal location for dine in, carryout, and delivery, as we offer tasty pies, …
Cristy’s Pizza: Your Favorite Local Pizza Shop in Southeast Ohio
Order online and see for yourself! Get pizza delivered in Amanda, Baltimore, Lancaster, Circleville, Chillicothe and Logan. You deserve it!
Reviews
Marsha Bailey
I ordered a gluten free (cauliflower crust) pizza with cheese and pepperoni. It was so good. Edge to edge toppings and lots of sauce which I love. My husband ordered a calzone. It was loaded with toppings and cooked to perfection!! Would definitely recommend and would visit again!!
… moreTammy Mendoza
I am from the Southside of Chicago where we love and pride ourselves on deep dish pizza thats 2nd to none. However, Cristy’s Pizza in Lancaster, Ohio has sets itself apart for me with thier focus on fresh ingredients, a unique crust that is baked to a beautiful golden buttery brown with a perfect consistency of thick and doughy., Although it is in a class of its own I could described as being in the group of others that included a Sicilian or Detroit-style pizza. For our first visit we ordered a med size Goliath Pie with an extra 3 cheese blend and pepperoni that was as big asy hand. It was absolutely incredible, we were seated fast, the staff was so friendly, it was really clean, our order came out fast and the quality of all the above easily surpassed our expectations given the value of how little the charged for a freshly made product. Just to top it off they also offer gluten-free options, including a cauliflower crust and a thick gluten-free crust. This being only the tip of the iceberg though they have a very extensive menu with something for everyone. I know we will be visiting many more times to come and Christy’s Pizza is a place we would recommend as a must visit for anyone I’m sure they will shot up to one of your top five-star favorites too.
… moreMydivot
We ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and a pepperoni and cheese pizza.. the pepperoni pizza had hot honey on it that we didn’t order. We are not a fan of sweet pizza!! Do better and take the time to get the customer’s order right! The woman at the register said “it’s been crazy “ when we arrived to pick up our order. I’m not surprised if the customer doesn’t get what they ordered. Also there was a black hair on one of the pizza slices!!! We will be looking somewhere else for take out pizza.
… moreKyle Skaggs
Stopped in try some of the food and seek possible employment through on the job training. The food was incredible and every member of the staff was very inviting, warm, and great. They work like a well oiled machine! Keep it up, everyone.
… moreMatt Fink
This place is always on point. Have yet to experience a bad visit. Wait staff is polite and prompt! Food is always the same great quality! Highly recommend
… moreJerry Hinkle
The pizza was extremely greasy. I put the box on my seat for a 5 min drive and grease ran all over my seat. The crust was saturated with grease. I didn’t get the two ranch sides that I ordered and paid for. Plus the pizza was 10 minutes passed the time it was supposed to be. All around bad experience.
… moreRJ Cordova
Boom Boom Bacon Cheeseburger. Add an extra patty. Absolutely fantastic. Tastes like it came off the grill at your best friend’s backyard BBQ. Staff was fantastic also
… morejess frank
Turn over rate is noticeable. That’s my only complaint. You never get the same pizza made the same way when you order. It’s like playing Russian roulette with them. Light sauce doesn’t mean drown the pizza in more sauce, please. Anyways only bad complaint. Service is extremely amazing. Shout out to a great server at East Christy’s who has been there a while. Melissa (with long brown curly hair in a ponytail). She has always gone above and beyond for her customers. Will return a lot. Cristy’s classic is my favorite pizza from there. This has been and always will be a staple in this community forever. One of the best pizza places in town.
… moreE Holdren
I’m in love with one of the gm’s at the east Lancaster location and have been for about 20 years and I blew it, so now I have to live with. Great pizza though.
… moreCarrie Smith
We eat Cristys pizza all the time. But when you order over 50 dollars in food and you get a Philly steak pizza and it has no steak. And yes I have a picture of it. Please do better
… more