Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Eddie’s Pizza is an family friendly bar and restaurant founded in 1931. The food is High Quality, healthy and affordable. Eddie’s famous Bar Pie pizza is a thin crust pie that can be customized with a variety of options including Gluten Free slices. Eddie’s also features other popular bar food options such as Burgers and Chicken Wings.
Vintage local joint serving up thin-crust pizza, including personal “bar pies,” in a basic setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2048 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: (516) 354-9780
Website: http://www.eddiespizzany.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Eddie’s Pizza
THE RESTAURANT … Contrary to the clock on the wall which reads 1941, Eddie’s Pizza was opened in the early 1930’s. Eddie’s perfected a pizza to be both high in …
Restaurant – Eddie’s Pizza
A 10″ Eddie’s Personal Pizza is only 270 calories. Location. 2048 Hillside Ave New Hyde Park, NY 11040 516-354-9780. Amenities. Full Bar Waiter Service Group …
Eddies Pizza (@eddiespizza) · New Hyde Park, NY – Instagram
Photo by Eddies Pizza on February 22, 2026. May be an image of. OMG! Hot wings, cold beer on a snowy day. Yes we are open and having fun. Photo by Eddies …
Reviews
Jodie Simpson
I been going to Eddie’s since I was a little boy… no joke! My parents use to own a shop nearby and it was great, don’t let this place fool you, looks like some typical pizza joint – nah, this place has some amazing history and is a bar pie place and has some amazing food. The chicken dishes are amazing, you can get cherry peppers on your bar pie which make it very amazing. Every waiter and waitress here is super nice and kind. They have a jukebox, this place feels like a gangster hangout and it is amazing. Awesome old movie posters on the walls, this place is great! It is very nostalgic for me at 25 years old but this place also rubs my heart that this is what old NY was like, this place gives off that vibe of a NY very long gone… We can cheerish and enjoy it here.
The food is great, the vibe is great, everyone is great. I am unsure if the man with grey hair works here still but he was amazing also such a funny kind guy. TRY THIS PLACE! Have a coors and relax and feel like you’re one of the gangsters who would import it illegally to the East Coast back in the day 🙂
… moreThe food is great, the vibe is great, everyone is great. I am unsure if the man with grey hair works here still but he was amazing also such a funny kind guy. TRY THIS PLACE! Have a coors and relax and feel like you’re one of the gangsters who would import it illegally to the East Coast back in the day 🙂
SmartGames308
The parking lot is so filthy and dirty. Seems like the business does not care about the cleaniless of where their clients park their car before going to eat. There aren’t any public trash cans on the parking lot, which might contribute to the issue. There is no front parking, so people are forced to park in the dirty parking lot
… moreKissy Kat
Best pizza in NY. Our waitress Victoria was accommodating and knew everything on the menu!! It’s nice to see such a nice accommodating person ☺️. 10gold Stars!! Thank you. Will be back, we’re in new jersey, we came here upon recommendation!
… moreMike
The best of the best. Lives up to the hype. If Turtle and Vinny (Entourage) like it, so do I. Try the fried eggplant pizza. You won’t regret it.
… moreAnn Wong (AWong)
Established hole in the wall place. It was my first time. Great pizza. The thinnest crust I’ve ever had, almost like a water cracker. Almost wished it was a tiny bit thicker but not upset over it. Recommend Eddie’s special. Also tried pizza skin & regular bar pie. Eddie’s special had the right proportion of ingredients, so crust held its integrity. CASH Only!
… moreAndy
I don’t usually leave bad reviews, but this place really let me down. The pizza was a disaster — extremely floppy, the sauce tasted like it came straight out of a cheap can with zero flavor, and the dough itself tasted cheap and low quality. I also tried the lasagna and for $18 I was given a tiny sliver that was nowhere near worth the price. The garlic knots were undercooked and doughy in the middle, which just made things worse.
The staff themselves were fine — friendly and trying their best — but the storefront has a literal hole and has gone downhill so badly. Unfortunately, the food is just terrible and not worth coming back for.
… moreThe staff themselves were fine — friendly and trying their best — but the storefront has a literal hole and has gone downhill so badly. Unfortunately, the food is just terrible and not worth coming back for.
Brian Whitaker
We’re going here for over 30 years. Very disappointed the other day as the waiter barely Spoke to us and the bartender wanted nothing to do with us.
I understand people have bad days.
I tried several times to talk to the bartender with the ponytail asking about the history of the place and he really wanted nothing to do with me
… moreI understand people have bad days.
I tried several times to talk to the bartender with the ponytail asking about the history of the place and he really wanted nothing to do with me
Cinncinn27
Everything was delicious. Our waiter Jose was very nice! Pizzas are always top notch and the thin crust is my absolute fav!!
… moreCrystal Leung
We ordered the Eddie’s Special large pizza to take out. This is definitely one of the best thin crusted pizza I’ve had in New York! There’s a reason why this place has been around for almost a century!
… moreMicheal Parksdubose
I’ve been eating pizza here since high school 30 plus years ago and it’s even better now!
… more