Howie Wills
Id say that I probably order a pizza every 2 months on average. Always a large sausage for carryout. The price was always $12. Good deal. Tonight I order the usual and the price is now $18. That’s a pretty steep increase in price. I get it, everything is going up price wise. But a $6 hike is a little much. Nor going to say I’ll done ordering from them but I am gonna be ordering less than usual.
… moreDeclan
Got a Meatball and Parmesan Sandwich w/ a Pepsi before my haircut. Probably one of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had at a pizza location. Definitely plan on going again.
… moreKyle McClanahan
Great Pizza. Fast Service.
Seriously though – From the minute I placed the order up until delivery: 21 minutes. I considered knocking a star for the dough..I have a feeling it has to do with how quickly they cook the pies, and it could have been a tad crispier – but my air fryer can take care of that! 🙂
The pizza itself was delicious. I ordered online for 20% off my order, and I got the All-Meat Large, half Cheese only. The meat is juicy and fresh, and doesn’t fall all over the place with each bite you take.
Cheese is perfectly cooked, down to the light brown bubbling on the mozzarella.
12/10 will order again. Prices are $1 less per pie VS Pizza Hut. No-Brainer.
I doused my pie in Parmesan when I first got it – just FYI for photos lol.
… moreLeeAnna Bohnert
Absolutely delicious!! First time ordering and they hit it outta the park! We got the Alfredo Chicken & All Meat. Called ahead they said 15min was done on time and it was hot, fresh, and sooooo good!!!
… moreEric Sands
My wife and I Ordered a pizza, the driver started walking up the driveway but turned around like she was going to leave until she saw me standing at my doorstep. Then the driver came to the door and said she went to the wrong door and someone tried to sign it and take the pizza. She then said she forgot a pen and was trying to find the pen. She asked me if I had a pen she could have. And then she found a broken pen, she then broke the pen in half making me sign the receipt with only the ink stick (that’s inside the pen). Didn’t think anything of it and went to go enjoy it. There ended up being hair in the food. My wife has long curly black hair and I have curly blonde hair. And there was a white hair in my food. No animals made that clear to them. I called them and they said the driver had to come back and “ inspect” a pizza for the hair? Then 30 minutes later, no one shows up. I called them again, they acted dumb like they didn’t know what I was talking about. They put me on hold twice, then seemed to transfer the call just to answer it again like a new guest. They said the driver would be 5-10 minutes but now it’s 20 minutes.
… moreMailee Vyne
I wanted to try this place for the first time. It looked good. But when I got home and took a bite. Everything was sliding off the super thin crust with very little sauce. It’s not worth my time at all. I ordered regular crust too. It was so weird. This is pizza??
… moreBecky Alonso
Good pizza, nothing crazy just pizza. I had a medium stuff crust pepperoni, sausage, spinach, bell peppers, olives, and tomatoes. When I went to go pick up it was just 1 guy doing it all, im sure he was under alot of stress with the amount of orders, there were a few of us waiting. But he was nice when I went in to pick up my order. If you just want a solid pizza with no gimmicks this is it.
… moreJaeleen “Sh1tSh0w8.7.3” Zurfluh
Nite time is the right time to order from Muldoon Sicily’s. The notes devoured an XL before I could even start eating
… moreitsSukl
Came in for the first time and got an xl pizza with cinnamon sticks and when I opened the pizza there was hardly any pepperoni I was shocked less than 10 for an XL size I’m sorry but what the hell? And it was super flat but a lot of cheese, the cheese slid off the thin crust when i picked it up and itvwas extremly floppy and folded so easy if i didnt hold up the entire piece but since I was hungry l ate a couple slices and was not worth the price you charge, I would’ve been better off going to dominos or little Caesars and it would’ve tasted better than what I had today costing less than the pizza and “cinnamon sticks” combined. On to the “cinnamon sticks” if you can call it that it was just a round flat bread covered in cinnamon sauce not cut up into sticks at all so it was just thin (like the pizza) cinnamon bread that was tough to chew through. I don’t ever write bad reviews or complain but if you’re charging prices similar to Pizza Hut and are worse than Little Caesars in taste I’m going to complain
… more