Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2285 W Harrisburg Pike, Middletown, PA 17057
Phone: (717) 944-6979
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Nonnie’s Subs | Middletown PA – Facebook
Nonnie’s Subs, Middletown. 933 likes · 119 talking about this · 16 were here. FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED SINCE 2025.
Order Nonnie’s Subs – Middletown, PA Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Nonnie’s Subs at 2285 W Harrisburg Pike in Middletown. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Nonnie’s Subs (@nonniessubs_middletown) – Instagram
FAMILY-OWNED & OPERATED ❤️ 2285 W Harrisburg Pike, Middletown, PA 717-944-6979 ⏰ Tues–Sat | 10:30 AM – 6:30 PM. Photo by Nonnie’s Subs on March 21, 2026.
Reviews
Joshua Knoll
Depends on what map you look at this can be a bit off. This place is located across the street from McDonald’s in the little strip mall. Now onto food review. If you have a larger order I recommend calling ahead. Gives the employees time to prepare the food especially during lunch hours. They do have chips and drinks however I recommend calling to double check availability (it can vary) depending on hours. Now as for the hoagie/sub/hero itself. I got the non seeded roll it was very fresh. They do have different cheeses to choose from. I always get the standard Ham & Cheese sub for my reviews. I personally liked that all the meat was hand sliced and not pre-packaged or already sliced. Made to order and it was very good. Please give the workers the benefit of the doubt as they are still trying to get the systems in place for the orders they get. So if they skip on something. No need to write a bad review tell them about and so they can make sure it’s done correctly for the next time.
… moreTimothy Wells
I was in the area for work and found this gem! They just opened up in the past few months and they are killing it. I got a beast of a hoagie on a seeded, crusty roll. All the meat is sliced for each person. The price is right and will definitely be back!!
… moreTeresa
The hoagie was seriously amazing! So good! I got the #21 Roast beef w/aged provolone on a seeded roll, they do not skimp on the meat at all, And, they slice the meat fresh as well!!! I’m an hour away, but I will definitely make sure I hit that place somehow on my way home! And the owner, Joe, such a nice guy!
… moreChuck “Q” Luongo
One of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had! Normally I don’t like going out for a sandwich because it’s never as good as the one I can make at home but this was the exception. The quality of the meats and the care that went into crafting it was exceptional! It’s definitely my new favorite spot!
… morekim little
Highly recommend this sub shop. They have amazing Italian subs, fresh ingredients, freshly made. I cant say enough good things about the family that owns it. Very nice and friendly. My husband could eat one of their roast beef subs daily,
… moreJoe Zigmund
I needed a bite to eat before departing my flight at MDT. Found this sandwich spot and so glad I did. They have the best lineup of Italian sandwiches….super fresh bread, veggies and meats. Sandwich crafted on the spot…so delicious. Owners were so nice. Please support this wonderful local business and skip getting a garbage sub at Wawa or Sheetz!!
… moreChrissy Rudy
Grabbed some subs for dinner. Husband got the White house, I got the Italian tuna. Both subs were amazing. Decently priced, and the people were very kind. I have to add in that the shop was very clean and smelled good. We’ll definitely be coming back.
… moreGrace Rico
I have been trying to get to this place ever since it opened and boy am I happy that I did! Between the amazing and personable customer service, quality products, and reasonable prices, you cannot go wrong with any sub on their menu. The bread was fresh, the meat was superb, and the veggies were ripe and delicious. Will absolutely be eating there again!!
… moreMatt Little
Absolutely delicious, literally wouldn’t change anything – this is with “half cheese” and “extra veggies” for reference.
… moreJack Miller
If you are looking for hoagies with quality ingredients, then this is your place. Meat is freshly cut and has flavors you can actually distinguish. Tomatoes that are red and flavorful…not hard tasteless chunks. Buns are good enough to eat by themselves!
… more