Kevin Menard
Falafel was really fresh and tasty, and the hummus delicious as well. Had a taste of the frozen yogurt- really refreshing and delish! Pita very fresh; everything seems really authentic, and meal was satisfying.
… morejill bassi
The owner is so awesome. The place is very clean the food is so fresh and delicious I highly recommend this place
… moreEthan Shibutani
Nice little family owned shop. Got the dynamite pita and it was awesome – a little bit spicy and had crushed Doritos in it which was a great touch.
… moreChris Linteris
Wow!!! We are new to the area and stopped in for a last-minute dinner, and we’re so glad we did!! This is one of the coziest and friendliest, places I’ve been to. The food was perfect- flavorful, healthy, and lots of options. When we mentioned our daughter doesn’t love falafel yet (she’s only 5), she made us a Lebanese cheese bread (not on the menu yet, but it should be) which was very thoughtful and kind. I can’t recommend this place enough!! Thanks for an amazing experience, personalized service, and a delicious meal- we will be back many times next season!!
… moreEddie Celik
Every time I visit Sag Harbor I make it a point to come and eat at What The Falafel. I’ve had almost everything on their menu and I’ve enjoyed it every time. If you’re going for the first time, I recommend getting their spicy sesame pita with a side of fries. The pita sandwich is flavorful and the fries are the perfect side to complement it.
… moreIman A.
So excited to see they’re opening in Sag Harbor! I’ve tried the other locations and it is the best falafel . Very fresh and flavorful!
… moreJoe Bakhash
What the Falafel in Sag Harbor is a hidden gem, offering a delightful blend of authentic and innovative Middle Eastern flavors. Their use of the freshest ingredients, coupled with unique recipes, sets them apart. The onsite freshly baked pita adds an extra layer of freshness to their offerings. What truly sets them apart is their consistent delivery of top-quality food and warm hospitality, turning first-time visitors into loyal regulars. If you’re in Sag Harbor, don’t miss the chance to experience What the Falafel.
… moreTim Amann
Tiny hole in the wall you must try!! Instant Favorite in Sag Harbor. My go to is the Spicy Sesame. The owner and staff are so friendly. The food is out of this world with fresh flavors
… moreSuzanne Borget
I love this place! Such a great addition to Sag Harbor.
I must have their classic falafel once a week! I crave it. It is a friendly, clean and adorable place. Love their fresh, homemade pita! Food is delicious, fresh and healthy!
… moreSisi
I tried the falafel from What The Falafel takeout place, and it was really good! The falafel was crispy outside and soft inside, and the flavors were amazing. They gave me a big portion, and I felt full and happy. The people working there were nice and quick. Now, I always go there for tasty falafel. I also tried their spicy sesame sauce with warm pita bread. It’s so tasty that I could eat it every day with any meal. Highly recommend!
… more