Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Neighborhood bar & grill rotates 30+ taps, including local brews, to pair with basic pub grub.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450
Phone: (585) 377-5450
Website: http://donnellysph.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Donnelly’s Public House – Fairport, New York – 33 Craft Beers on …
Visit Donnelly’s Public House for your favorite craft beers. Fairport’s neighborhood restaurant where friends & family meet for a meal or catch up over a …
Donnelly’s Public House – America’s Best Restaurants
Donnelly’s Public House. Bar and Grill. Share This Restaurant · (585) 377-5450 · [email protected]; 1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450. About Donnelly’s Public …
Donnelly’s Public House, 1 Water St, Fairport, NY 14450, US
Donnelly’s Public House is a cozy neighborhood spot in Fairport, NY that offers a casual dining experience with a variety of food and drink options.
Reviews
Brandon Rehak
Best pub in the area. Food is absolutely amazing and fresh. Beer selection is top notch and the team working there know their beer. Traveling for work and have never had a group make me feel more welcome. Wings are killer and fish fry is worth going for.
… moreDavid Dais
Went here for dinner tonight with my fiancé and it was decent/okay at best. Ordered the buffalo garlic boneless wings for an appetizer and they basically were just covered in got sauce.
For dinner I ordered a burger and she ordered the buffalo chicken salad (mild). My burger was okay but not great. I can tell they used a basic frozen patty because it tasted like it. I have had burgers at other pub places before and they were a lot better than this place.
My fiancé’s buffalo chicken salad was ordered as mild, but was much hotter than she would have liked. Also, looking at my receipt, I noticed an up-charge for fries and gravy that the waiter never mentioned which was definitely not cool. Overall the food was decent, but we definitely wouldn’t come here again.
There was actually a pizza place next door called TK’s and I saw they had great reviews. Will definitely try that next time. Also, there is a public parking lot adjacent to the building.
… moreFor dinner I ordered a burger and she ordered the buffalo chicken salad (mild). My burger was okay but not great. I can tell they used a basic frozen patty because it tasted like it. I have had burgers at other pub places before and they were a lot better than this place.
My fiancé’s buffalo chicken salad was ordered as mild, but was much hotter than she would have liked. Also, looking at my receipt, I noticed an up-charge for fries and gravy that the waiter never mentioned which was definitely not cool. Overall the food was decent, but we definitely wouldn’t come here again.
There was actually a pizza place next door called TK’s and I saw they had great reviews. Will definitely try that next time. Also, there is a public parking lot adjacent to the building.
Keishlah
The appetizers were great! I really Loved the pretzel and it tastes great with a side of cheese if you don’t like the mustard. I also had mushrooms sandwich with fries and it was perfectly cooked and crispy fries. Definitely will be back. The server was so polite and on the ball with everything. Great Food and beer spot.
… moreKyle
The food is good, mostly have wings or a salad. I had a burger in this night it was juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection as was my wife’s. Never have trouble choosing a beer to wash down the food as the selection is always fantastic. I would highly recommend this place if you are ever in the area.
… moreJ.G.
What do you look for in a restaurant?
Consistency.
Donnelly’s nails it every time.
My go-to is Build Your Own Burger (don’t forget the meat sauce).
Chicken wings?
Heck yes.
With football season here, every sunday that has an afternoon game, they got 10 for 10 special – dine in only.
They kill it with the salads too.
Had a 10k race – i’m typically a creature of habit.
But i decided to go crazy, and order a salad instead of my burger.
The Taco salad – probably in my top 3.
The service – amazing.
Outside seating always available.
… moreConsistency.
Donnelly’s nails it every time.
My go-to is Build Your Own Burger (don’t forget the meat sauce).
Chicken wings?
Heck yes.
With football season here, every sunday that has an afternoon game, they got 10 for 10 special – dine in only.
They kill it with the salads too.
Had a 10k race – i’m typically a creature of habit.
But i decided to go crazy, and order a salad instead of my burger.
The Taco salad – probably in my top 3.
The service – amazing.
Outside seating always available.
A S
Cozy public house with 33 beers on tap, daily specials, and a big menu. I got the Buffalo garlic Parmesan wings, which were delicious. Company got the Rueben sandwich and the Don Cubano sandwich. Everyone enjoyed themselves and their food. Pretty quiet spot with a few patrons around late lunch time on a Friday. Good food, great atmosphere. Lower rating on the service as we had various ladies checking in on us so the service was a bit inconsistent – no one checked in after our food arrived. No one came by to see if we wanted more beer, did stop by eventually with a refill of our waters. but quiet time of day so not too surprised.
… moreJennifer
Popular, warm, neighborhood pub. Staff is so welcoming and friendly, everyone feels like an old friend here. It’s nice for families, couples, and groups. Extensive beers on tap and full bar with skilled bartenders. Good pub food with rotating specials. While I generally have simple tastes in adult beverages, the bar staff has demonstrated skill mixing more complicated cocktails, and depth of knowledge regarding the multitude of whiskeys and craft beers on offer.
… moreSteve R.
People who came in after we ordered got served before us. Our $20 mac and cheese was very light on the specialty toppings, and the noodles had clearly been sitting under a warmer for some time. The outside seating is nice when the weather is nice. We ate on the first floor.
… moreDavid H
Ireland has a home in Fairport and it’s at Donnelly’s Public house. From the moment you arrive it feels like home. Great sandwichs and Chili. You must check it out.
… moreSue Higgins
This was a wonderful Irish pub experience with a fun and varied beer list and delicious comforting filling food. It was so good that I’m coming back with my fiancé.
… more