Relaxed strip-mall eatery turning out NY-style pies, hoagies & classic Italian platters.
Robert Jennings
I was up at Joint Base for a volunteer meeeting. I had plenty of time to go to 3 Brothers Pizza for dinner. I had an amazing Chef’s Salad and a very good Ziti with meat sauce. I brought a friend a couple of slices of pizza that looked good too!
… moreKevin Jarrett
In a word, FANTASTIC! This is the meat lovers pizza, size small, and it was plenty for the two of us. The crust could’ve been a little bit thicker for my taste but it was still delicious and the toppings were amazing. Service was first rate. Great value for the money and overall a wonderful experience. So glad I found this place, just minutes away from the Union Transportation Rail Trail, where we rode earlier in the day. Will definitely be back!
… moreElizabeth Cibotariu
Great pizza! And the Zeppoli ‘s are my favorite. Better priced than any pizza joint I’ve been to lately and the tables and sitting areas plentiful and clean. The service was fast and they are really friendly. I don’t know why more people don’t come here. This place should be packed!
… moreDan Kolansky
My family moved from NJ when I was a teenager. So whenever I’m back in town I try to get some local cuisine. NY style Pizza is really made best in NJ, if you ask me.
I bought myself a “family cheese pizza” thinking it was a large pizza. It was not. That thing was _massive_. It was amazing and I lived on pizza for the entire day. Rip my diet, but so freaking good.
… more#Hashtag SteveJ
Super friendly service, decent pizza with a whole bunch of different styles. Regular pies, Sicilian, pan pizzas, great flavorful toppings and a plenty of them. Other Italian dishes as well as sandwiches. Pizzeria side seating is nice, as well as a dining room on the other side.
… moreSandy Li
Every time we go to Great Adventure, we would make stop at this pizza joint. The deco has a ton of air force pictures with lots of history that speaks to the town. My family (including my picky child) loves the pasta here – which also comes with either a side salad OR garlic bread. Price is reasonable with good portions. I had the garlic and mushrooms pasta while another member had the with linguine with ground up Italian sausage. Kiddo had the child size spaghetti with meatball. We finished EVERYTHING! Will definitely return.
… moreJames Badua
I was only here for a short tdy, but I’ll be sure to return every future visit. Food is excellent, can’t go wrong with any order. They always offer to cut your slice into smaller pieces if you have a kid. Staff really makes you feel like family, even during rush hour.
… moreTheodore Gibbons (Kurt)
Another winner from 3 Brothers Pizza, Cookstown,NJ
Serving the local area and our active-duty military for over 40 years! Thank you! Great sauce and REAL cheese. The dough is absolutely delicious. A fold-over to eat classic style. Be sure to check them out!!
… moreCheryl T
Delicious! Pizza by the slice, garlic knots, salads , appetizers, burgers! I would definitely recommend it to anyone! The staff is awesome too! They deliver on base
… moreRobert Alvarez
Food was fantastic as always, pizza came out perfect, service was amazing, and I felt like I was eating at a family place. Would recommend stopping in.
… more