Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Little, relaxed eatery specializing in brick-oven pizza, salads & other Italian bites.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 308 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944
Phone: (631) 477-6984
Website: http://www.rollingindoughpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Rolling in Dough Pizza
Rolling in Dough combines two of the coolest inventions: automobiles & pizza.
1943 Pizza Bar (@1943pizzabar) · Greenport, NY – Instagram
6.7K+ followers · 579 posts ·
One Bite You’re Ugly By The Way Pizza Review – – YouTube
One Bite You’re Ugly By The Way Pizza Review – 1943 Pizza Bar (Greenport, NY). 2.5M views · 3 years ago …more. One Bite Pizza Reviews. 1.49M.
Reviews
Anna
Me and my friend were craving pizza so we decided to hit up 1943 pizza. Right off the bat the atmosphere was really nice, it’s a cozy little place and you can see the people making the pizza in front of your own eyes which I thought was pretty marvelous. The first thing I ordered was olives, and when I tell you these olives were immaculate I mean it. PERFECT. Next we ordered a pizza and me and my friend were having a tough time picking out pizza so we asked our sever, whose name is James, to make whatever pizza that he thinks he thinks we like and holy mackerel. I think James got temporary pizza making powers God because that pizza was sensational. Overall the service was top tier. Katy the manager was so so nice and welcoming and Griffin, he’s just a great dude with great hair, and a hardworking dude at that. To sum it up my experience at 1943 transcends all other pizza places I’ve ever been to. Great staff great food and overall a great place. 10/10 would recommend.
… moreTracy Burgess Levy
Cute intimate space with excellent pizza! I’m the WORST with remembering to take pics, so this is our leftover (to go) white pizza with meatballs and mushrooms. One pie is six nice sized slices and plenty to share with a friend!
… moreAmy Kang
This is out go-to pizza spot in Greenport.
This time we had clam pizza and it was so delicious!
Casual atmosphere with efficient service.
… moreThis time we had clam pizza and it was so delicious!
Casual atmosphere with efficient service.
Esfira Shakh
Family weekend getaway could not have started off with a better feeling than a thin crust pizza filled with delicious flavors of pesto and roasted mushrooms over a classic margarita. The ambiance and the outdoor vibe is an added bonus. If you’re out in Greenport you must visit and enjoy this delicious pizza. The salads; arugula and Caesars are both delicious additions.
… moreJennifer Post
By far the best pizza we’ve had in a while across LI. Sat outside on patio on a weeks day, service was adequate but food was top notch. Hands down the best most crispy think crust imaginable. The olives were phenomenal especially bc of the variation in sizes and flavor plus the olive oil was super fresh. Will def go again! Wish they had a full bar. There are nearby bars, surely open on weekends. Prob a great weekend hang out. Yum!
… moreDaniel Lee
I had an absolutely amazing experience at 1943. The ambiance was fantastic, and the food was out of this world. The Harbor ale beer had a whisper of ocean brine, balanced and lovely, pairing wonderfully with the pizza. It had a medium hoppy flavor that was lightly sweet.
The red sauce ricotta, noonas meatballs, onions, and mozzarella pizza was perfection. It was just saucy enough, just cheesy enough, with a thin and crispy crust. The cheese pull was strong, and the crust was light, fluffy, and crispy. The red sauce was full of flavor. The meatballs, sliced like pepperoni, were savory, and the onions added a wonderful touch. The ricotta cheese was like mashed potatoes, simply amazing.
The Margarita pizza was another delight. The tomatoes were fantastic, with the added extras of potatoes and onions balancing the tomatoes’ acidity and sweetness. The bright herbal garlic goodness with the soft starchy added mashed potato was a revelation. The crust was so good, you must make sure to eat it. Note that the Margarita pizza does not come with onions and mashed potatoes as standard, we added those as extras.
Lastly, the outdoor setting on the patio was private and secluded from the sidewalk, great for dog lovers. The indoor setting had a big oven in the middle, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The service was wonderful, kind, and generous, embodying the best of Long Island hospitality. We had such an incredible experience that we came back again the same day. I highly recommend 1943 for anyone looking for a top-notch dining experience.
… moreThe red sauce ricotta, noonas meatballs, onions, and mozzarella pizza was perfection. It was just saucy enough, just cheesy enough, with a thin and crispy crust. The cheese pull was strong, and the crust was light, fluffy, and crispy. The red sauce was full of flavor. The meatballs, sliced like pepperoni, were savory, and the onions added a wonderful touch. The ricotta cheese was like mashed potatoes, simply amazing.
The Margarita pizza was another delight. The tomatoes were fantastic, with the added extras of potatoes and onions balancing the tomatoes’ acidity and sweetness. The bright herbal garlic goodness with the soft starchy added mashed potato was a revelation. The crust was so good, you must make sure to eat it. Note that the Margarita pizza does not come with onions and mashed potatoes as standard, we added those as extras.
Lastly, the outdoor setting on the patio was private and secluded from the sidewalk, great for dog lovers. The indoor setting had a big oven in the middle, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The service was wonderful, kind, and generous, embodying the best of Long Island hospitality. We had such an incredible experience that we came back again the same day. I highly recommend 1943 for anyone looking for a top-notch dining experience.
Tina H
1943 is located in Stirling Square. I’ve eaten here several times already in the last 2 months. The pizza is great. Always made to order. Lots of toppings to choose from. If you are not in the mood for pizza, they have salads and stuff. The pizza is crisp. Many Vegetarian options. Nice wine choices. The space is small so on a busy evening you might need to wait a bit. Very casual.
… moreKaritas Mitrogogos
On my recent visit to Greenport, I had lunch with a friend at this simple but cozy pizza bar … and we really enjoyed it!
Their salad options were very tempting, so we opted for sharing a Ceasar Salad that was tops and one of their delicious brick oven pizzas, with a crunchy thinish crust & yummy topping, that was cooked to perfection.
The service was very friendly and prompt.
… moreTheir salad options were very tempting, so we opted for sharing a Ceasar Salad that was tops and one of their delicious brick oven pizzas, with a crunchy thinish crust & yummy topping, that was cooked to perfection.
The service was very friendly and prompt.
Natalie Sequeira
The staff is warm, the vibe is inviting, and the pizza is consistently exceptional. Always a 10/10 experience.
… morePeter Montalvo
Glad we got to stop here on our trip to Greenport.
It’s a small cozy spot. Very good pies. I come from
NYC where there is some great pizza, and this was pretty good!
I actually liked the meatballs the best! There sauce was top notch!
Overall, we had a great experience here and would recommend going here if you are in the area.
… moreIt’s a small cozy spot. Very good pies. I come from
NYC where there is some great pizza, and this was pretty good!
I actually liked the meatballs the best! There sauce was top notch!
Overall, we had a great experience here and would recommend going here if you are in the area.