Caitlin McElhaney
Archie’s Pizza brings the local, authentic and the funky! No matter what you choose on the menu, you won’t be disappointed. From the pizza to the sides, everything is high quality and delicious! My favorites are the buffalo Ted pizza, garlic knots and the cinnaknots! Easy to order directly from the Autumn Arch taproom or walk in to the pizza shop behind the brewery. Even on opening day, the food came out quickly and was nice and hot! From craft beer to craft pizza, Autumn Arch x Archie’s has you covered!
… moredan vennard
Archie’s Pizza is an absolute gem! The crust is perfectly crisp on the outside with that soft, airy chew inside — total perfection. You can tell every pie is made with care, from the fresh ingredients to the balanced sauce and gooey cheese. The “Buffalo Ted” and classic pepperoni are both standouts, and the garlic knots are unreal.
Bonus points for being right next to Autumn Arch Beer Project — grab a beer, order a pizza, and they’ll even deliver it to your table. Great food, great vibes, and a huge win for Newark.
Plus there is plenty of parking and zero Main Street traffic to deal with!
… moreStephan
There’s a new Pizza Benchmark in town. The team at Archie’s Pizza know that the path to a great Pizza shop following is through your clients’ stomachs. Their pizza is on point. Crust: blistered and crunchy on the outside and full of tender air-floofed dough on the inside. Sauce: tangy with small chunks of real tomatoes. Cheese: gooey and not greasy. Toppings: to die for whether you like your pie simple, or loaded with the goods. Their menu is Pizza centric, and they have small bites and salad. A very good showing for a startup pizza joint. Their ‘Buffalo Ted’ (Buffalo Chicken) Pizza is a new take on the local trend and is – IMHO – the best take yet. Their 3.14 (Pepperoni) Pizza has crispy cupped Pepperoni’s that crunch when you bite into them! If you are looking for something to wash down your Pizza, they are conveniently located behind a brewery!
… moreMichael Auger
The crust was great, crispy with a pleasant chew. The amount of ricotta they put on was perfect for the pie we got. The garlic knots were chewy without being underdone and perfectly seasoned.
For price you are looking at $12-25 per head depending on how much of a pizza you will eat or any sides you get. A bit on the higher end for a pizza night, but I can see myself coming back here around once a month for just pizza. As a pairing to a beer at autumn arch it’s a fine deal for a dinner out
… moreRobert Esswein
Amazing pizza! Definitely recommend Ted’s Buffalo pizza. We ordered from Autumn Arch and the process is easy, and quick!
… moreHeather Ellenberger
Tried Archie’s for the first time. The pretzel and beer cheese were delicious. The pizza is phenomenal and the cannolis are the best I ever had. The service and staff were pleasant and it’s a cool space.
… moreNick
Pizza is amazing. Stopped here on our way home from ocean city. Got a cheese and a pepperoni and both were great. Dough is amazing. Sauce is perfect. 10/10 pizza. The atmosphere is ideal for us, it’s a Saturday evening and there’s literally no one in here, I think there’s a brewery on the other side of the building maybe? But there’s 5 small tables to sit at if you want to dine-in. Otherwise I guess most people carry out or eat at the brewery side. Anyways, great pizza!
… moreDeborah Wood
Delicious! Exceeded expectations!!
Pizza crust was light crispy tasty. Loved the sauce and the pepperoni cups, oh my!
Also had a Caesar salad… dressing light and just right…. very good! And cannolis , yes please! High quality on all. Looking forward to trying more of the menu. Highly recommend.
… moreGoofyJeff
Excellent Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza and the Garlic Knots with Marinara Sauce were outstanding!!! Will be back to try more!!
… moreLindsay Haines
First time here and this pizza was amazing!!! Definitely found our new pizza spot!
… more