Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Bagels your way cafe
Picked For You Acei Bowls Eggs & Omelettes Bagels & Spreads Bagels, Spreads & Dozen Deals Salad Sandwiches.
Order Bagels Your Way – Mount Sinai – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Bagels Your Way at 331 New York 25A in Mount Sinai. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Bagels Your Way – Mount Sinai, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Group Deals & Catering · Dozen Bagels & Spreads · $21.00 · Tray of Scrambled Eggs · $35.00 · Coffee 2 GO · $20.00 · Tray of Home Fries · $35.00. Tray of Bacon.
Reviews
stephen erato
I have been going here for years other places have opened nearby but they are the best. The Bagels and sandwiches are excellent always fresh and tasty. The ladies that work there are great so nice and always pleasant.
… moreKingdom Warrior
I stop here most mornings before work. Their egg sandwichs are some of the best in the area. Their bagels also really good. The staff always smiling and welcoming. I recommend this place to my customers as well when they are looking for a place to eat when waiting.
… moreChristine Averna (CntryLady451)
Parade route made access to my usual bagel shop difficult. I’ve been here before and was very satisfied. Today all the bagels are overcooked and tough. Look forward to getting back to my usual shop (Better on a Bagel in Miller Place)
… moreVincent Malizia
Great bagels with flavor and they’re soft
Staff has been there for 20 plus years
… moreStaff has been there for 20 plus years
C C
Used to love this place, was my go to for an egg sandwich with turkey sausage. Today I received a pathetic sandwich that didn’t taste good at all. They went from a great, full-sized, flavorful sausage patty to these dry, tiny little sausage discs. For the price, not worth it. The saving grace here is the crispy potatoes, still good. Unsure if I will return.
… moreKerry Noyb (Mommabear3boyz)
Staff is always friendly. The food also really good. I highly recommend this bagel shop.
… moreColton Hart
Delicious Affordable 10/10 BCE on a roll every time. Consistently. Perfect break and good portions. There’s this cute little blonde lady who wears a cap and works at the counter, she is DELIGHTFUL!!! So sweet, so helpful and kind and Competent! Perfect go to for breakfast and the quintessential LI/NY deli’s/bagel cafes (oh and did I mention too, the bagels are Fantastic too!)
… moreErik Thompson
Absolutely friendly staff. Bagels are just okay. Much more doughy than it should be with too soft of a crust. They either don’t properly cook them or mix them enough. Not quite a true NY bagel but it was adequate. My co-worker had an egg sandwich. Asked for scrambled and at best it was over easy with a broken yoke. Hardly call that scrambled. More like lazy. Wouldn’t put this spot that high on a list but would eat here again as it was clean and friendly people
… moreJames Canale
Fantastic experience every Sunday morning. They have the most delicious pastries, the coffee is always brewing and of top quality. Most importantly, the chicken cutlets are the best I have ever had; always fresh and delicious. Many delis have sub par chicken cutlets, but this place has the absolute best!! Totally recommended.
… moreAnnMarie Pszybylski
VERY grateful to Brian for waiting after closing for me to pick up my order. Not a good week for a multitude of reasons and I forgot I placed my order for pick up. I called, he said no worries, if not today another time I can pick up a replacement order. THIS is why I travel there. So kind, accommodating and always a kind word. And let’s not forget the yummy bagels. ALWAYS a hit in my household. Oodles of thanks Bagels Your Way, we will be back.
… more